Star Trek: Voyager

Fourth Season Recap

For episodes airing from 9/3/1997 to 5/20/1998
Series created by Rick Berman & Michael Piller & Jeri Taylor
Executive producers: Rick Berman & Jeri Taylor

Review by Jamahl Epsicokhan

Another year, another season of Voyager in the books. It looks like it's time for the annual recap and retrospective. What was this season all about? What did the subtraction of one cast member and the addition of another mean to the outlook of the series? Such questions will be addressed in this season review, which, as always, I'll hype as "the most comprehensive Voyager review I'll write this year." Part one has a brief take on each episode. Part two is the general commentary on the "big picture." Pretty simple, so let's proceed, shall we?

Part 1: Capsule Reviews

To see the rankings and 10-scale ratings for this season's episodes, click here.

Scorpion, Part IIAir date: 9/3/1997. Written by Brannon Braga & Joe Menosky. Directed by Winrich Kolbe.

"Scorpion, Part II" was a good way to launch the fourth season. The combination of Trekkian adventure, character conflict between Janeway and Chakotay, and the intriguing, well-utilized thematic elements involving the nefarious Borg collective was balanced well, making for a story that competently resolved the elements set up in the first half. Still, the largeness of part one made it very difficult for part two to pull everything together without it all feeling a bit too easy. A lot of the story elements had a downside: Harry's recovery was almost laughably easy, Janeway and Chakotay's conflict was resolved with an argument that was too lightweight, and the use of the super technology to defeat Species 8472 didn't go very far beyond the expected. But "Scorpion II' is solid science fiction, which sits pretty well with me.

Rating: 3 stars

The GiftAir date: 9/10/1997. Written by Joe Menosky. Directed by Anson Williams.

After bringing Seven of Nine on board in "Scorpion II," "The Gift" went on to send her in the direction that would encompass a great deal of the rest of Voyager's fourth season. In that regard, this episode was effective, featuring the painful moments for a single drone who had been disconnected from its hive. The scenes between Janeway and Seven are incredibly taut and intriguing; both Mulgrew's and Ryan's performances shone in the initial outing for what would become the most intriguing character relationship of the season. On the flip side was the loss of Kes, who is written off the show in a disappointingly ineffective manner that comes off as arbitrary and incomprehensible (and packaged with a silly "action" finale). There wasn't nearly enough closure between Kes and the other characters. But using Janeway as the core of the Voyager "family" was nicely done, as she offers her sense of maternal wisdom to both Kes and Seven.

Rating: 3 stars

Day of HonorAir date: 9/17/1997. Written by Jeri Taylor. Directed by Jesus Salvador Trevino.

The most intriguing aspect of "Day of Honor" was the way it paired up Paris and Torres by way of an extreme situation (that is, stranded out in space as they run out of oxygen). The situation itself was a bit of a cliché, but Torres was especially well-characterized in her scenes with Paris; the idea that she can't come clean about her feelings, building up walls of self-defense in the process, is very in tune with B'Elanna's personality. Aside from the romance angle, there isn't much here. The use of some stock-issue aliens called the Cataati as a 20th-century analogy of impoverished people turning to crime is reasonable but not very compelling, especially given the ineffectively bland-to-bizarrely-quirky performance of the primary Cataati guest star.

Rating: 2.5 stars

NemesisAir date: 9/24/1997. Written by Kenneth Biller. Directed by Alexander Singer.

A turn to the more cerebral side of Trek was the focus for one of the few Chakotay-oriented episodes of the season. The theme is certainly reliable, if derivative, as it serves as an indictment on hatred and violence. The story is slow-moving but effective in the long run, with some nice details of war cruelty. The idea of "brainwashing" worked reasonably well by challenging the commonplace dramatic assumption that it's easy to label someone the "good guys" and the others the "bad guys." The finale, where the situation is resolved but Chakotay still can't get past his lingering inner-hatred, also sends a strong statement. The execution isn't standout, but the story is certainly interesting and socially respectable overall.

Rating: 3 stars

RevulsionAir date: 10/1/1997. Written by Lisa Klink. Directed by Kenneth Biller.

There's not a whole lot worthy of being said about "Revulsion," for good or ill. It's a standard plot with some interesting snippets of dialog. The performances by Picardo, Dawson, and Leland Orser (as Dejaran, the crazy, tortured hologram looking for vengeance) worked reasonably. The story itself is predictable and relies on stock thriller conventions, lacking a fresh slant on its material. Characteristically, Doc's non-reaction to Dejaran's eventual demise is a particularly evident weakness. As for the Seven-and-Harry B-story—it's amiable and forgettable. In fact, the entire episode is an hour-long diversion that can be quickly forgotten afterward. There are some enjoyable little character moments spread across the episode, but it isn't quite enough to give the episode much in terms of relevant context.

Rating: 2.5 stars

The RavenAir date: 10/8/1997. Teleplay by Bryan Fuller. Story by Harry Doc Kloor and Bryan Fuller. Directed by LeVar Burton.

Somewhere inside the so-so "Raven" is a better episode trying to get out. Sure, there's a plentiful cache of interesting backstory for Seven here, as it shows the circumstances surrounding her assimilation all those years ago, but it's constantly at the mercy of such a tired array of plot pieces, including the typical Hard-Headed Aliens of the Week™, who push Janeway so far that I was hoping she would punch one of them. Of course, after Seven flees the ship in search of answers, the Hard-Headed Aliens are a source of counterfeit conflict every step of the way in response to Janeway's attempted diplomacy—right down to the obligatory action finale. That's too bad, because I liked the backstory for Seven (even if it's highly unlikely that the crew would happen upon her old ship), and Tuvok and Seven work well together. Levar Burton's use of imagery was also compelling stuff, although I still don't buy the "symbolism" angle of a psychological connection between "Raven, the bird" and "Raven, the ship."

Rating: 2.5 stars

Scientific MethodAir date: 10/29/1997. Teleplay by Lisa Klink. Story by Sherry Klein & Harry Doc Kloor. Directed by David Livingston.

After a solid opening stretch, Voyager took its first major stumble of the season with a completely plot-oriented episode that relied on preposterous Fun With DNA™. The episode wasn't completely intolerable, mostly because it chose not to take itself too seriously and is punctuated by some interesting moments of manic energy (most notably, Janeway in crazy mode as she goes over the edge and pilots the ship between the two stars, and the opening sophomoric goofiness—silly as it was—of Paris and Torres making out all over the ship), but the plot was so jerry-rigged and disconnected that it felt like an episode written by a committee of people, each on a different controlled substance of choice. The end result is not pretty, and falls into serious disarray under any scrutiny. It all grows very tedious, with characters who are jerked around, thus coming off as unwitting plot pawns rather than people.

Rating: 1.5 stars

Year of Hell, Part IAir date: 11/5/1997. Written by Brannon Braga & Joe Menosky. Directed by Allan Kroeker.

Back in "Before and After," the idea of a year of desperation was intriguing. Here it became interesting for very different reasons. The hope that "Year of Hell" would work as a dark and probing drama vanished almost as soon as the Krenim made their first appearance. In place of that hope came the complex time-manipulation games brought about by Annorax and his time ship. It makes for some solid sci-fi, and Annorax's quiet obsession is the most intriguing angle (thanks to a strong performance by Kurtwood Smith). The Voyager crew's lengthy problem also worked reasonably, with some nice character details and another revisit to the Janeway Family Theme™. As a setup, "Year of Hell, Part I" was solid, entertaining stuff.

Rating: 3 stars

Year of Hell, Part IIAir date: 11/12/1997. Written by Brannon Braga & Joe Menosky. Directed by Mike Vejar.

The dreaded Reset Button™ returned with a vengeance at the end of the "Year of Hell" wrap-up, but, really, anyone who didn't see it coming a week in advance (if not more) is probably naive. I could complain and nitpick and rip apart the time-manipulation paradoxes, but why? This episode was still very reasonable as a self-contained adventure, which is what Voyager is all about these days. Considering the interesting parallel between the tragic Annorax and the no-nonsense Janeway and the duality of their obsessions, as well as Chakotay's intriguing sympathy and understanding of Annorax's dilemma, this episode packs some respectable character-oriented punch alongside its adventure storytelling. The arbitrary reset ending was weak and unsatisfying, but I'm not going to complain too loudly. Maybe none of this two-parter actually "happened," but for once I really don't care.

Rating: 3 stars

Random ThoughtsAir date: 11/19/1997. Written by Kenneth Biller. Directed by Alexander Singer.

After an effects-laden two-parter, Voyager settled back into conventional Original Series format by visiting an alien world and analyzing a culture-shock problem when Torres has a violent thought which is transferred to one of the telepathic citizens, leading him to violently beat another person. "Random Thoughts" suffers occasionally from a campy nature; the death of Neelix's new "friend" is corny in execution, and the images of "ultraviolence" aren't all that effective. But the meaning behind what's on the screen comes across well, with a few higher-brow-than-usual statements about violent tendencies and dark inner-demons (including the notion of a "black market" for violent imagery). Gwynyth Walsh turns in an effective performance as Nimira, whose sincerity in tackling the growing problem is respectable, as is the chemistry between her and Tuvok. It wasn't a standout offering, but it certainly utilized many of Voyager's strengths well.

Rating: 3 stars

Concerning FlightAir date: 11/26/1997. Teleplay by Joe Menosky. Story by Jimmy Diggs and Joe Menosky. Directed by Jesus Salvador Trevino.

And then came this fluff piece, which hung on a silly premise about some random aliens who steal the Voyager computer core. The setup is no more than an excuse for a lot of irrelevant exposition between Janeway and Leonardo da Vinci (a character who, despite Rhys-Davies' charisma, strikes me as a needless role to be wasting screen time on given the large cast this series has), who go down to a planet to track down the thieves. The plot is full of unlikely conveniences and stock action, and the arrogant presumption that a historical figure and all his knowledge can be dropped into a holographic program isn't something I particularly care for. By the end, especially with the obligatory flight in da Vinci's craft, the self-important creative narcissism behind the whole da Vinci/Janeway relationship becomes all too evident. The performances are quite watchable, but the episode is a needless endeavor too set on being cute and clever. It didn't work for me.

Rating: 2 stars

Mortal CoilAir date: 12/17/1997. Written by Bryan Fuller. Directed by Allan Kroeker.

This episode didn't leave the lasting impact I hoped it would. Neelix, naturally, is still one of the most shallow, pointless, and uninteresting major characters Trek has ever had, despite the Annual Serious Neelix Analysis™ that "Mortal Coil" provided. Nevertheless, this outing was sensible and utilized the side of Neelix we rarely see, offering issues of religious faith that Trek rarely explores. Watching Neelix come to terms with his crisis of doubt was surprisingly compelling, and the episode's use of imagery proves effective. Chakotay's role in the episode was also nice, especially the fact that his spiritual guidance offers "no quick fixes." Neelix's near-suicide was actually a moment of true suspense. But I sincerely wish the writers would find a purpose for this guy, because an episode like this, while good, shows how much of a bland cipher he is 99 percent of the time (and thus isn't consistent with the "big picture" of his character).

Rating: 3 stars

Waking MomentsAir date: 1/14/1998. Written by Andre Bormanis. Directed by Alexander Singer.

In my original review of this episode, I called it "the epitome of so-so," which I think still stands. The crew's dreams become the topic of another plot-heavy episode, which brings about a sometimes-entertaining but thin story about aliens who take over the ship in a collective crew dream. It's the second-best Chakotay episode of the season (which, unfortunately, doesn't say much considering he only had three shows and one of them was "Unforgettable")—this episode managed to show him competently taking action, which is rare these days. Unfortunately, there isn't much about the plot that is fresh; the story is often too mechanical in its plot advances, and the motivation for the aliens, who exist in an unlikely dream state, is about one step shy of total incredulity—proving to make them yet another alien race who exists simply to provide a forced conflict. Keeping the episode in the realm of "okay" is some good "moon imagery" and a few twists where we aren't sure whether Chakotay is awake or dreaming. But these touches aren't enough to make the episode wholly worthwhile.

Rating: 2.5 stars

Message in a BottleAir date: 1/21/1998. Written by Lisa Klink. Directed by Nancy Malone.

In some ways, "Message in a Bottle" is an extremely frustrating episode. Don't get me wrong—it works on many more levels than it fails on. In particular, it's a great example of the season's overriding sense of fun; it's an action comedy that gets the job done very nicely, with the constantly flabbergasted EMH programs portrayed by Robert Picardo and Andy Dick in way over their heads, where they trade one-liners and kick some Romulan butt (well, sort of). The USS Prometheus is a neat ship with ambitious production design (even if a fully automated "vector assault mode" is pushing it). But, as the pivotal episode where the crew of the Voyager finally gets a message back to the Alpha Quadrant and realize they are "no longer alone," having such an important issue shoved to the back burner like an afterthought is simply wrong. If the writers can't take this huge issue seriously, how in the world can we? For what it is—a balance of entertaining cartoon and drama—"Message" is very effective … but there's also a lot of wasted potential.

Rating: 3 stars

HuntersAir date: 2/11/1998. Written by Jeri Taylor. Directed by David Livingston.

And then "Hunters" did it again. If we have an unprecedented episode where a lot of screen time is devoted to crew members receiving letters from their Alpha Quadrant ties, why in the world do we need a subplot where Tuvok and Seven are captured by the Hirogen? If that wasn't bad enough, we've got the most cartoon-acted Hirogen "characters" ever, who yell and growl and look really dumb. No, thanks. Transparent use of Harry and Neelix doesn't help much (and don't even get me started on what turned out to be in the "mysterious Starfleet message" that the crew receives). Fortunately, much of the letter-receiving angle of the story works extremely well, as Janeway finds out her fiancee hae has moved on while Chakotay and Torres learn the Maquis have been wiped out—the first mention of the Maquis in a very long time (and a very welcome one, at that). The Paris angle, if a bit rehashed, was reasonable. But the episode left me thirsting for more. Call my bottom-line verdict a guarded recommendation.

Rating: 3 stars

PreyAir date: 2/18/1998. Written by Brannon Braga. Directed by Allan Eastman.

Four episodes (five, if you count "Message in a Bottle") featured the Hirogen, and "Prey" was probably the only good use of them. Like many of the better Trek outings, this episode drops Janeway into the middle of a tricky moral dilemma when an individual from Species 8472 seeks safety from Hirogen hunters on board Voyager. Trek has always been good at humanizing past enemies, and here it puts an unexpected spin on an old conflict, going so far as to make an 8472 pitiable. Just about every element in "Prey" works, and works well. On the technical level, Allan Eastman's direction is good stuff, with suspense that's well above average. Meanwhile, Tony Todd's presence offers the first believable Hirogen character. But what really sets this episode apart is its decision to introduce a fiery conflict caused by the clash of opinions between Janeway and Seven. The latter's decision to sacrifice the 8472 to save the ship is a gutsy move by the writers, and the consequences bring forth challenges for both characters. Intriguing arguments all around make this one of the season's best (and the best in terms of Voyager's current goals)—an episode that had me genuinely involved.

Rating: 3.5 stars

RetrospectAir date: 2/25/1998. Teleplay by Bryan Fuller & Lisa Klink. Story by Andrew Shepard Price & Mark Gaberman. Directed by Jesus Salvador Trevino.

Seven continued to be the core of the season in an episode where plot and character are nicely interwoven to emphasize the consequences of Janeway & Co. being on the wrong side of a judgment call while trying to protect one of their own. True, the plot is a bit convenient in execution at times. In particular, Kovin's extreme reaction to being accused runs just a little too haywire; that he would ultimately accidentally blow himself up is a bit much. But the story keeps its focus on character. Watching Doc vie for justice is compelling, particularly the way he fires up Seven's anger in the process of convincing her she has been wronged. Picardo and Ryan are both terrific as two people who get caught up in prematurely presuming Kovin's guilt as they struggle with embracing their own humanity. Their regret in the final scenes following the tragedy is particularly well conceived. "Retrospect" is a winner that uses its characters wisely.

Rating: 3 stars

The Killing Game, Part IAir date: 3/4/1998. Written by Brannon Braga & Joe Menosky. Directed by David Livingston.

The first half of the deadly-Hirogen-holodeck-games two-parter was all setup and no payoff, and on those terms it was okay. David Livingston's pace over the story took a relaxed pace, allowing the story to unfold on agreeable terms, although there were some questionable elements. While the technology that transforms the characters' identities strikes me as a convenient device for gratuitous role-playing, I did find some of the details of the WWII setting somewhat entertaining, and it was interesting to see the various personalities (most notably Tuvok's, Janeway's, and Seven's) carry over into the holodeck characters. The introduction of a Hirogen character who wants to preserve his endangered society through holodeck usage is also a palatable idea. But the setup as a stand-alone outing wasn't consistently solid enough to be worthy of a recommendation, and spilling WWII onto the decks of the ship didn't exactly leave me enthralled.

Rating: 2.5 stars

The Killing Game, Part IIAir date: 3/4/1998. Written by Brannon Braga & Joe Menosky. Directed by Victor Lobl.

"Killing Game II" was an exercise in manic plot-induced excess, and a lot of it simply became boring. Gunfire and more gunfire punctuated endless scenes of holograms fighting each other with holographic ammunition (what could be more pointless?). The historical perspective of the entire setting is rendered all but irrelevant, and the only interesting Hirogen character is killed off in an unsatisfying manner, reducing the audience's stake in the Hirogen problem to null. The truce at the end prompts incredulity. The only reason to see this episode is the same as the sole reason to go see the new Godzilla movie: if you want a sorry excuse for a story as a means to propel mindless destruction on a grand scale. On that level, I guess, this episode delivers … if you like seeing the holodeck and sickbay blown up with no regard to consequences. "The damage to Voyager has been extreme," says Janeway. But who even cares since it will all be reset to normal by the next episode?

Rating: 2 stars

Vis A VisAir date: 4/8/1998. Written by Robert J. Doherty. Directed by Jesus Salvador Trevino.

The vis-a-vis in "Vis A Vis" occurs with a literal body-switching experience for Paris when an alien named Steth steals Tom's identity in exchange for his own. The premise is a high concept, but there's surprisingly little done with it, keeping the story firmly rooted in the realm of the mediocre. Steth does a number on Paris, Torres, and then Janeway, but several character consequences of Steth's deception (most notably, his seduction of B'Elanna) are never addressed, and the plot doesn't take enough risks. The most interesting acting possibilities (imagine Robert Duncan McNeill as Kathryn Janeway!) are left untouched. What hurts here most, though, is the misuse of Tom in the early scenes, where he experiences an identity crisis that emerges from virtually nowhere, and then bites B'Elanna's head off for no apparent reason in a scene of alarming juvenility. The characterization of Paris here is a rehash at best, and unconvincing regression at worst.

Rating: 2 stars

The Omega DirectiveAir date: 4/15/1998. Teleplay by Lisa Klink. Story by Jimmy Diggs & Steve J. Kay. Directed by Victor Lobl.

Now here's an example of the right way to do a tech plot. While the idea of the omega molecule is so big that it opens a dangerous can of worms, the use of that bigness motivates Janeway and the crew rather nicely, going so far as to rescind even the Prime Directive. Issues of trust come to the forefront, and the largeness of the problem adds a level of high-stakes excitement. It's probably one of the most solid plot-based sci-fi-oriented outings this season (although I'm still a bit confused about whether the molecule can be created at will given the effort of production, or if it has to be found to be replicated). Good use of Janeway/Seven highlights Seven further accepting her social limits, and the final realization—a spiritual moment for our former Borg—is a wonderfully intriguing character touch.

Rating: 3 stars

UnforgettableAir date: 4/22/1998. Written by Greg Elliot & Michael Perricone. Directed by Andrew J. Robinson.

The final stretch of episodes continued its up-and-down trend with the ironically titled "Unforgettable," an episode that shows how not to do romance on Trek (perhaps the Voyager equivalent of DS9's "Meridian"). We have two characters exchanging bland dialog, who fall in love in a manner that is hardly believable and completely lacking in any sense of chemistry. It's a shame that Chakotay has been reduced to a character of such apparently indifferent dispassion. (By the way, dispassion is not a way to approach a romance story.) The idea of a people who can't be remembered strikes me as a little implausible, and the episode never seems to understand how its own rules work, but I'm more frustrated that the plot isn't put to any use beyond the most obvious and predictable (not to mention the built-in, self-acknowledged reset button). There's very little here, and what's here is so pedestrian that the hour grows incredibly dull.

Rating: 1.5 stars

Living WitnessAir date: 4/29/1998. Teleplay by Bryan Fuller and Brannon Braga & Joe Menosky. Story by Brannon Braga. Directed by Tim Russ.

Ranking up there among the best hours Voyager has ever done is "Living Witness," an example of great Trek that doesn't use the particular series' strengths to its advantage, but rather exists outside the normal confines of the Voyager reality. (DS9's "Trials and Tribble-ations" comes to mind as a similar one-shot wonder.) It's an original, absorbing story that takes a fresh perspective, works up a nice sense of wonder, has the reasonable and sympathetic central character of Quarren (effectively portrayed by Henry Woronicz), puts Doc in a sticky situation where the moral stakes run deeper than the safety and image of the Voyager crew, and uses "evil crew" role-playing in a way that is both entertaining and dramatically sound. The only significant flaw—the idea of a "Doctor backup program," which seems to go against everything previously established about his existence—is still a mentionable drawback that opens up an annoying can of worms, but it's not nearly enough to bring down this impressive installment. Nice work.

Rating: 4 stars

DemonAir date: 5/6/1998. Teleplay by Kenneth Biller. Story by Andre Bormanis. Directed by Anson Williams.

Coming off the heels of the season's best episode came the season's worst, which is probably the worst episode of Voyager since "Threshold." The setup premise of "running out of fuel" was hopelessly arbitrary, conjured, and absurd (not to mention a demonstration of a total lack of competency among the entire crew), leading to even more preposterous absurdity and the worst use of Trek "science" I've seen in a very long time. Deuterium shortage? People who don't fry at 500K? Half-sentient liquid metal? Please. None of this makes sense if you think about it for a microsecond, and it's so chock-full of self-contradictory plot holes that it's difficult even to keep track of them. Add all that to a terribly unfunny B-story that makes Neelix look sillier than he has in years, and a forced notion where Harry suddenly becomes "more assertive" (which might've worked if it weren't so blatantly obvious) and you have an example of science fiction near its worst.

Rating: 0.5 stars

OneAir date: 5/13/1998. Written by Jeri Taylor. Directed by Kenneth Biller.

Plot holes abound in "One." How did the crew fail to detect the nebula until they were standing right next to it? Where did all those stasis chambers come from? How could Paris survive after climbing out of his stasis chamber? How did cutting life support deplete all oxygen on the ship in 30 seconds? I really don't care. This episode was set on saying something about its central character, and I liked what it had to say. It made for a good analysis of Seven's dual needs for independence and the presence of others, and serves as a possible turning point in her opinion of socializing. The narrative was excessive at times; by the end Seven's hallucinated images proved almost too pervasive as the story drove its points home with a sledgehammer (and I could've done without the alien intruder as a red herring), but this has something substantive to say about a character who has been an integral part of much of this season's successful elements. Me likes.

Rating: 3 stars

Hope and FearAir date: 5/20/1998. Teleplay by Brannon Braga & Joe Menosky. Story by Rick Berman & Brannon Braga & Joe Menosky. Directed by Winrich Kolbe.

Was I expecting the crew to actually get home? Not really. Was I expecting some sort of progress to come out of this episode? Perhaps. Did I want the entire episode to be another example of how to reset all possible progress back to zero? Certainly not. "Hope and Fear" is a plot that apparently exists to toy with us, making us care about a problem and open our minds to a possibility just so the writers can say, "Sorry, but none of this is what it seems." I can see where they were going with some of this (Janeway's skepticism concerning the whole matter helps), but the plot uses far too many contrivances so that the clues can be read two ways. It's sneaky and manipulative and I don't like it. What's the point of a story that baits our interest with a ruse only to show us how elaborate that ruse can be? The notion of an encrypted message that just says "sorry, you're stuck" is dubious at best (I don't care if it had "information about the Delta Quadrant" in it, because that's a lackluster way to resolve a potentially interesting mystery), and the alien's faux Federation ship is simply too perfect in detail to come off as anything but a product of a skilled TV production design staff. On the upside we have some wonderful Janeway/Seven character work that supplies the bookend for the season, phenomenal production values, good use of the Borg as closure, and a genuine sense of wonder. It's too bad that wonder is conjured out of an alien plot that strains so much credibility that I slowly became aware I was watching writers plan a calculated course of failure for the Voyager crew. The episode earns several points for characterization, showmanship, and plotting ingenuity, but it earns several dozen demerits for convenience and deception.

Rating: 2 stars

Part 2: Season Analysis

Lately I have been struggling over a question, a question that I have been trying very hard to answer but still, after four seasons, cannot come up with a definite answer for. That question is: What is Star Trek: Voyager all about? If I asked that question back in season one, I think I would've had an answer for what I thought Voyager was and would become, but that answer has long since been rendered obsolete. The series changed direction and purpose somewhere during the second season and has never looked back. Now, change isn't necessarily a bad thing, especially seeing as season two did a lot of things wrong with the setup premise established in the first season. But seasons three and four have proven over and over again that Voyager is a series that tends to wander and wander—and I'm not sure where exactly it's wandering to.

Maybe that's part of the point. Maybe we're just supposed to tune in to see what unforeseeable problem the Voyager characters run into each week and how they solve it—sort of like the point of The Original Series. Maybe Star Trek: Voyager is simply The Original Series reconceived for a 1990s television market. Maybe wandering blindly into the unknown is all there is to it. After all, Voyager has without a doubt become a series that is sold on entertaining for one hour at a time (whether I happen to agree with that method of storytelling or not). Nearly every episode this season was a self-contained story that any new viewer could tune into and probably fully comprehend without feeling the need to go back and look up backstory. It's all about simple adventure—about what you can find when wandering in the unknown.

But there's a dangerous pitfall in taking that attitude, I think, which is that there's already a lot of Star Trek material out there. If you count all of the four series' episodes, the number is rapidly approaching 500 hour-long episodes (a number the franchise will surpass almost immediately next season), not to mention the soon-to-be nine feature films. We've done TOS. And we've done TNG. So it seems to me that Voyager needs to be more than TOS or TNG projected into the Delta Quadrant. But without its own plot arcs or identity, Voyager puts itself in danger of becoming simply TOS or TNG revisited, which I think is potential left disappointingly unrealized. Voyager needs to be more than a series of occasional one-shot wonders filled with pedestrian adventures in between. An approach similar to DS9's over the years strikes me as a suitable one. I'm not saying DS9 is infallible or even close (this season of DS9 has had its own notable problems), but I am saying that episode-to-episode trends that at least claim to pay respect to consequences and build on prior events are something that we need to see a lot more of.

But we need more than trends; we need trends that utilize the important aspects of Voyager as a series. Again and again I have to ask myself: Just why is Voyager in the Delta Quadrant? What are we finding in the Delta Quadrant that we couldn't, essentially, find anywhere? Beyond the most basic elements of dialog and storytelling, what is being said about this ship and crew that couldn't be done in the Alpha Quadrant? Who are we meeting out here that brings anything new to the human question? How is the crew reacting to the prospect of being alone for 60 years? The unavoidable and most truthful answers to those questions, in order, are: I'm not sure, not very much, nothing of consequence, nobody to speak of, and they aren't. I don't understand the appeal of this premise if it refuses to acknowledge the most important dramatic advantages that it could bring to the series. In short, Voyager is not playing to its strengths about being a ship that needs to fight for survival. And it's also not exploring the unknown—it's exploring the derivative under a pretense of the unknown.

Now, I hate to sound like a broken record (because I feel like I've been saying the same thing for the past three years now), but in order for Voyager to succeed (and I do want to see it succeed, contrary to those people who allege that I "hate" the show, which I don't), I think someone needs to take a closer, more serious look at what being stranded is all about. Being stranded does not mean dropping in an occasional line about replicator rations, searching for food, or, worst of all, the idea that we've suddenly run out of fuel ("Demon") when fuel is an issue that hasn't even been acknowledged for years. Being stranded does not mean you trash half the ship—blowing up the holodeck, blowing up sickbay—and then write it off with a single line about damage to the ship being extreme ("The Killing Game"), never again to be considered even as an afterthought. Being stranded does not mean that when the characters do see a promising chance to get home ("Hope and Fear") and it doesn't pan out they simply shake their heads quietly and forget the opportunity was ever there. Being stranded does not mean losing crew members ("Scientific Method," "One," or the long-forgotten dead who are never acknowledged in "Message in a Bottle" or "Hunters" when the crew makes contact with their Alpha Quadrant ties) can be a subject treated as lightly as on TOS or TNG.

So, to sum up, I think that "wandering" is not enough. There has to be a context, and there must be goals. Yes, I know that Janeway and her crew are trying to get home, but it seems to me that the rewards and failures of the journey are more often used as a product of plot convenience packaged in the form of twisted fortune (or misfortune) than it is a credible dramatic device. To date, the most significant progress the crew has had in finding a faster way to the Alpha Quadrant has been the magical farewell gift from Kes that threw them 10,000 light-years in 10 seconds ("The Gift"). Honestly, it doesn't say a whole lot to me when the crew goes through a grueling hour of "hope in check" only to realize they're only going to gain 300 light-years ("Hope and Fear"), yet can gain 10,000 light-years under almost arbitrary circumstances. This doesn't say to me that survival, determination, and ingenuity will get Voyager home; it says to me that magical circumstances that emerge from the most unlikely and contrived of places will. Dramatically, I see that as a problem, and that's why "Hope and Fear" left me so cold. Sure, there was some nice character work, but in a season finale you almost expect the producers will supply a story that demonstrates what the series is all about. If the series is about getting home, then maybe some progress toward that goal would be prudent if we're going to sit through a plot that tantalizes us about that goal for 40 minutes. Even 5,000 or 10,000 more light-years might've supplied the crew with a sense of renewed hope.

But single-hour "fun," while entertaining (as many hours of this season have been), is not enough to get the job done on a drama series—at least, not for me. I think there needs to be more emphasis on creating a common stream of thought that can be seen throughout a season. There has to be an overriding purpose lurking somewhere behind 26 plot-based sci-fi adventures. I'm not at all saying that the series has to be an elaborate, interconnected web of episodes telling a single story. But there has to be purpose somewhere in all these plots, and I don't feel that a purpose is evident. Part of the problem is that some of the characters seem to exist more to get the plot from one point to the next than they exist to be people. In a big way, this season has been bipolar when it comes to characterization. This has been a year featuring some of the best character-oriented episodes and arcs in the entire series' run, but also featuring some of the biggest lapses in terms of using characters as people instead of plugging them into a plot to move a story along.

So what is it that I do want to see? Well, I want to see people taking actions and having to live with the consequences. I want to see that the crew is at least in partial control of their own fate rather than being the unwitting subjects of a coin-toss situation manufactured by the writers. I like to see characters evolve and learn from their pasts. I like to see characters who represent a point of view. In short, I like people who have identities and opinions and who are not simply a writer's pawns.

On one front, this season of Voyager has displayed some of precisely what I want to see, and, with its best character work to date, shows exactly what could make this a solid series. I'm referring, of course, to Seven of Nine, whose controversial introduction into the cast back at the beginning of the season had some skeptics suspicious and angry, especially with the reports that Jennifer Lien was canned in favor of a co-star with more sex appeal (reports which I'm neither confirming nor denying, because I honestly don't know the circumstances surrounding Jennifer Lien's departure). I'll be the first to admit that the series has shifted significantly to telling mostly "Seven of Nine" stories, often at the expense of other characters who get relatively little screen time as a result. Many feared that Worf's addition to DS9's cast in its fourth season would overshadow the rest of the characters, which turned out not to be the case since he was used as part of the ensemble. On the other hand, those who feared Jeri Ryan's addition to this cast would cause the focus to keep landing on the same character rather than being spread around equally probably had a reason for concern. I doubt I would argue with anyone who claims this series right now is "Star Trek: Voyager starring Kate Mulgrew and Jeri Ryan."

But Jeri Ryan has proven that she is a talented actress and the writing staff has such a handle on this character that, hell, I'm glad when I see a trailer that reveals next week's episode will be another Seven story. While I still think her conveniently form-fitting outfit is an annoying sign of what her sole original appeal might've been, Jeri Ryan and the writers have proven that Seven is much, much more than a token Borg character with a great body. (Still, I personally wish her outfit would be replaced with a Starfleet uniform, symbolically linking her to the "family" once and for all, but that probably won't ever happen since it would be too risky in perceived ratings terms to potentially abandon viewers who do watch the show because of the "Borg Babe.") Seven represents the age-old "humanity question" that has always been at the core of Trek, whether it was Spock, Data, Odo, or the Doctor, and the character's growth this season has been consistent, compelling, and very entertaining. It's the perfect example of how to use characters as people and personalities, rather than as caricatures or plot pieces. The balance of tension and guarded understanding between Janeway and Seven has proven over and over again to be something on this series that is worth watching, and there has always been the sense that just as Seven is learning from Janeway, Janeway is also learning from Seven more about those very issues centering around the "human question." (Although, sometimes it gets a little more black-and-white than I would care for, making Janeway too often rigidly "right.") Seven has brought a lot of multi-episodic character-oriented storytelling to this season—something I haven't seen done effectively since the first season when all the characters were still new.

But while Seven and Janeway have kept this season interesting and focused, I have some serious doubts about where other characters are headed, assuming they're headed anywhere. It's perhaps a telling sign that the loss of Kes at the beginning of the season had almost no impact on the series. With all due respect to Jennifer Lien's admirable talents, if characters aren't complex or essential they probably won't be missed … and I frankly don't miss Kes much at all. In strictly utilitarian terms, the loss of Kes in favor of Seven of Nine has been a blessing on Voyager. Unfortunately, it makes me wonder just how essential some of these characters are to the series, particularly Harry Kim (a.k.a. "Ensign Former-Green") and Neelix (a.k.a. "Talaxian Chump"). Harry's decision to become "more assertive" ("Demon") was so blatantly spoon-fed that someone should've just posted a sign on Garret Wang's forehead prior to filming that said, "CHARACTER CHANGE IN PROGRESS." Even though I didn't like the way the change was brought about, it might prove worthwhile if it's handled believably next season, but such a follow-up is essential … and I've been burned by such follow-up hopes too many times (Doc's holo-family from "Real Life" comes to mind as an example). Harry Kim cannot continue to be the shallow Ensign Green; he needs meatier stories with an edge. The same goes double, if not septuple, for Neelix, a constant trouble point when it comes to characterization, mainly because he has no discernible purpose. He is or has been everything from "cook" to "morale officer" to "talk-show host" to "ambassador," and never (since first season, before he became the obligatory comic relief character) has any of it been remotely interesting. His only reasonable story this season was "Mortal Coil," which, really, had nothing to do with who he typically is.

Harry and Neelix have always been problematic; what worries me more is Chakotay, who I'd say has severely received the short end of the stick this season. I've always liked Chakotay (even if Robert Beltran is sometimes a little more low key than I'd like) but this year he has become a bland source of often-blind moral support for Janeway and little more. "Nemesis" was good, and "Waking Moments" had him taking some action for a change, but ever since he and Janeway reached that agreement in "Scorpion, Part II," Chakotay has been surprisingly devoid of opinion, insight, or personality—just when I thought we were getting somewhere when "Scorpion" showed that these two aren't always on the same page. I like his low-key humor and ability to understate situations, but what happened to the passion and will? Virtually gone. Instead we have a cold, calculating, and procedure-oriented Chakotay (a la "Unforgettable"), who no longer seems to have a set of opinions or agendas. His role is simply to be a confidant for Janeway (or, as someone said to me in a tongue-in-cheek e-mail, his role is to say, "Yez ma'am. Whutevah you sez, ma'am"). Being a confidant is okay at times, but I'd much rather see what this guy is thinking and feeling, even if it means butting heads with Janeway.

When characterization becomes mechanical like it has had a tendency to do this season where Janeway and Seven aren't concerned, stories are completely dependent upon the ability of the plot to get the job done. And when plot is completely driving the series, it's going to have a tendency to cause hit-and-miss trends, particularly like the unevenness at the end of the season. This may explain why an episode like, say, "Vis A Vis" fails while an episode like "One" works. Both have plot holes, but because "One" has a clear character development goal in mind, it's easier to look past the flaws in the plot. "Vis A Vis," on the other hand, fails on plot and then has the problem of being completely confused in its assessment of its central character. Bottom line: When your story is all plot and completely self-contained, sometimes it will work and sometimes it won't. This is why we sometimes get one-shot wonders that literally exist outside the confines of Voyager reality ("Living Witness" and "Year of Hell," as obvious examples), and other times we'll get clunkers that are almost completely irrelevant ("Demon," "Scientific Method," "Unforgettable"). This season of Voyager has been good in that it has found a happy middle ground that has proven more consistent than past seasons. Most of the episodes fell in the 2.5- to 3-star range, with only a few clunkers at the 1.5-and-below area. At the same time, I haven't been blown away with many great episodes in the 3.5- or 4-star range. The only episodes I would qualify as absolute "must sees" would probably be "Living Witness" and "Prey," with "Scorpion II," "Retrospect" and "The Omega Directive" as the runners-up.

So what we have here is a respectably middling season of Voyager, which is okay, but could still be much improved upon. There's little shame in a 2.5-star-rated episode, because that means an episode is doing something right (even though I don't completely recommended it). But there's also no great pride in it, either. It's just adequate. And a steady diet of "simply adequate" can be frustrating. Even though Voyager is doing generally better than in seasons past, it still suffers from a lot of the same problems it had in those earlier seasons, the primary problem being that we aren't really making much notable progress.

The Delta Quadrant still isn't a very fascinating place, and is populated with too many stock alien races that exist solely for the sake of counterfeit conflict. Glib conflict doesn't often tell us much about the characters; it's more a device for standard action. (If I've learned anything about Voyager, I've learned that, so why haven't the creators?) Why can't we have more relationships with alien cultures who are (gasp!) peaceful and perhaps tell us a little something about ourselves? Why is everyone bent on taking over or destroying the ship? Surely there has to be someone out there with more depth than that. Conflict is about real problems, like those in "Living Witness," not about blowing up the bad guys with technobabble.

Just look at the Hirogen for a prime example. Here was a culture whose presence spanned six episodes and thus can be labeled the primary aliens of this season (if you don't count the Borg, which have been abundantly present in spirit). But since the Hirogen were pack hunters, their purpose most of the time was to seek out and destroy the starship Voyager, which simply isn't a fresh approach to alien encounters. Sometimes something interesting can be done with such a premise ("Prey" did a phenomenal job, and parts of "The Killing Game" were interesting, even if the episode itself was a big mess), but I've had enough of stock aliens that are so limited in motivation, and whose conceptions are so limited in imagination. If we're not going to analyze the realistic problems of being stranded (which I might as well give up on, since time after time the ship and crew takes a pounding and time after time it simply doesn't matter), we at least need to see something fresh and exciting out here in the vastness of the unknown. Why can't we be surprised? This is, after all, science fiction, with almost limitless possibilities. I say push the envelope.

I'm often critical of this series, but it's not out of anger; it's because I want to see Voyager live up to its potential rather than settling for so much less, which it has a tendency to do more often than not. Given its technical resources and cast talents, I think it's capable of putting out much more than it has to date. I think someone at the writing stage needs to step back and look at what more can be done aside from spinning the wheels from week to week. Risks must be taken. The status quo must occasionally be shattered. We have to feel like we're going somewhere. If we're going to find out what Voyager is all about, we need to know more about how characters other than what Janeway and Seven think and feel. Each of the characters needs more to do, and the writers need to set goals for them to strive toward. Voyager also needs to reiterate its mission statement, because if the crew is not going home for a long while, then we need for them to find more out here in the Delta Quadrant than convenient little devices which create a problem that can quickly be solved. One-shot wonders are fine and dandy, but a TV drama series is typically more than a hit-and-miss string of isolated little stories. We need to see a reason for Voyager to do what it does rather than just wandering into random situations. There needs to be a driving purpose, and it can start with character arcs. Janeway and Seven had character arcs this season; now it's time to extend this nature to everyone else—before it's too late.

Voyager is by no means a series to give up on, in my opinion. But nor is it something to be enthralled about. In general, it's shallow, one-hour entertainment. On those levels, it sometimes comes through, but I think it's high time that somebody looks at how Voyager can transcend the limits that have grown around it the past four seasons and make it worthwhile as a series. The key word is SERIES—a set of stories that have something to do with one another beyond having the same characters in each individual installment.

Maybe next season will be a SERIES instead of a collection of shows. Maybe not. With the end of the fourth season also came the end of Jeri Taylor's reign over the series. (I'd like to send out a kind farewell to a long-time Trek writer/producer who has, in my opinion, often been unfairly maligned here in the Internet realm, for reasons I still don't understand.) With Brannon Braga (who has been harshly targeted even more than Taylor, and just as unfairly) taking over the creative processes of the series I'm not sure if we'll see any significant changes or not, but I can hope that we'll see some interesting new things come out of season five, and perhaps more emphasis on long-term thinking. I'll be back in August to find out. See you then.

Previous: Season 3
Next: Season 5

◄ Season Index

19 comments on this post

Thu, Feb 25, 2010, 6:35pm (UTC -5)
Thoughts about Voyager as a series ...

My understanding is that Rick Berman wanted to keep standalone episodes where there were
charming characters that people would come back week after week to see: a kind of family you would invite into your living room. Here is a link to his quote on BBC:

Star Trek by the time of Voyager was a huge success, and did not need to take risks to prove itself. Newer shows like Xena, Firefly, or Battlestar Galactica needed to take risks to get attention.

Personally, I like having both series that are standalone and create a sense of family and series that push the envelope in looking at the dark side of human nature or taboos in our culture.

Thoughts about Voyager characters ...

The Doctor and Seven of Nine were terrific in scenes and episodes examining the human condition, the evolution of individuality and what morality is. Favorites include Lifesigns(S2) and Life Line(S6) for the Doctor, and The Gift (S4) and Survival Instinct(S6) for Seven.

Janeway/Chakotay had powerful scenes in Scorpion and Equinox, where their personalities clashed over command decisions, and I thought Chakotay made searing moral arguments and Janeway crossed the line.

Neelix, an eternal optimisit, could be annoying at times, or endearing, and I mostly chose the latter. If I could have more friends like Neelix in his discussion with Belanna in Day of Honor(S4), or his caring for Tuvok in Riddles(S6), I would be truely blessed. Neelix actually had some of the most intense and mulit-layered character dramas with episodes like Jetrel (S1) where he faces the man who designed the weapons that destroyed his world, and Mortal Coil(S4) where his indentity and purpose in life are nearly destroyed after a near-death experience.

Harry Kim has been considered the eternal chump, as well as the eternal ensign, on Voyager, but I suspect, that along with Neelix, he is disliked because he is not as strong or charismatic as characters like Chakotay or Tuvok. Harry is attached to his parents, and often gullible, and while these are not heroic character traits, they are certainly believable. While character growth was slow over 7 seasons, I would not say it was non-existent, with his relationships in The Disease(S5) and Ashes to Ashes (S6), and then his command of an alien ship in Nightingale(S7) and finally in the future, a captain in Endgame.
Thu, Nov 8, 2012, 4:27pm (UTC -5)
Your biggest complaint was that voyager was made of indepedent episode rather than long story arcs. I think you need to keep in mind that in the late 90s when people watched reruns of this show they did in on TV, not on bittorrent or Netflix or vod. So people who were not dilligant enough to watch every episode when it aired didn't want the episodes to be connected! This allowed watching random episodes of voyager - just like tos or tng - and enjoying them. I love this feature of voyager and many other series.
Mon, Dec 3, 2012, 12:38am (UTC -5)
While you are correct, nadav, that historical context is important, be aware that Jammer was reviewing these episodes when they first aired. This analysis was written in the late '90s, so Jammer was not using unfair hindsight. Serialization was not foreign to American prime-time TV during Voyager's run; the most popular show at the time Jammer posted this analysis, if I'm not mistaken, was ER, which was heavily serialized. Like Jammer, I wanted stronger continuity in Voyager even in the context of its original airing.
Latex Zebra
Fri, Dec 28, 2012, 10:10am (UTC -5)
I do recall watching this as it aired and thinking it was a massive improvement on previous seasons.

This is Voyager turning a corner.

Still never did enough charaxcter/event continuity.
Making sure that you can pick any episode up at anytime doesn't mean you have to treat the audience like morons.
Tue, Jan 15, 2013, 1:39pm (UTC -5)
THIS, for me, is one of the single best seasons of any Trek series for me. Along with season 5 which I love equally if not more, I didnt see many of the episodes on tv but I bought the dvds together. I found these two seasons incredibly consistent in quality, creativity and well as LARGEness in scale. There was a little bit of serialization. I,too, wish there was more but still, no doubt this was turning a corner for Voyager and ranks as among the best and most attractive for me in the whole Trek canon.
Jo Jo Meastro
Thu, May 16, 2013, 6:19am (UTC -5)
I'm going to try posting from my ps3, apologies in advance should the predictive text riddles my post with enough anomalies to make even Geordie La Forge blush! Anyway, I've been meaning to comment on season 4 of Voyager for a while but just never got round to it till now. I'd definitely say this season has been the strongest season of Voyager so far, with the amount of good episodes and the introduction of Seven Of Nine. I feel she's the one that's given this season a strong central core and she injected an unpredictable freshness and a respectable shake-up amongst the crew. I also enjoy the new angle given to Torress and Tom (fans will know what angle I'm talking about). I've enjoyed lots of season 4, hated some of it but all in all its been fun. I've long accepted what Voyager as a show has chosen to be in terms of tone and approach, its nothing amazing but with this season and last; at least it can still serve up plenty of good TV. After taking a break from Voyager I plan on starting season 5 pretty soon!
Ross TW
Sat, Jan 23, 2016, 6:26pm (UTC -5)
Doing a franchise re-watch and just finished Voyager's 4th Season. One of my fave seasons in Trek, and definitely the best of this particular series.

I forgot just how often Seven and Janeway fought in this season, but the tension is SO compelling. It provides a through-line for both characters, and they grow a lot in the process. Seven's a breath of fresh air that makes everyone she interacts with better. (Even Harry, who I've never disliked; I thought his crush on Seven was cute and realistic.)

I feel like there's a loose attempt at continuity here. Early on, Seven and Harry work on building Astrometrics for several episodes (and that set is awesome). There's the Hirogen, the letter from home, ramifications of the 8472/Borg conflict (followed up on in Prey and Hope & Fear). So ... I appreciated that a lot.

I felt like Janeway changed a whole lot this season. From 'Year of Hell' onward, she became notably more aggressive in her actions. Coincidentally or not, this coincides with her 'letting her hair down.' I wonder if the writers liked the Janeway they saw in 'Year of Hell' and just kept pushing her in that direction.

Epic, all-time episodes in S4, like 'Scorpion,' 'Year of Hell,' 'Prey,' 'Living Witness,' 'Message in a Bottle.'

Also, one of my favorite dialogue exchanges, between a Hirogen and Paris:

"I once tracked a silicon lifeform through the collapsed mantle of a neutron star."

"I once tracked a mouse through Jefferies Tube 32."

Love it.
Diamond Dave
Thu, Feb 18, 2016, 2:28pm (UTC -5)
This season turned out to be a crushing disappointment to me. After a slow start, we had a 12-episode run I scored at 2.5 and above, the longest in the 16 series I've watched so far. I was using the words fresh and innovative a lot, and it looked like the series had genuinely turned the corner.

And then we had The Killing Game two-parter... from that point on (yay, Nazis vs Klingons!) the last 8 episodes only managed an average of 1.81 in my scoring. So the series overall averaged out at 2.44, just a hair ahead of series 3 and behind 1 and 2 - or, put another way, ahead of only TNG series 1 and 2...

So it's sad that the middle season run shows that Voyager really can do compelling watching - it just can't do it consistently across a whole series. Perhaps for me this is where the lack of real continuity fails - if the individual episodes miss the mark then there's nothing to fall back on. And the promise set up by Scorpion was never fulfilled.

My main criticisms of the characters remain - too many are contributing nothing to the story. The Paris/Torres romance failed in my eyes to do anything for their stories. Chakotay, Neelix, Harry offer nothing either.

But ironically the thing that did work was bringing Seven in. Despite being something out of a teenage male fans wank fantasy, we actually did get some really compelling stories for Seven, all based on a strong performance from Jeri Ryan. It says something that Kes was not missed at all - and yet as I've repeatedly said I found Kes one of the more interesting characters up to now. It just shows there's not much competition there...
Mon, May 23, 2016, 8:43am (UTC -5)
Here are my Voyager Season 4 rankings.

Episode Name / Rating
Scorpion Part 2 / 3.50
The Gift / 3.50
Day of Honor / 3.50
Nemesis / 3.50
Revulsion / 3.00
The Raven / 3.00
Scientific Method / 4.00
Year of Hell / 3.50
Random Thoughts / 2.50
Concerning Flight / 1.50
Mortal Coil / 1.00
Waking Moments / 2.50
Message in a Bottle / 3.00
Hunters / 3.00
Prey / 4.00
Retrospect / 2.00
The Killing Game / 1.00
Vis a Vis / 2.50
The Omega Directive / 3.50
Unforgettable / 2.50
Living Witness / 4.00
Demon / 1.50
One / 3.00
Hope and Fear / 3.00

Average: 2.84

One of Voyager's (if not trek's) best seasons. The addition of Seven of Nine was huge and while I didn't really want to see Kes go (should have been Harry) - it was the right decision. Jeri nails the part and they seem to really enjoy giving her great stuff.

Only three 4-star episodes, but only four stinkers. Overall quality of this season was outstanding. Some truly great trek in there.

I rated DS9 S5 a 2.88 which I thought was DS9's finest.

I know Voyager S5 is good, it will be interesting to see how it ranks out.
Sat, Jul 1, 2017, 4:56am (UTC -5)
While I would also have appreciated more story arcs, that's no reason to constantly berate this shoe. They are travelling home at high warp, they are going to leave many of their consequences behind. Audiences seem to constantly clamour for shows which "boldly go" which is one reason why DS9 is the least popular Trek, despite being the best. Voyager was delivering exactly what Trek fans moan that they want. That's exactly what TOS, TNG and, later, ENT would deliver. I don't recall any of those shows having overreaching arcs or consequences or character growth either. But that's OK because they're not Voyager.
Jason R.
Sat, Jul 1, 2017, 6:57am (UTC -5)
Nopoet, TNG and TOS could get away with a reset button every week because they took place in the Federation where resources were unlimited and dead crew, smashed shuttles, holes in the hull and other detritus could be swept clean without consequence to the story. Not so with Voyager, stranded 70,000 light years from the nearest starbase or gas station.

Voyager's premise was incompatible with a reset button. Contrary to what you said, it was a show that needed continuity. Seeing the Voyager, shiny and perfect, sailing through space with its professional starfleet crew each week was an insult to the audience's intelligence and a waste of the premise. If all they wanted to do was have an alien / anomaly of the week they could have just done it in the alpha quadrant, a la TNG.
Sat, Jul 1, 2017, 9:46am (UTC -5)
"TNG and TOS could get away with a reset button every week because they took place in the Federation where resources were unlimited and dead crew, smashed shuttles, holes in the hull and other detritus could be swept clean without consequence to the story. Not so with Voyager, stranded 70,000 light years from the nearest starbase or gas station."

But, if Voyager (and the rest of the Starfleet's vessels) is made of intelligent, self-repearable, materials (nanotechnology is known in Federation - vide TNG's "Evolution")?
And they have replicators too. And... Hey! they can harvesting matter and antimatter somewhere down the road (TAS "One of Our Planets Is Missing", VOY "The Cloud").
William B
Tue, Nov 7, 2017, 4:13pm (UTC -5)
I managed to catch up and write about most episodes this season, so I'm fairly happy; as always, I'll maybe go back and fill in the rest, or maybe this is it. Ratings, with differences from Jammer's rating in parentheses:

Scorpion, Part II: 3 (=) (I think I'll settle on 3, but I might have to really think about it; this is one I haven't written up)
The Gift: 2.5 (-0.5)
Day of Honor: 3 (+0.5)
Nemesis: 2.5 (-0.5)
Revulsion: 2 (-0.5)
The Raven: 2.5 (=)
Scientific Method: 2 (+0.5) (this is silly and not great and sometimes dumb, but fun enough to go above 1.5, despite what I said earlier, I think)
Year of Hell (both parts): 3.5 (+0.5 each)
Random Thoughts: 3 (=)
Concerning Flight: 1 (-1)
Mortal Coil: 3.5 (+0.5)
Waking Moments: 1.5 (-1)
Message in a Bottle: 3 (=)
Hunters: 3 (=)
Prey: 3.5 (=)
Retrospect: 3 (=)
The Killing Game, Part I: 2.5 (=)
The Killing Game, Part II: 1.5 (-0.5)
Vis a Vis: 1.5 (-0.5)
The Omega Directive: 3 (=)
Unforgettable: 1 (-0.5)
Living Witness: 4 (=)
Demon: 0.5 (=)
One: 3 (=)
Hope and Fear: 3 (+1)

So the average comes out to 2.56, which is a dramatic improvement on any of seasons 1-3 and is overall pretty good. I'd characterize this season in similar terms to Jammer, basically, but I think my overall feeling about it is better; I'm not really disappointed in the show most of the time, because I know what it is by now, and I think this season does involve a lot of honing of the show's strengths. I will say that the season started off with a sort of 2.5-average period from Scorpion II through Scientific Method that was comfortably in the 2-3 range throughout -- average with a decent run of quality -- and then from Year of Hell on was similar in average but much more variable in quality, with a fair number of standout shows and lots of very bad ones; the whiplash of (especially) Unforgettable/Living Witness/Demon, my favourite of the season sandwiched between my two least favourite, was pretty extreme. I agree with Jammer on Prey and Living Witness (neither of which I talked about) being season highlights, and I think I'd probably agree with them being the best of the season (certainly Living Witness), but I do think that Year of Hell is very good, as is Mortal Coil, as well. The end of the season went a little haywire -- The Killing Game II through Demon had one classic, one very good show, and four bad ones -- but overall the season is notable for its managing to get rid of many of the rough edges of s1-3, which were especially noticeable in s3 before the dark Before and After-and-after period. The quality control seems to be better, basically (though, again, it started conking out at the season's end, which produced lots of good shows but many bad ones).

And of course, Seven of Nine. So of course her introduction is a mixed blessing; while the suit is pretty distractingly silly, the writing and performance of the character were top-notch and she had a solid, well-written character arc for the season. The problem is that the movement to focus on Seven did leave much of the cast behind, and there is a sense in which many characters were left behind never to be fully recovered. Janeway and the Doctor are the only two characters who don't seem to take a hit *at all* from Seven's introduction, at least this season; Janeway is clearly still the centre of the show, and her relationship with Seven also gains prominence even if some of her other relationships wither a little bit over the season. The Doctor still has several key episodes and generally is better used than in season three and one (and to a lesser extent season two, which was his best season previously). It's worth pausing to note before continuing that the show is not *exactly* the Seven show. She is a frequent topic of conversation and an unstable element and does seem to have the most screentime save Janeway. However, the only episode in which Seven is sort of a full, unambiguous episode lead is One; before then, she was a key figure in an ensemble single main plot in several episodes (Scorpion II, Scientific Method, Year of Hell, The Killing Game, Prey -- which, yes, has Seven make the final call, but is mostly an ensemble piece with a lot of material for Chakotay), was a central figure in one of the plots in a fairly evenly split A/B episode in several cases (The Gift, Revulsion, The Raven -- which has a Seven focus but spends a *lot* of time on the Voyager side of things; this is the iffiest of these I think), and several episodes rely on Seven's interaction with another cast member, usually Janeway (The Gift, Prey, The Omega Directive, Hope and Fear) but also the Doctor (Retrospect, the first half of One). In the Janeway episodes I listed, Janeway arguably gets more focus in pretty much all of them, and the Doctor has more of an arc of sorts in Retrospect than Seven does. The season is still "the Seven show" insofar as many of the key character beats end up centring on how major characters react to Seven in addition to how she reacts herself, but it isn't *quite* a total takeover of the show.

What we do see, though, is how the cast besides those characters suffers. Chakotay actually still has a lot of material; Scorpion II, Nemesis, Waking Moments and Unforgettable are basically all vehicles where he's the lead or maybe co-lead in the case of Scorpion II. The problem is that besides Scorpion, the episodes don't really do that much with Chakotay himself, and Waking Moments and especially Unforgettable are actually bad. He does have big, important supporting roles in Year of Hell, Hunters and Prey, probably among others, and Year of Hell especially makes good use of him. B'Elanna does okay in the first half of the season, particularly with Day of Honor but also Revulsion, Scientific Method and Random Thoughts, and her relative disappearance in the second half of the season is partly a function of Dawson's pregnancy rather than the shift in the show's focus. But the rest of the men in the cast seem to mostly disappear: Neelix, apart from Mortal Coil (though this isn't a huge change from season three); Harry, apart from Demon (I guess?) and the occasional Seven scenes ala Revulsion; Tuvok outside Random Thoughts and the two stories where he's paired with Seven -- The Raven and Year of Hell; and Tom outside the early B'Elanna relationship episodes, that brief Message in a Bottle subplot, and the woebegotten Vis a Vis. One of the comic highlights of the season for me was the scuffle of the organic boys in the fake history in Living Witness, partly because in some ways I think it does represent accurately the way the show sort of reduced the large male non-AI supporting cast to a somewhat undifferentiated mass with very little material this year. For the record, I'm absolutely not claiming this was sexism against men or something like that, particularly given the amount of affection the show still holds for the Doctor (and how little impact Kes' ejection from the show really had), so much as that there are a whole lot of characters that seem out to sea. I'm hoping this will get better in future years, but from my memory of season five, the only character of this set who I recall getting significantly more and better material in season five than in season four is Tom. The main place where it's a big shame is with Tuvok; to some extent Seven has usurped Tuvok's role as both Janeway's confidante and as the stoic, efficient co-lead, and while some episodes like The Raven, Year of Hell, Unforgettable, and Hope and Fear (among others, probably) played up a bit of a compare/contrast between them in the way they both approach their different attitude from the more emotion-driven rest of the crew, I think that the show generally downplays this angle. This is a shame because of course the show manages to avoid having Seven step on the Doctor's arc by having the Doctor take a mentorship role with Seven as an "outsider commenting on humanity," and the differences in their responses in that particular role are highlighted throughout.

In fact, the real issue I think with the cast besides Seven, the Doctor and Janeway isn't just the amount of material but the quality of such, which is clearest in Chakotay's case. Most of the worst episodes of the season -- Concerning Flight, Waking Moments, Vis a Vis, Unforgettable, Demon -- are all ones that have very little Doctor or Seven material (I'll admit Waking Moments has a fair amount of Doc presence and so is maybe a marginal case). I'll add that Scientific Method and The Killing Game both have the odd property that the first and superior half of the story included some Doctor/Seven plotting which was mostly dropped partway through, at which point they didn't have a particularly significant role. Anyway with often only one or two episodes featuring a cast member in a significant way, the quality of that (those) one or two episode(s) has a big impact; I end the season feeling better about Neelix's story than Tom's because I thought Mortal Coil was great and Vis a Vis was bad, rather than because Neelix was better served by the other 25 episodes of the season than Tom was. Along those lines, the relative dearth of material for Tuvok is a shame but what material he has is good, and so I still feel happy about the character -- and besides, as the oldest and most stable one in the cast, it's not a big deal for him not to change very quickly.

And it is worth noting that the world on the ship seems to be shrinking. This was literalized at several points in the season -- the crew being sent off into escape pods at the end of Year of Hell I, the entire crew save Seven and the Doctor being put into stasis in One, the way only main characters seemed to be involved in the Killing Game scenarios we saw -- but really, besides the occasional appearance by Vorik and the Wildmans' role in Mortal Coil, there were no indications this season of a continuing world on Voyager outside the main cast. This was true in season three, too, for the most part, after Basics Part II, and in some ways it does feel a bit as if Jeri Taylor et al. severed themselves from most from the Piller era that wasn't baked into contract (Suder, Hogan and Seska were of coursed KILLED in Basics II, but Carey or other characters introduced in previous years are still around, no?).

Anyway, it's a bit disappointing that a lot of the cast is underserved, but the show really did get a burst of energy from Seven's introduction, as well as the exciting development in the Message in a Bottle/Hunters mini-arc. There's a sense in many episodes this season of a show gesturing toward the kind of long-form arc storytelling that DS9 was imperfectly executing over on the other channel, but with a somewhat looser approach, epitomized by Prey, one of the season's best, which grew out of ongoing storyarcs which were coming to a head -- interpersonal conflict between Janeway and Seven, the way the Hirogen and Species 8472 had been introduced and their role in the show thusfar, relying on the crew's experience with both species in terms of how they reacted to the situation. So there's a weird mixture where the show is becoming more committed to being episodic while also branching out into new territory. I think mostly what it is is that the show's focus is narrowing, and that leads to some clarity in the parts of the show that get focused on, but a feeling of the universe of the show closing in more tightly when it felt in previous years like the show had the potential to be...well, wider. The show is much better this season so I mostly won't complain about the choice (more than I already have), but I also get why people like Robert say that they felt a lot more attachment to ~s1-2 where the show seemed to be imperfectly building to something grand.
William B
Tue, Nov 7, 2017, 4:17pm (UTC -5)
That should read, "...building to something grand in a different way." Really "grand" is the wrong word; broad might be more like it, but I don't mean broad in the sense of "broad comedy." The season seems to be focusing in on a handful of characters with sharper focus, and also to some extent really going all in with the mythic qualities of the story (which works very well in some eps, like Living Witness), and that really is basically both a good and bad thing. I feel like it would have been possible for the show to balance both the strong new elements it included with some of the discarded elements from s1-2 (and sort of 3, the transitional year), in which case Voyager could actually have eventually become a much better show. But I think it's still taken a turn for the better this season and I'd largely say I enjoyed it.
William B
Fri, Nov 10, 2017, 10:56am (UTC -5)
Just another question while it's on my mind: so in the Taylor era (which I'll define as Flashback through Hope & Fear), are there any recurring members of the crew who appeared besides Vorik and the Wildmans (I know Naomi isn't a crew member, but...), and I guess Seska in Worst Case Scenario? (I guess technically Kes was not a main cast member in Scorpion II and The Gift, but I think it's obvious she's in a different category.) And moreover, were there any episodes in this period in which a one-episode crew member had a significant effect on the episode, in some way? These aren't meant to be purely rhetorical; I honestly can't think of any. This is sort of what I mean about what I think the show was trying to have (if imperfectly) in s1-2 that they mostly lost in s3. I'll grant Vorik, and the Wildmans do appear in Mortal Coil (and SPOILER Naomi becomes a significant character), but otherwise it's not just supporting players, but the whole world of Voyager seems to only be the main cast. I guess if we count the Leonardo da Vinci holoprogram as a "crew member" we could throw him in too....
Sun, Dec 17, 2017, 5:46am (UTC -5)
My ratings for the season. Highest to lowest.

3.0 - Message in a Bottle
3.0 - Prey
2.5 - Scorpion Pt. II
2.5 - The Gift
2.5 - Day of Honor
2.5 - Scientific Method
2.5 - Year of Hell Pt. I
2.5 - Mortal Coil
2.5 - The Omega Directive
2.0 - Nemesis
2.0 - Revulsion
2.0 - Year of Hell Pt. II
2.0 - Hunters
2.0 - Living Witness
2.0 - One
1.5 - The Raven
1.5 - Random Thoughts
1.5 - Waking Moments
1.5 - Retrospect
1.5 - Hope and Fear
0.5 - Concerning Flight
0.5 - The Killing Game Pt. I
0.5 - Vis a Vis
0.0 - The Killing Game Pt. II
0.0 - Unforgettable
0.0 - Demon

So my average for this season is 1.71 stars

A more consistent season than the first three, but unfortunately consistently mediocre yet again.

My season averages so far.

Season 1 - 1.53
Season 2 - 1.65
Season 3 - 1.44
Season 4 - 1.71

So the best season yet, but not by much. Seven made the season a little more interesting I guess, but I still miss Kes. I'd rather listen to her silky sweet voice, than Seven's stilted know it all voice.
Sun, Dec 17, 2017, 5:48am (UTC -5)
Come on Voyager, you have 3 seasons left to get above a 2.0 average. Unfortunately my hopes aren't very high :(
Thu, Jun 7, 2018, 5:58pm (UTC -5)
I think it's pretty obvious that Voyager was intended to more-or-less be TNG continued, more TNG with a few tweaks, and even given that as it went on the producers and writers tended to become less ambitious and less interested in the few tweaks.

For Season 4, I agree with Jammer that the supporting characters were often pretty mechanical and OTOH Seven was usually interesting. Only a few misses ("Concerning Flight", "Retrospect", "The Killing Game, Part II" and especially "Demon", fewer big misses than in season 2 or 3), only "Year of Hell" a big success, the rest somewhere in the middle. With the average stories some were really lacking in ambition but the cast had become more likeable.
Thu, Nov 4, 2021, 12:29am (UTC -5)
I just finished this season for the first time and I think of the first 4 seasons, this one is probably the best. There weren't that many great episodes, but there weren't a lot of horrible ones either. Seven is a welcome addition to the show. I thisk she's my favorite part of the whole series so far.

I also think it's interesting that there was more of an attempt at connecting plot threads between episodes this season, or at least more of an attempt than I remember from any of the other seasons. The second half of the season is very focused on the message from Starfleet which I thought was an entertaining enough story.

All in all, a decent season. I'm glad I saw it, but still not quite reaching the highs of some of the other Trek shows.

Submit a comment

I agree to the terms of use

◄ Season Index

▲Top of Page | Menu | Copyright © 1994-2023 Jamahl Epsicokhan. All rights reserved. Unauthorized duplication or distribution of any content is prohibited. This site is an independent publication and is not affiliated with or authorized by any entity or company referenced herein. Terms of use.