Star Trek: The Next Generation
"The Loss"
Air date: 12/31/1990
Teleplay by Hilary J. Bader and Alan J. Adler & Vanessa Greene
Story by Hilary J. Bader
Directed by Chip Chalmers
Review by Jamahl Epsicokhan
The Enterprise becomes ensnared in a field that pulls the ship along like a boat in a current. It turns out the current is actually a swarm of two-dimensional life forms that exist in space on a flat plane (which, of course, is not unlike how space travel is often depicted in Trek anyway). The crew must figure out how to escape the current without hurting the 2D-beings. The sci-fi gobbledygook surrounding this storyline is not one of TNG's best examples of sci-fi gobbledygook.
Coinciding with this encounter, Counselor Troi's telepathic abilities suddenly vanish. Is there a connection? Gee, what do you think? Will Troi have her abilities back before the hour is up? I wonder. "The Loss" is a better title than "Two-Dimensional Life Forms" and it describes the more relatable of the story's equal-time-shared plot. I had sympathy for Troi's loss of her ability to sense other people's feelings, whom she aptly now describes as "surfaces without depth" and "projections." But the depiction of this just doesn't work. Troi has a meltdown where she snaps on Beverly, and I didn't buy it. And her almost immediately resigning her post borders on silly as knee-jerk overreactions go. Dramatically, the net effect of a helpless Troi feels more shrill than effective. Aren't TNG characters supposed to be more perfect than this?
The 2D-beings plot turns to tedium and forced jeopardy simultaneously. We've got the 2D-beings headed toward a cosmic-string fragment (with the gravity of 1,000 black holes, if I heard right, although one would've been sufficient) and the only way for the Enterprise to escape comes when Troi hits on the idea of "moths to a flame." Of course, creating another "flame" in this instance involves reams of cascading technobabble that … oh, never mind.
Previous episode: Final Mission
Next episode: Data's Day
Like this site? Support it by buying Jammer a coffee.
116 comments on this post
Wed, Mar 5, 2008, 2:50pm (UTC -6)
Thu, Mar 6, 2008, 6:42pm (UTC -6)
Fri, Mar 7, 2008, 4:54pm (UTC -6)
Mon, Jul 11, 2011, 2:59pm (UTC -6)
Data's Day - One of the funniest things ever in television is when Beverley has just finished working so hard with Data on tap dancing (because he had said he needed to learn 'dancing') and then he concludes that he is fit for dancing at the WEDDING! Gates' reactions are HILARIOUS!!!
Wed, May 23, 2012, 4:50am (UTC -6)
Funny, I don't recall Troi's moping getting anyone killed. Indeed, Picard encourages her to help the crew even though she doesn't have her abilities, whereas Worf saves Odo's shapeshifting ass by catching Shakaar's would-be assassin.
There's goes your DS9 bias again. Sheesh.....
Sun, Dec 2, 2012, 11:39am (UTC -6)
Her episodes usually tend to boil down to either falling in love with some Mary Sue of the week or going around whining about her problems in a very self-centered way. Troi is my least favorite character.
Wed, Jun 26, 2013, 1:12pm (UTC -6)
Really, Troi's reaction to her loss of empathy does make sense -- after all, she has just been disabled. Worf's reaction to finding out he has lost his mobility in "Ethics" is to try to *kill himself*, and so I think Troi going around yelling at people trying to help her and threatening to quit her job are pretty tame in comparison. That said, something still doesn't work for me about this story. For one, it's fairly clear that her powers are likely to come back when the 2D life forms go away, and the episode mostly obscures this point by cheating -- having Beverly announce that Troi has permanent brain damage which might not repair itself, and then having Troi regain her powers instantly when the Enterprise is out of the 2D life forms' wake. That the episode makes no reference at all to the fact that there is a *disabled main character* to whom Troi might possibly talk also annoys me, though yes Geordi's being born blind is different from Troi's loss of her powers. Part of it may be that, in the end, I'm not actually that sure that Troi is very good at her job most of the time -- so many episodes involve Troi being inappropriately pushy, for example -- so that I find an episode devoted to Troi learning how she doesn't need her powers to be a good counselor somewhat unconvincing. Ideally, I wish that Troi had learned from her experience being badgered by Riker and Crusher that going on to someone in pain that they aren't dealing with their pain enough and invading their personal space to do so is not always the best way to get them to realize what they are doing wrong, and that she might become a better counselor simply by realizing what it's like to be the patient. Some elements of the dialogue hit on this -- Beverly's saying that therapists make the worst patients ("except for doctors") and Riker's suggesting that Troi likes being in emotional control of every situation and that she needs to learn to accept lack of control point to this, and those do help the episode work for me; but neither are quite enough.
I do find the attempt to link the two plots thematically especially hamfisted and funny -- "Why, everyone feels as flat to me as those two dimensional life forms!" and whatnot -- and indeed about as far as the episode ever got to developing the "2D life form" idea is "Maybe 2D life forms aren't affected by gravity the same way 3D objects are," which is a fine premise I guess but is not very imaginative. (When they mentioned the cosmic string, I thought they were going to argue that the cosmic string was essentially a one-dimensional object for all intents and purposes, and that that would be relevant somehow, but no dice.) That Troi was able to psychoanalyze these 2D life forms as acting on instinct was meant to prove that she doesn't need empathy to be useful, which is good I guess? But her speculation doesn't feel convincing enough to really establish this thing.
I guess I agree with 2 stars.
Wed, Jun 26, 2013, 1:14pm (UTC -6)
Wed, Jun 26, 2013, 1:35pm (UTC -6)
Thu, Aug 1, 2013, 7:25pm (UTC -6)
Thu, Nov 7, 2013, 7:06am (UTC -6)
I like Troi, I just think the writers have done a really poor job with her character, her lines and her stories.
"Flat" describes this episode very well.
Mon, Apr 21, 2014, 1:42am (UTC -6)
It's harder to empathize with a character who loses a power that normal humans don't have. As Riker says, there's something aristocratic about it. The show didn't succeed in showing us what it was like for her to lose her sensing abilities and making us care about it. I agree with William that they also missed a great opportunity to have her interact with Geordi.
Also, the 2D life forms plot was pretty bad. I don't find the idea of 2D life forms convincing. Is that even physically possible?
Fri, Aug 1, 2014, 12:31pm (UTC -6)
Fri, Aug 1, 2014, 12:57pm (UTC -6)
========
How do you propose we understand something that has never happened, and will probably never happen? And something we have never experienced. You can't understand qualia if you don't experience it. No matter how "well explained" it is. You also can't go into depth about something that is absolute fiction.
Tue, Aug 5, 2014, 4:46pm (UTC -6)
WHAT? It sounds like you don't believe in the power of (the best) writing to be convincing and transportive.
Tue, Sep 2, 2014, 2:03pm (UTC -6)
Tue, Jan 20, 2015, 9:28am (UTC -6)
Sat, Jul 4, 2015, 1:12am (UTC -6)
Well, okay, it does do a few things bad. What was the point of Troi's outbursts and general attitude about her loss? Was it to make her look unprofessional and all-around unlikeable? If that was the case then mission accomplished, I guess. And, the way she gets her empathic abilities back is just absurd. A short circuit in her brain because she couldn't handle such intense emotion? Give me a break! If that's the case, why is there verifiable brain damage (which is hand-waved away in the end)?
I would have rather had a techno-babble explanation for her impairment with something like the organisms blocking her abilities with a subspace field or something - because.... wait for it.... techno-babble doesn't bother me. Shock, horror, surprise, fainting, screams, sighs, pants-shitting, mass hysteria ensues and the internet explodes!
Then life goes on. On to "Data's Day."
4/10
Thu, Jul 30, 2015, 2:41pm (UTC -6)
Sun, Sep 13, 2015, 9:43am (UTC -6)
The plot with the 2D beings is also difficult to associate with, as they don't react to anything the Enterprise does and are therefore just 'there'. Ballsy move though to have Worf recommend firing photon torpedoes yet again - and for Picard to actually agree to it! 1.5 stars.
Wed, Oct 7, 2015, 1:20am (UTC -6)
Wed, Oct 28, 2015, 7:58pm (UTC -6)
I always attempt to look at the episodes the way I did when I first saw them, recorded to VHS tape (I've still got them).
The beginning wasn't too bad, with Troi interacting with the crew-woman. Normal stuff, but setting the stage...
Only an idiot would not completely tie in the 2D beings and Troi's loss of her abilities, since they happened at the same time. I mean, really? When first viewing this, I thought 'Oh, the little critters are messing with her'. They sort of thought this as well, but only mention it for a bit.
It was mentioned above that they said Betazoid's have great brain-healing abilities, and that they never mentioned it again. Perhaps they (the writers) saw it as Troi trying to rationalize things, as folks do when disaster strikes. But why say they can heal better than most, then completely forget about it?
On first viewing, I thought she needed to wait out the current crisis, because things might change. And heck, how many hours was this crisis? Not that long, I think. Troi reacts as if it's been weeks or months she's been without her abilities, but it's only been a few hours. She ends up with a nasty attitude that reminded me of the voice Marina used in the episode where she was taken over by an alien, later in the series. But I digress: On first viewing, I couldn't suspend reality long enough to think she was really in a peril we were worried about. THE SHIP IS GOING TO DIE!... and we're worried about two crew-women who are having a terrible day? ...
And we need to be interested in that crew-woman? At that exact moment towards the end? When she goes to Troi and explains Troi was correct all along? With the next scene telling us how many Minutes are left until the are all GOING TO DIE?!
Heck, I just watched this a few hours ago and cannot quickly recall the techno-babble they used to save the day. But... it seemed Troi took Wesley's spot this week: she figured out something that they could try, and it worked. Yea!
This episode was an instant dislike for me when it first aired. Not that it was... totally... horrible, but it seemed Troi was completely out of character, like she'd been written by someone who knew about the series, but hadn't watched many of them. I really thought she would handle this problem better, especially since it happened at the same time as the alien 2D problem.
I believe the Troi I recall from earlier episodes would be smarter about the problem, try to help with the resolution, and not bother with an appointment when they were all GOING TO DIE!
Enjoy the day Everyone!
Wed, Oct 28, 2015, 8:23pm (UTC -6)
Mon, Feb 22, 2016, 11:55pm (UTC -6)
Funny how horrible this is for her. Imagine having to function without knowing people's private and personal feelings and emotions; and without having to violate people against their will.
Tue, Feb 23, 2016, 9:10am (UTC -6)
I thought it was funny she was so willing to up and quit being a counseler though at the drop of a hat lol.
Thu, Feb 25, 2016, 10:19pm (UTC -6)
Did anyone else notice how over it Stewart was about a third of the way into the episode? I don't think he'd rate it among his favorites. It seemed almost like two different stories at the same time. I mean, who resigns their position on the ship in the middle of a crisis? Who starts packing their crap up when the ship's about to be destroyed? Where did she think she was going to go? There didn't seem to be much urgency from...well, anyone in this episode, really. The bridge crew acted mildly concerned, but that's about as far as it got. Ho hum, we're about to be sucked into a cosmic string. How unfortunate. That will surely put a crimp in my holodeck plans.
And seriously, it took four people to write this stinker?
Thu, Feb 25, 2016, 10:21pm (UTC -6)
Tue, Jun 21, 2016, 3:21pm (UTC -6)
Let's compare it to DS9's "Melora" shall we? Troi becomes this sort of angry woman who doesn't like people "walking on eggshells" because of her disability. Ensign Melora was the same way, and the episode spent time showing how great Melora was just as she is.
So, this episode also shows us how great Troi can be as a professional without her empathic powers. And...it works to some degree. I like Troi puzzle-solving with Data for a change. There are also some great scenes for Riker and Troi where Riker gives Troi some tough love (and Troi of course gets back at him later).
And finally to address people's complaints about Troi's attitude, I think Siritis was trying to act out the emotional range of a newly handicapped person. It may come off strong, yet I think her off-putting demeanor shows just how painful it is to lose an important sense in a small amount of time.
3 stars.
Tue, Jun 21, 2016, 3:35pm (UTC -6)
Fri, Jun 24, 2016, 7:14am (UTC -6)
www.youtube.com/watch?v=UX70f7ovNl8
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ycAyqaFh84o
This episode could have been about a real disablement, like Wolf in episode Ethics, that was being disabled, even in the far future. Losing your "know it all abilities" comes across more as a dumb joke, "I lose my powers, I hate everyone! I got my powers back, now I love everyone!"
One and half Star
Sat, Aug 13, 2016, 4:56pm (UTC -6)
I felt the way that Troi described it ("surfaces without depth") was a great descriptor. It would be like humans going about their life but feeling an emptiness not unlike depression.
The only thing that truly bothered me and it extends beyond this episode is that Troi is the only counsellor onboard the entire ship? Sure there's some crew members with degrees in psychology but no other counsellors. Yes, people in a more perfect society can probably handle their mental and emotional health better than we can, but come on! For example look at "Q Who" -- 19 crew members were killed by the Borg. It rattled Ensign Gomez and she probably didn't get a chance to meet any of them. I imagine the crew members and possible family members of the dead would need counselling. It would have been nice if they had introduced someone who worked under Troi but oh well.
I like the idea of an empath being on the bridge for the captain and in other situations but shouldn't there be some sort of disclosure of her abilities to whomever they're dealing with? Seems somewhat underhanded to me.
Thu, Sep 8, 2016, 10:31pm (UTC -6)
While Star Trek VOY was not the best ST series (it's still far better than ENT), I have to give credit where credit is due, they at least got rid of Kes, you know the blonde version of Troi.
"Listening to Counselor Troi's pedantic psychobabble."
Thank you Q
Zero stars
Fri, Dec 2, 2016, 9:44am (UTC -6)
TNG writers didn't try to make Troi a particularly likeable character - she just floated around, reading minds, making judgements, playing victim and eating chocolate.
Sat, Dec 17, 2016, 7:28pm (UTC -6)
Mon, Jan 9, 2017, 10:09pm (UTC -6)
But as nice as a skimpy costume is, it's an insult to the character and the story—especially when the writer hasn't given a care for anything beyond moronic titillation. That's why Troi is such a useless pile of rubbish. It isn't Marina Sirtis' fault; she did her best with the material she was given. The problem is that the character was only there for some sneak peak panties, and nothing else. The writers didn't think about ANYTHING ELSE when they conjured her up.
Even the job itself—Counsellor—was dull and pathetic. If such a position were available on the Enterprise, she still wouldn't be on the Bridge. So, with a total lack of character development, or backstory, or prognosis, they simply forced Troi to repeat "I sense..." "I feel..." And even THAT wasn't consistent. When a scene would genuinely benefit greatly from having her talent, there was some silly reason why her power wouldn't work.
It was just really, really lazy and insulting to the audience. At least Marina got paid. I consider the character a total failure—not only did we not receive a character with depth, we also didn't get to see any lovely Marina Siritis/Troi panties!
I sense a very disappointed reviewer.
Mon, Jan 9, 2017, 11:10pm (UTC -6)
Then you have episodes like "Face of the Enemy" where Sirtis and Troi play out a fantastic Hunter for the Red October-like story. And to be fair, this episode itself did a good job of showcasing Troi's psychology abilities minus her powers. I don't think overall the writers did a stellar job with the character but credit where credit is due.
Tue, Jan 10, 2017, 12:30am (UTC -6)
Fri, Jan 13, 2017, 8:59am (UTC -6)
Troi acts like a brat for the majority of the episode. The technobabble sci-fi plot was stupid and the resolution was even dumber. An exceptionally dull episode in a so-far excellent season. 0.5 stars from me
Thu, Apr 13, 2017, 3:55am (UTC -6)
Mon, Jun 5, 2017, 4:17pm (UTC -6)
Guinan was excellent, as always.
Mon, Jun 5, 2017, 4:37pm (UTC -6)
Geordi was born blind and never "lost" anything. He seems pretty content with his VISOR as we see in episodes like "The Masterpiece Society". What did Data lose?
Mon, Jun 5, 2017, 10:48pm (UTC -6)
"Geordi was born blind and never "lost" anything. He seems pretty content with his VISOR as we see in episodes like "The Masterpiece Society". What did Data lose?"
Funny you should ask, I had to check the episode order just to make sure. Not seven episodes earlier Data lost the emotion chip that would have given him the thing he'd been after for years. I'd say that's more of a loss than Troi losing some special ability that no one else even had in the first place.
Regarding Geordi, I agree that he never 'lost' his sight, but I do think it would be fair to still say he has a disability that he's had to learn to live with. He has some advantages there, but if you remember from "Hide and Q" it's pretty clear that despite his scanner-vision he is missing out on a lot of what others take for granted, and I'm sure he's aware of that at all times.I definitely think he could have contributed something to the discussion of how to cope with feeling left out or having suffered a misfortune.
Tue, Jun 6, 2017, 10:34am (UTC -6)
Data losing a chance at feeling emotion isn't really the same as what Troi's going through in this episode, I'm not sure Data could relate. But even so, Data does have a scene with Troi where explains that he lacks human insight anyway.
As for Geordi and his blindness, pardon the pun, but I don't see it. "Hey Deanna, I've lived without sight all my life, so you'll be fine without empathic powers?" What? Guinan was really a good choice because she actually does have a skillset and capabilities similar to Troi.
Tue, Jun 6, 2017, 10:48am (UTC -6)
But it's possible the episode is a bit of a non-starter because she loses a power that no one in our world actually has. This is why Riker's "aristocratic" accusation maybe has some weight -- there is a bit of a "poor little rich girl" vibe here, where Troi has to suffer the unbearable fate of...being like other people. And I think that doesn't mean that it isn't a horrible and painful loss, at all -- anything that is central to a person's identity is hard to lose. But it also seems as if Troi doesn't quite get to the point where she adjusts to recognizing that her experience post-loss is actually what other people go through all the time. She sort of does, but I'm not sure if she learns that much, besides some generic "have confidence in yourself" lesson. I think that she maybe does view her empathic powers at the episode's end much more as a gift that she should treasure, rather than a default setting she takes for granted, the loss of which she should mourn, which is something.
This is one frame, though; if we look at it from Troi's perspective, it's awful, especially since this is part of her connection to (one of her) species. But I think that element of the story gets lost, too. I mean, imagine how her relationship with her mother would change if she could no longer communicate telepathically. There are lots of angles the episode could have taken, I think, to make the episode richer and deeper. I don't hate it like many do, but it plays to me as (jokey reference intended) pretty 2D.
Tue, Jun 6, 2017, 10:51am (UTC -6)
Data doesn't experience emotions, but what he experienced would qualify to most humans as a major trauma. His brother killed their father than stole his birthright, which included the completion of his programming. There is something Edward-Scissorhands-ish about that; very sad, I should think. His experience isn't a 1-to-1 comparison with Troi, but he (and heck, even Worf) could certainly have something to say about things being suboptimal compared to what they hoped for.
About Geordi, we can talk about the tech behind his VISOR all day, but ultimately his character was originally about how even disabled people will have a place right alongside everyone else in the future and will be able to contribute. The idea isn't that he *isn't* disabled, but that in the future being disabled won't have all the negative consequences that it does today. It's one thing to say that he's afforded the chance to contribute, but quite another to write off his disability and say that since he's 'used to it' that he has nothing to add to someone's experience of recently becoming disabled. The point isn't that his experience and hers are identical, but that he is a role model for the audience in how lacking some capability others have doesn't mean you can't be useful or participate. Troi's problem isn't that she lost her empathic powers; it's that she was obviously hanging on them as a crutch and can't cope without them. Her problem is emotional rather than technical, and that's how Geordi could help, because he no doubt went through a gamut of emotions of the course of his life regarding his blindness.
Of course you'll get no argument from me that Guinan was a prime candidate to assist. I'm just agreeing with Michb that this was a bit of a wasted opportunity. When anyone else on the ship has problems we are usually treated to them hearing advice from various crew members. Whether it's Data, Worf, or whomever else, they'll go through the gauntlet of hearing various comments from the different perspectives. We often even get humorous scenes when Worf or Data try to give people advice. Just saying, they could have done better using the crew in this one, rather than zeroing in on how upset Troi was. It ended up feeling like a giant tantrum rather than giving her a chance to finally lean on others for support like they do on her. Isn't the show supposed to be about how everyone can help each other?
Tue, Jun 6, 2017, 10:52am (UTC -6)
Tue, Jun 6, 2017, 10:54am (UTC -6)
Tue, Jun 6, 2017, 11:03am (UTC -6)
Tue, Jun 6, 2017, 11:16am (UTC -6)
Actually, TNG in general really plays down Geordi considering his blindness a disability. No crew member ever mentions it, and Geordi never seems discouraged or left out because of it. In fact, I can really only think of one episode, "The Enemy", where Geordi's blindness even affects his performance. I think being blind is something we might consider a terrible disability today, but not such a big deal in the 24th century, and I'm sure that the writers purposefully avoided making us feel bad for Geordi, but rather liked to show off how incredibly capable Geordi was with his blindness.
So sure, in another show, a blind guy having a heart-to-heart with a woman who lost a sense would work, but it's somewhat antithetical to TNG's message of inclusiveness.
As for Data, I'm still not convinced. In order to experience the trauma you speak of, Data would need to have emotions. Since Data never had emotions, he has nothing to "feel" traumatic about. "Brothers" was just another interesting day for him.
Tue, Jun 6, 2017, 11:33am (UTC -6)
Tue, Jun 6, 2017, 11:38am (UTC -6)
The only time I felt that Geordi may have experienced discrimination from blindness was in his conversation with the woman engineer in "The Masterpiece Society". I feel like LeVar added a bit of a chip on Geordi's shoulder in his acting in that scene. It was quite good.
Tue, Jun 6, 2017, 11:43am (UTC -6)
I think that it's worth noting that the Romulans' using his VISOR in "The Mind's Eye" is especially despicable because of using his disability against him -- not exactly "discrimination" in the sense we're talking about, but very brutal.
Tue, Jun 6, 2017, 12:14pm (UTC -6)
I forget about "The Naked Now" because season one's full of early installation weirdness, but I suppose Geordi does lament being blind when "drunk". It might even be safe to say Geordi would only mind being blind if he was out of his senses from intoxication.
I did think about "The Mind's Eye", but we never really get a moment where Geordi reflects on being used as a tool by the Romulans (and later again by the Klingons in "ST: Generations"). That might make for a darkly humorous conversation with Troi, though:
Geordi: You think it's hard losing your mind-reading skills? How do you think I feel being, after Data, the single biggest security risk to the Enterprise because I have to use tech to live a normal life?
Then again, we might just end up feeling worse for Geordi than we do for Troi. :)
Tue, Jul 25, 2017, 3:37pm (UTC -6)
A Troi-focused episode is not a good recipe for me -- she has had her annoying moments in prior seasons. Here she's lashing out at Crusher, Riker etc. for losing her empathic abilities -- perhaps hard to care about it if you don't know what it's like to lose a sense.
I think the sci-fi aspect here of 2D beings and their pull on the ship was poorly done. The technobabble didn't make much sense to me -- seems like the Enterprise tried the appropriate things but the moths/flame solution didn't have any logic for me or how the ship could create the reverse phenomena.
The 1st 30 mins. was pretty forgettable, the opening dreadfully dull. Like I said, hard to empathize with Troi's "loss". And I thought her petulant actions were unprofessional -- but I guess it's all meant to show what it could be like for a therapist to become a patient. But resigning as ship's councillor too? I really liked how Guinan showed an interest in the job -- she should really be the ship's councillor. Riker had some good parts trying to help Troi but also putting her in her place a bit with the "aristocrat" comment.
"The Loss" doesn't quite make it to 2 stars for my rating. You got 2 mediocre plots, weak sci-fi, and very slow pacing. So I think 1.5 stars is more appropriate. I don't know what more they could do with the interesting idea of 2D beings, but definitely more could be done with a key crew member losing a sense.
Wed, Aug 16, 2017, 7:46am (UTC -6)
Wed, Aug 16, 2017, 8:20am (UTC -6)
Sorry all, that was borderline trolling, but I couldn't resist.
Wed, Aug 16, 2017, 10:35am (UTC -6)
Thu, Oct 19, 2017, 11:42pm (UTC -6)
Imagine losing a part of your self that you've had since birth, something that everybody else on your home planet has. A thing that basically defines your species and their entire role in the federation. Imagine the shame of having to go back to betazed and be treated like the poor disabled girl who has to talk aloud while everybody else is having telepathic conversations.
Of course troi was angry, anger is normal in the aftermath of losing something so innate that helps define who you are. Its not like she was parading around the ship shouting at anybody who would listen, she only responded harshly when people were being overly pitiful to her.
It also makes perfect sense that she would have misgivings about her role on the ship without her empathic abilities. They are a crutch that she is used to leaning on in the absence of any evolved human like instincts that she has probably never learned or had to employ before.
So what if troi acted like a diva about the whole thing. Worf is the biggest drama queen on the ship most of the time and everybody loves him.
I think a lot of people just defaulted to meh it's a troi episode she's just being her usual crappy self. The thing is she actually has a very valid reason here. She doesn't know that her abilities are going to return and the weight of having to get used to being essentialy disabled is a hard one to bear for anybody (yes even beautiful half alien women).
So what if the sense she lost isn't a human one. Your lack of understanding of her plight doesn't make it any less real for the character.
I will say while I'm here though that a lot of episode was kind of nowhere. The bits I liked boiled down to Guinan being a better counsellor then troi as usual and Data and Troi puzzling out the solution to their problem in a very believable way.
Mon, Jan 1, 2018, 6:40pm (UTC -6)
The Enterprise is one hour away from being torn apart so, you know, the tin can's working on it down in Observation.
Also, lines like "I feel as two-dimensional as our friends out there." Yikes.
The part that irritates me the most is the massive Troi uppercut Beverly eats in the early part of the episode, only to completely disappear afterwards. I am watching TNG for what, the 50th time through, and I finally get it. Season 2 was great and Pulaski was a better doctor.
Tue, Feb 13, 2018, 8:11pm (UTC -6)
The biggest problem with this episode was the guest cast. My god, every time I watch I want to smack Troi's patient, Ensign Brooks. She was played with all the depth of a puddle. And don't get me started on her melodramatic way of speaking. Wesley's replacement, Ensign Allenby, was terrible as well. What a stiff. I remember cringing when I read the BTS stuff that the new conn officer was intended to become a love interest for O'Brien!. So glad they dropped that idea.
Wed, Feb 28, 2018, 3:54pm (UTC -6)
She has a very human meltdown and is realistically traumatised brittle and hurting.
The rest of the episode is baloney.
Sat, Apr 14, 2018, 10:07am (UTC -6)
Why didn't they separate the saucer section?!
Even as a kid, it struck me as terrible writing.
Sun, Jul 8, 2018, 1:27pm (UTC -6)
2-dimensional beings? Huh?
"Cosmic string". What a load of garbage.
Troi simply being part of the plot is a strike.
Troi being a total whiny bitch. Ugh.
So much technobabble blah blah blah it was a total turnoff.
Sun, Aug 19, 2018, 10:28pm (UTC -6)
Fri, Feb 15, 2019, 7:45pm (UTC -6)
Sat, Apr 6, 2019, 8:45pm (UTC -6)
Second, it gave a good jab at our arrogance about disabled people. We abled people create the disability. A planet full of Deaf people would be just fine: communication would be different but hearing isn't like breathing. Here the episode questions disability by taking away an additional sense. All the humans around Troi who never had that sense are like "so what? we do just fine.". I have a Deaf partner so perhaps this resonated with me in particular.
8/10
Tue, May 21, 2019, 11:07pm (UTC -6)
Thu, Dec 19, 2019, 5:57pm (UTC -6)
An interesting premise, pretty well realized, though Troi's completely illogical, wildly emotional reaction was a touch overdone. She's a grown woman, and a counselor.
I liked Guinan's role in talking get off the ledge.
Lots of talk about depth, and like the last ep, lots of talk about what is real. And perspective. The creatures don't see the strong as the Enterprise does. Things that affect three dimensional creatures don't affect them. Troi knows that the non Empath humans don't understand her. Etc.
Though there's talk of Troi feeling like she's losing her Enterprise family, and Riker basically acting like a family member, this ep takes a small step away from the heavy family theme of the Season.
Slightly above average.
Mon, May 25, 2020, 5:29am (UTC -6)
Seeing Troi turn almost immediately into a brat after losing her powers makes for challenging viewing, in part because it reminds us of times people around us have behaved insufferably in reaction to setbacks. On the one hand, we want to empathise and understand them - the episode makes it clear that this is a parallel to a major disability. Picard compares it to blindness or being in a wheelchair.
On the other hand, Riker's reaction in Troi's quarters embodies the other angle: that Troi is merely brought down to the level of everyone else, and her attitude is actually very insulting. This really hit home for me, particularly what Riker says about her having control. I've had experiences with brilliant and supernaturally charming people throwing a tantrum when things don't go their way, simply because they're so used to being able to manipulate the situation - and Troi's reaction here rings true to life. Such people are blind to the privilege they enjoy, and seem to hate the idea of an even playing field.
With this in mind, I totally understand people's bitchy comments about Troi on this page and others - it's an aspect the show rarely, if ever, delves into, but there would be understandable resentment of a betazoid counsellor with the ear of the captain. She is essentially appointed to spy on the crew constantly, to make sure that no one can cover up their personal misgivings with professionalism. Imagine you bloody hated Riker (an understandable position) but were determined to get along with him for the sake of your career and the rest of the crew. Now imagine that his ex-girlfriend was always hanging around, able to read your emotions and report them to the captain. What a hideously unfair and impossible situation to have to deal with.
So this episode gets points from me for making Troi realistically hateful in the instance she loses her powers, but the show as a whole is docked points for never making more of this, or allowing her to confront this very unpleasant aspect of her character and grow to be a better person. We have multiple episodes where Data reacts to new limitations and flaws, and has to puzzle it out; Troi should have been given the same treatment.
-
Also, an interesting point that gets quickly lost in the mix: Troi compares how she sees people without her powers to holodeck characters. This strongly suggests that the holodeck is completely unconvincing and unnerving to Troi - something like the equivalent of the uncanny valley. It wasn't programmed to simulate actual feelings and emotions on whatever wavelength she picks them up.
This begs the question, however: why did the writers put this line in here? It tells us (and Riker) nothing about Troi's present condition, because the rest of the crew *do* find holodeck characters convincing.
Additional: Guinan was great, and one of the weaknesses of the episode is that it's really not clear why she *shouldn't* be the ship's counsellor rather than Troi. Her style is to listen and respond, rather than impose her ideas on a situation, which I would have thought is the better technique for helping people with their anxieties.
Thu, Jun 4, 2020, 12:56pm (UTC -6)
And the basis of the episode, with the 2D creatures and the cosmic string, just didn't grab me at all.
Sat, Jun 6, 2020, 7:03am (UTC -6)
Sun, Jun 14, 2020, 3:18pm (UTC -6)
Thu, Sep 3, 2020, 9:59am (UTC -6)
Wed, Sep 30, 2020, 6:07pm (UTC -6)
Sun, May 9, 2021, 4:38am (UTC -6)
A friend lost his vision in his early 20s to an undiagnosed neurological condition. When he was first admitted to the hospital he was upbeat and hopeful but gradually sunk into a deep moodiness and stopped being helpful to the medical staff until it was pointed out that he was hurting his own care by not participating. He snapped out of the funk and started working with the staff again.
I would have rather seen something like that with Troi falling into a depression. People handle grief and loss in all sorts of ways and lashing out childishly is absolutely one of those ways but that doesn't make for a good TV viewing experience.
I did not feel empathy for Troi because she was acting less like someone suffering loss and more like a spoiled brat who had their favorite toy taken away.
Mon, May 17, 2021, 11:23pm (UTC -6)
Sat, May 22, 2021, 7:59pm (UTC -6)
I think she's always exhibited a smug, self-satisfied air, like she naturally just knows better than you. She represents to me the worst aspects of the therapy profession - her behavior reminds me of the worst members of that group - she talks down to people, like "oh, how simple you are". When placed under ANY pressure, however, she always behaves selfishly and tends to lash out at others. I strongly agree with a lot of what Riker says to her in this episode about her "aristocratic" bearing and aloof nature.
Basically, her snooty behavior is irritating, but the hypocrisy implied in her smugness towards other people's emotional reactions when juxtaposed with her repeated emotional fragility really bothers me. I don't see a single redeeming quality in her personality - Beverly, while she can be annoying, exhibits a strong, sincere desire to help others that I find admirable, however Deanna's personality is nothing but smug arrogance, judgement of others, and myopic, self-centered petulence. I can't stand her.
Sun, May 23, 2021, 6:39am (UTC -6)
Sun, May 23, 2021, 12:06pm (UTC -6)
Sun, May 30, 2021, 9:04pm (UTC -6)
In the end it turned out that in fact no, Troi’s betazoid abilities were temporarily suspended and the rest was all her.
And we’re supposed to like this character why, exactly?
Sun, May 30, 2021, 9:10pm (UTC -6)
Mon, May 31, 2021, 1:51am (UTC -6)
Why pick this name... Sure, Miles had some rough edges but he was a fundamentally good guy. Your comments on the other hand are so negative and unpleasant that I really don't get why you even watch the show.
Have you watched Star Trek Discovery? I think that could be right up your alley.
Mon, May 31, 2021, 3:03am (UTC -6)
Mon, May 31, 2021, 4:19am (UTC -6)
Mon, May 31, 2021, 8:41am (UTC -6)
Mon, May 31, 2021, 12:36pm (UTC -6)
Mon, May 31, 2021, 1:53pm (UTC -6)
Mon, May 31, 2021, 8:00pm (UTC -6)
Just judging from your comments so far, there doesn't see to be much, maybe anything, you like about TNG. Not the writing, not the characters, not the actors.
Nothing against that. Hey, you know what they say: There's no accounting for personal tastes. But just out of curiosity, why are you even watching the show, let alone taking time to leave comments on a review site? I don't think I would have the patience to stick with a series if I had a strongly negative reaction to several episodes. I pretty much gave up on Enterprise within a short time after it came out, and I never got around to watching most of its episodes. You apparently have a lot more stick-to-it-iveness than I do.
Tue, Jun 1, 2021, 1:46am (UTC -6)
I just love how they bother to watch every single episode of a 20-30 year old show, in order, just so they could complain about it here.
Tue, Jun 1, 2021, 2:15am (UTC -6)
Or mayhaps it's a disgruntled nuTrekkie try to prove a point and critisizing a show we like in order to get "the haters" to reply in ways the nuTrekkies do about their showswhen faced with criticism which the "haters" bristle at and argue against, thus proving haters are hypocrits. Though again, the new product vs old one does shift that narrative.
Or it's a smartass trying to get a rise. Or a regular ol' hatewatcher. I have noticed this one here tends to rag on the women characters/actors more too, intetestingly.
So many possibilities for why they're here though. In the words of Spock, "fascinating."
Tue, Jun 1, 2021, 2:18am (UTC -6)
Tue, Jun 1, 2021, 4:44am (UTC -6)
Tue, Jun 1, 2021, 8:39am (UTC -6)
I have no problem with critique of TNG, for me it is mostly about the style which is just unpleasant.
About people critiquing NuTrek in relation to this. I think a good comparison is to Enterprise which is a bland show but certainly a Trek show. There aren't hordes of people hating on Enterprise. People hated NuTrek, yes I'm going to say it, because it isn't Star Trek and Picard and Discovery are bad as shows, Trek or not, which adds insult to injury. I'm not sure if I can ever enjoy TNG or DS9 again after Picard destroyed Star Trek. Picard told us the important lesson:" Give up kids, there is no hope for the future. Empires rise, Empires fall until the end of time."
Taking one of the few genuinely positive visions of the future and crushing it. Unforgivable. It makes me angry just thinking about it.
Tue, Jun 1, 2021, 10:04am (UTC -6)
There aren’t hordes of people even watching Enterprise. There’s a reason why it was cancelled.
Tue, Jun 1, 2021, 11:12am (UTC -6)
1. Not liking Frakes, Sirtis and McFadden's acting isn't uncommon,
2. This ep in particular is widely disliked,
3. It's often easier to write about the things that one doesn't like than things one does.
That said personally I actually kind of like this one. I criticized it above and all, and stand by those points, but I also kind of like that Troi flails about, doesn't really take her sudden, traumatic loss of a part of her ability to relate to the world with much maturity, and I like the Riker scenes where he criticizes her. It's kind of a double edged sword because the episode acknowledges but then can't entirely resolve what are ongoing unanswered questions of the series, mostly whether Deanna is actually good at her job for real reasons or if she's mostly just coasting on her "superpower" (yes it's a species trait, but she is basically among others who don't have it).
I think episodes like this one maybe show up part of the cracks in TNG, where the show is both aspirational and a more traditional character workplace drama. Troi is an aspirational figure because she has insight into others' emotional state which she primarily uses to help them heal or cope with problems that they cannot deal with; she's a flawed imperfect person because she has this nosy insight into others that others don't really want her to have and she uses this to hold onto an advantage wherein she decides what is best for them. Troi deciding that the widow was wrong about her strategy for dealing with grief and defying her wishes to throw out her husband's stuff is representative of the ambiguity of Troi's role on the ship and the show: it's helpful and kind, and high-handed and manipulative (aristocratic, as Riker says). Take away her emotional insight and she's flying blind and loses her advantage and just has to guess like the rest of us. I think the episode maybe doesn't really "work" because it doesn't really go deep enough, or do enough on how the experience changes Deanna, but I kind of like that it's playing with it a bit.
Tue, Jun 1, 2021, 11:14am (UTC -6)
"There aren’t hordes of people even watching Enterprise."
It had through all seasons several million people watching.
When Genghis Khan conquered the Khwarazmian Empire his horde was 150.000 warriors strong. That means that Enterprise during it last season was still watched by almost 20 Mongol Hordes...
I would love to know how many hordes watched Discovery but CBS won't tell us.
Tue, Jun 1, 2021, 11:55am (UTC -6)
I think it's the combination of:
(1) Being a prequel. For some reason, many fans were against prequels as a matter of principle.
(2) Contradicting tons of widely-accepted fanon regarding the era in question.
(3) A few genuinely bad decisions that colored everything else (the Temporal Cold War, the Akira-Enteprise, the Vulcans etc.)
Many fans where so pissed off by the first few episodes, that they've never really given Enterprise a chance. Though a sizable proportion of them tried the series again later and changed their minds.
(as for myself, I've never really got all the hate. But what do I know? I also liked Voyager...)
Tue, Jun 1, 2021, 12:46pm (UTC -6)
I think two major scenes establish her competence even without her powers: how she reads the grieving Ensign, and how she comes to understand the psychology of the aliens of the week - helping the Enterprise to escape. But yes, the rest of the episode was all about her thinking she was useless without her powers.
OmicronThetaDeltaPhi, I think we agree. I have definitely been on the other side of this phenomenon, when it came to Discovery. I would see well-articulated criticisms that I agreed with laid out here. Now for all I know, there could have been strong rebuttals to the criticisms that could have led to lots of solid discussion. Instead they were often met with exactly that kind of "Why do you watch it then?!" wisecrack. In the end I did stop watching but that line didn't make it happen any sooner.
Tue, Jun 1, 2021, 1:17pm (UTC -6)
Tue, Jun 1, 2021, 2:16pm (UTC -6)
Wed, Jun 2, 2021, 1:38am (UTC -6)
It's not often that someone participates on these threads with 100% negative comments. Most of us are a mix, and that makes sense to me. The "I like this, but I'm not crazy about that, and I really hate this thing over here" is what makes possible interesting give-and-take discussions, especially because no two of us have exactly the same mix of reactions. I've found those discussions a fun hobby, off and on through the years, and I think that's probably true for most of us.
But when someone hates EVERYTHING, from the characters to the writers to the actors and now even to Jammer, without whom this platform for the discussions would not even exist, (and let's not forget that all except the first on that list are real human beings), well, I am genuinely puzzled as to how it's even a fun hobby, and that puzzlement is kind of distracting me , for the moment, from my fun hobby of talking about Trek with other people who enjoy it enough to see both its strengths and its flaws. I'm sure there must be a reason for O'Brien (who I think is probably also the equally angry Chief O'Brien) to be here. I just don't think it's the same reason most of us are here.
Be that as it may, it is no one but Jammer's business who is welcome here, so whatever mode of discussion is fine with Jammer pretty much has to be fine with the rest of us. If I never get my curiosity satisfied about why an unusual commenter came, so be it.
Wed, Jun 2, 2021, 3:18am (UTC -6)
Wed, Jun 2, 2021, 5:51am (UTC -6)
Seems he doesn't hate everything.
Wed, Jun 2, 2021, 12:27pm (UTC -6)
Anyway, at this point I tend to agree with Tomalak: don't we have more interesting things to discuss?
Wed, Jun 2, 2021, 3:56pm (UTC -6)
It's very sad if people instead have to scroll through endless posts that don't even reference the episode but instead focus on something no one will even care about a month from now. I doubt many will bother.
Wed, Jun 2, 2021, 3:57pm (UTC -6)
Thu, Jun 3, 2021, 5:05am (UTC -6)
On the other hand, I fully agree that endlessly talking about it isn't productive. Calling out on the guy's behavior was good, but being stuck on this topic isn't.
Also let's be honest: Such behavior is so common on the internet (even if not here) that it doesn't really merit this kind of interest. Honestly, who f***-ing cares? We should call out such behavior once, and then let it be.
(it's a pity that this had to happen on the thread of such a meh episode, which makes it harder to go back on topic...)
Thu, Jun 3, 2021, 1:27pm (UTC -6)
I actually do think this episode has some value to it. Yeah, Troi's grief at "the loss" comes across kind of over-the-top and even self-absorbed (I mean, she's busy resigning her job and packing up her office when the ship is supposedly about to be destroyed), but the loss of perspective is the very nature of her loss of ability. During the period when she lacks her empathy (in the Betazoid sense of knowing what others are feeling), she also lacks "empathy" in the more ordinary sense. She is becoming a universe unto herself, all that matters in her own little world, as are the one-dimensional beings.
For the beings for whom it is their natural state, there's nothing pathetic about it. But for someone whose entire life had been lived within the minds and emotions of others, it was indeed a "loss," not just for her, but for the people of her community.
There is a lesson in that, I think, about the dangers of CHOOSING to live in too small a world.
Mon, Jul 19, 2021, 6:06am (UTC -6)
Crusher: "The results of the scan are inconclusive."
Troi: "What does THAT mean?"
We also have this episode to thank for the visual of Geordi going skin-diving, presumably wearing nothing but his visor. Lordy.
I did like Picard and Riker's convo about horse riding in the holodeck Himalayas. Picard's line about programming Riker a "suitably docile steed" was hilarious.
Actually the episode was only watchable because of Frakes, whose acting i have really come to admire. His delivery is so natural and unforced, that he alone salvaged a number of the Troi scenes which were otherwise dreadful. Sometimes it's just the look in his eyes, where Frakes can effectively onvey concern, impatience, confusion, compassion, etc.
The directors must have recognized that because there are a lot of "Riker reaction shots" in this and many other episodes that bring things back from the brink. Also in this episode we have his classic stance of putting one leg up and crossing his arms over his knees while chatting with whatever ensign is navigating the ship.
Nevertheless 1.5 stars is all this episode deserves.
Thu, Aug 26, 2021, 2:58am (UTC -6)
The ‘2D creatures / cosmic purple string’ sub plot was only interesting towards the end. Otherwise it was just an excuse for more endless technobabble.
However, there were a few good moments: Troi’s conversations with Guinan, then Data, were enjoyable, as was Data’s earlier explanation for why he didn’t deliver timescales down to seconds anymore!
2 stars seems right - not one of TNG’s best.
Thu, Aug 26, 2021, 3:21am (UTC -6)
Sorry, didn’t mean to rake the ashes. Ignore my musings…
Thu, Aug 26, 2021, 4:06am (UTC -6)
It's the name. O'Brien. He is the lovable everyman. That's why so many of the guys here dislike Keiko, as well. Calling him out on his occasional racism and even worse make him eat healthy. Never got the hate. I thought the two had the most adult relationship on the show. Miles making a sacrifice for his wife's career was a really sweet thing and fairly progressive for the 90s. Plus her hair looked great and where can I get some of those 24th century skin products... ok ok she was not the greatest actor but still... what was I talking about??
Fri, Oct 1, 2021, 6:13pm (UTC -6)
Sat, Oct 2, 2021, 2:05am (UTC -6)
you are not missing much. Plotlines go nowhere, lots of action and a complete disinterest in science. Pike looking at a torpedo explosion through a window is very funny, though.
Sun, Oct 17, 2021, 1:19am (UTC -6)
To be sure, we may find Troi wallowing a bit too deeply and too quickly when knocked off her pedestal and boy does she wallow, but I could relate to the situation as laid out by the writers. The line: "You couldn't be more wrong Deanna," spoken by her formerly grieving patient was always memorable to me. Ouch. No emotional intelligence there, at least not at that point.
Riker, in a pretty good scene, gives Troi a dose of tough love, which doesn't help. Later on, Guinan delivers a reverse-psychology zinger which does. Pretty effective stuff, and I liked the hazard posed by the cosmic string. (I have to remember that that's different from a quantum filament).
It's what I would call a 'quiet life problem episode' where no hostile warship swoops in to threaten anybody. A lot of people find such episodes dull, or 'after school special-ish'. Oh well.
Mon, Oct 18, 2021, 3:05pm (UTC -6)
You have to hand it to that Enterprise crew, they are completely calm when a mere 4 minutes away from total destruction. I would have resembled Commodore Decker.
Submit a comment
◄ Season Index