Review Text
There's a long history in Star Trek of cliffhanger resolutions that don't live up to their setups. In the case of "Hegemony," part one was an efficient and well-made hour, but not one that had me on the edge of my seat in anticipation for part two — and certainly not something that would play as worth two years of waiting in the wake of the writers' and actors' strikes. As I've said many times before, it's really hard to recapture what made "The Best of Both Worlds" special. When you work out the math of what can actually happen with one of these resolutions, there just aren't a ton of innovative options the writers can come up with. Here, they're content to explicitly repeat past examples — specifically, "Best of Both Worlds" itself.
That being said, "Hegemony, Part II" does an okay job of getting us back into the fray of things, starting with the chaotic but clearly conveyed cold open, in which Pike splits the difference on the decision whether to disobey orders in order to protect his kidnapped crew members, or follow orders in the interests of both tactical prudence (the Enterprise is hopelessly outnumbered and outgunned) and galactic peace-keeping (Starfleet doesn't want to start yet another war with the Gorn after having just ended one with the Klingons). Pike stays in the battle just long enough to plant a tracking device on the captive crew members' ship, and then retreats to regroup with Admiral April.
Starfleet's official orders are to not engage the Gorn and respect the Gorn's unilaterally established demarcation line. Pike doesn't like being perceived as "prey." April agrees to "punch back," but in a limited way that can hopefully walk a fine line. This is reasonable tactical debate — although averting a war seems increasingly unlikely when it becomes clear the Gorn incursions are looking like the prelude to a full-scale invasion of the Federation.
Aside from the macro-crisis, we have the personal stakes. Indeed, this is the one place where the outcome might possibly have been in doubt. Captain Batel is infected with Gorn parasites that will soon kill her (and hatch baby Gorn) if a way is not found to disable or remove them. Batel is notably not a regular character. But she is very important to Pike emotionally, as they recently reaffirmed their relationship. Complicating matters and upping the urgency is that Chapel can't put Batel into stasis because she's allergic to the drugs that would do so.
This thread provides the emotional underpinning for the story, with Pike up on the bridge forced to ponder the death of his girlfriend, while Chapel, with Spock's help, attempts to cure Batel in the long tradition of Trekkian medical mysteries. (This has its own emotional underpinnings, as Spock and Chapel, recently broken up, must also resolve their feelings ahead of Chapel leaving for a three-month fellowship with Dr. Roger Korby.) The Spock/Chapel material probably works the best among this multi-threaded story. Meanwhile, Una's Illyrian blood might be the key to Batel's survival chances.
Other plot threads include Scotty (Martin Quinn, newly added to the regular cast) working with Chief Engineer Pelia — who is evidently being established as Scotty's mentor in the near term — to duplicate the miracle cloaking device that allowed Scotty to escape the Gorn on the planet in part one, such that the Enterprise can also render themselves invisible to the Gorn here in part two. Notably, Pelia does the opposite of the "Scotty it" performance guarantee and oversells to Pike what is possible in a short time frame, much to Scotty's horror (perhaps, in fact, pointing to how Scotty's inflated time estimations will eventually come to be). Carol Kane's way-out-there performance is a bit much for what might've worked better if played a little straighter.
We also have the subplot aboard the Gorn ship, where La'an is able to escape from a Gorn digestion pod, which has encased each of the imprisoned crew members and colonists and threatens to eventually digest them and turn them all into fuel. La'an helps a few of the crew to escape, but it's argued that getting them all out before they are digested will take too long and they need to figure out how to get them all out at once. Ortegas is missing part of her hand, which has been digested; this oddly doesn't affect her confidence in her piloting ability, which you'd think might be a piece of the plot.
Fortunately, they stumble upon the answer (conveniently discovered transporter codes that will enable the Enterprise to beam everyone out at once) — but it still seems like a lot of people would be dissolved in the time it takes for the small team to execute their escape plan. This involves a lot of alien goo and slime in the long tradition of alien goo/slime creature features, then eventually a big firefight and a shuttle escape/chase sequence. La'an's continuing nightmares about her brother, who died at the hands of the Gorn years ago, continues to torment her and provide the personal drive to overcome this menace. But Ortegas suffers the worst of the experiences here, being wounded by a Gorn and left hanging in critical condition by the end of the episode.
All of this is slickly executed with the usually top-notch production design, you understand. But it all feels too routine and easy, with assumptions that prove true and work because the script said so. The discovery that the Gorn's extended hibernation cycle can be triggered with an artificially created solar flare (between some binary stars where a portal exists back to the Gorn homeworld, which calls them all back home on instinct) feels like this episode paying homage to "The Best of Both Worlds, Part II" almost too literally. Really, we're solving the current scourge of the galaxy with the exact same hibernation solution?
As I said, it's a math problem: The Gorn have to be dealt with in a way that resolves the threat but leaves them available for Kirk to eventually encounter in "Arena." (Pike notes, in what is perhaps a bit on-the-nose, "I can't help but wonder if we didn't just create a problem for someone else to solve later.") This solution neatly and conveniently does so, allowing all the plot threads to converge — Scotty's miracle cloak, the triggering of the solar flare, the escaping prisoners, the medical emergency — simultaneously. The grave risk of Scotty's dangerous technobabble for generating the solar flare in particular is hilariously dealt with. Pike says, "We'll just turn it off before we blow up." This is what's known as "simplifying for the audience." I enjoyed the line reading nonetheless.
This is all fine, if underwhelming. I like that SNW tries to keep the character cores of the story front and center, even as it does the sci-fi stuff and pyrotechnics. The Spock/Chapel stuff works nicely (with Chapel still leaving for her three-month fellowship at the end), and you feel for these two. And Pike gets particularly emotional over Batel (who pulls through) which is in keeping with the more vulnerable and open-hearted nature of the captain that the writers and Anson Mount have created.
It's nice to have this series back. Hopefully it can surprise us more this season than it does with this cliffhanger resolution.
Previous episode: Hegemony, Part I
Next episode: Wedding Bell Blues
Like this site? Support it by buying Jammer a coffee.




56 comments on this post
Nick
Welp … Just watched. Still dislike the Gorn/Alien gory dumbness and the deus ex machina was kind of another ‘and here a miracle happens’ thing.
Hey maybe I’m just old and cranky.
I’m glad the show is back and we’ll see what transpires …
Andy G
Sleep, Data. Great the first time, kind of meh this time around.
MossBoss
I was so tempted to stick in my Odyssey 5 DVD I've been watching, anything to delay continuing this two parter to kick off the new season.
I was disgusted by the whole thing. From the endless supply of lense flares, to the trashing of the original gorn lore, a sickness was induced in me. The gorn are depicted as cartoon monsters whose evolution makes no sense. 1/10.
Good night ya'll. I'm tired.
Benjamin
It was neat, paint-by-numbers, and spent the whole time building to a preordained conclusion, and I loved it. Heavens, I forgot just how much I missed Anson Mount in this role. He really must have been grown in a lab to play a Star Trek captain.
Norvo
Hegemony II had the impossible task of living up to 2 years of anticipation... and it's a Trek season opener, those very rarely end up being good or memorable. This was a very, very dark hour... Literally. Someone turn on a light, you've paid enough for top level CGI, don't be afraid to show it off.
What we got was such a predictable outing. Of course everyone survives. Of course Scotty pulls a miracle out of his hat with a little help from Pelia (still not sure which one of them has the most cringeworthy accent). And of course Ortegas is still able to pilot that Gorn shuttle even though she's barely conscious... And, of course, she gets to say her catchphrase again. She flies the ship, you know?
The notion that sating the Gorn hatchlings growing inside Batel would somehow put them to sleep is laughable at best. What do hungry babies do once they're fed? Grow some more! Still, at least the resolution didn't come from Orion street drugs or Una's miracle blood.
Does the Enterprise have the facilities to treat the hundreds of colonists? And did they get checked for any Gorn eggs? And how long does it even take to reach Earth from Gorn central?
Things I liked: La'an's moment with M'Benga when he tried some dimestore psychology on her when she was having a flashback to her previous Gorn trauma.
Spock and Chapel not falling for the Discovery curse: having a prolonged heart to heart right in the middle of a crisis. They quickly addressed the issues between them and carried on (until next episode, of course).
Let's hope this is the last we've seen of the Gorn for a good while...
Karl Zimmerman
Completely forgot about Paramount+ dropping episodes in the middle of the night, and didn't get to watch this in the AM. As a result, I just had a pretty distracted viewing during lunch hour. I'll admit my eyes weren't on my phone the entire way through, which may have negatively impacted my viewing, so take this with a grain of salt.
The episode was...fine. Completely met expectations in an unimaginative way. Absolutely nothing unexpected happened. No one died, not even characters that don't have future plot armor, or the rando colonists. We don't get a single realization about the Gorn that helps put them in any broader context, which is a shame, as I really was hoping for something that "humanized" them a bit, setting up for discovering they weren't monsters in Arena.
The episode also, I think, had a few too many subplots, which really hurt the pacing. In total we have:
1. Pike in "captain mode" on the bridge with Una and the rando extras, and talking with Robert April. I don't think this stuff was bad by any means, and it showcased Pike's command style well (collaborative, but able to make tough decisions). That said, separating him from Batel when she was on death's door in in sick bay until the very end of the episode blunted some of the potential drama here. You did get little hints of Pike's nerves in Mount's performance, but his mask of good Starfleet captain is almost perfect until the end, when he gets a chance to break down when they're out of danger. I dunno, I'd have liked a bit more explicitness here - like a scene where Una has to talk him down a bit, or a quiet moment when he visits sick bay. I feel like it would have made his arc here more compelling.
2. Chapel and Spock trying to save Batel's life. I actually think some of my favorite character moments of the episode were in their discussion, as rather than talk about their feelings, they talked around their feelings in a way that felt much more realistic. It provided a good distraction from the contrived medical drama.
3. M'Benga, Ortegas, La'an, and Sam Kirk trying to fight their way out of the Gorn ship. This section should have been an entire episode. There was a real sense of menace and horror missing from the rest of the episode, and I would have liked a chance to understand a bit more about the Gorn as well. They did weave back in La'an's PTSD, and presented it as being in a sense a conclusion to her childhood trauma. I also liked that they tried to give Ortegas something here, with her injuries (as she's the only one on the away mission without plot armor. That said, if they make her say "I fly the ship" again, I think I'll punch my screen.
4. Scotty and Pelia trying to tech the tech to plot the plot. Much slighter overall, but it doesn't need to be a major arc. I like that this younger Scotty is less confident, and Pelia is trying to build up into the older man we know.
The biggest issue across all four subplots is nearly everything relies upon technobabble. Not even established Star Trek lore technobabble - just stuff you know the writers made up on the spot. It's hard to make your characters look smart if they're relying on stuff that you, as the viewer, hasn't even got a hint of existing within the story. Obviously, Trek has done this a ton in the past, but without setup, there cannot be payoff, which is why the solutions offered here (most notably, the disappointing BOBW-like solution to the overall Gorn "issue" are underwhelming.
So yeah, some great character work in a competent, if uninspired, Trek package. Really let down by the Gorn remaining uncomplicated, dumb monsters right through to the end. Hope we don't see them again for quite awhile, if ever.
bradr
Imagine if the writing could hold a candle to the SFX and atmosphere teams. Sound design, incredible. Visuals incredible. Everything in this show is top tier fantastic except the writing.
What a boring hour of TV. The gorn are a stupid, boring enemy. The solution was out of nowhere. No stakes anywhere, the ending winds up exactly how you would have guessed 2 years ago. Tragic.
TJ
I didn't go into this episode with high expectations, because I knew the show runners had to wrap up this business with the Gorn efficiently lest they tread deeper into violating established Trek history. The Fx was fabulous, as always. The plot ran at a rather exceptional pace, and the action sequences were engaging. The show moved the Spock/Chapel storyline forward a bit as they raced to save Patel. And the ending was a nice touch, as I like this relationship between Pike and Patel, because it feels real and unforced... However, knowing that they couldn't possibly keep the Gorn around this season, I found it hard to get fully engaged in what was happening because it was just about that, moving past the Gorn. I would REALLY love to see this show get back to "exploring strange new worlds and seeking out new life and new civilizations". Let's hope we see that over the next 25 episodes that take us to the end of the series... 2.5 stars.
Gorn with the Wind
3/4 stars.
SNW does its thing. Top marks for the VFX, action, and good old fashioned problem solving via scientific gobbledygook.
While the acting and writing remains uneven, our new Scotty shines. I especially enjoyed how he and Pelia played off of one other. Spock and Chapel also had some nice moments which brought resolution to their romantic subplot.
The only knock is that it proved too predictable. Everything got the reset button and our characters are on more or less the same trajectory as ever before. That’s the flaw of all prequels, I suppose.
Lawrence Bullock
I've missed a good solid Star Trek with ties to TOS and the better moments of TNG. There's something about both of the episodes that just hit me right.
Were they perfect? Come on. It's hard to recapture lightning in a bottle. Trek is too popular and too familiar to be perfect to everyone.
The perception filters of one individual are different from another and one person's disdain of Trelane is another's warm fuzzy feeling at seeing a nod to an episode you'd never guess would be mined for homage.
I'm growing fond of the icons being pulled out their old tropes into something new. It's the way of life and a natural thing.
And also enjoying the whipsaw from whimsy into darkness at the drop of a hat. Why not? Let a thousand flowers bloom.
Here's my litmus test: Do I immediately want to watch the episodes again? Because here's the terrible truth: I can rewatch TOS and TNG episodes and have fun doing it. Likewise with DS9 and Voyager.
Discovery? Not so much. Maybe that will change but I'm not so sure.
Anyway, I'm glad SNW exists. Glad that Star Trek continues to boldly go....wherever it goes. And that's not just the drugs talking, but they help.
Kidding.
Tim C
I have two things to say up front:
(1) God I'm glad to have this show back!
(2) I didn't really like this story!
My major criticism of Hegemony Part 1 was that putting aside SNW's typically excellent acting and production values, the plot itself wasn't exciting enough. My basis for that criticism was that since this was a prequel show, trying to jazz up your core audience of Star Trek nerds with "OMG WILL THE GORN INVADE??" is DOA. We know they won't, therefore doubling down on the fakeout in the way that Part 2 does here just feels kind of... desperate? The most successful SNW episodes rely heavily on character drama to juice the stakes, and there simply wasn't enough of it here.
To be blunt: Pike's romance with Batel is not enough to hang a story on. At least, not with the way they've told it thus far. Pike has the Beeping Chair Of Damocles hanging over his head, and that is far, far more interesting than watching a romance we already know is ultimately doomed because we also know that he's walking away with Vina when all is said and done.
There was lots of stuff I liked in the episode! Stuff that I like in *every* SNW episode! Perfectly cast actors selling the hell out their performances. Energetic direction without the over-indulgence of Disco or Abrams. Awesome VFX starring the OG USS Enterprise. Cheesy music harking back to TOS. It's all up to snuff.
It's just a shame they couldn't have been used in service of a more interesting story, where the outcome wasn't a foregone conclusion.
Cynic
@Tim C
The biggest problem with "the Beeping Chair Of Damocles" is that not only do we the viewers know that these prequel characters can't/won't die but so does Pike. A 99.9% chance the Enterprise will be destroyed when they light it up? Pike knows for a fact he can't/won't die here and now, so that means it's safe to try.
John
@Cynic
Pike knows he (and Spock, I suppose) can't die or be too badly hurt, so the Enterprise won't blow up with him on it. However, he doesn't know Uhura, Chapel, etc. are also safe, so he's still risking someone getting a console blowing up in their face every time they run into something. That sort of thing is going to keep him from saying screw it, we're perfectly safe.
Sarjenka's Brother
I liked this two-parter and the general Gorn arc pretty well, but I didn't love it. I guess I'm a bit bothered by the canon-busting aspects of it, but it wasn't anything too egregious. After all, they were in one TOS episode and one Enterprise episode, best I can recall. So it's not like they're a cornerstone species. I'm glad we're done with them in SNW, though.
I really like this cast a lot, especially Anson Mount. If nothing else, the man fuels my sex dreams. The show is a big improvement over "Discovery" and the bulk of "Picard."
I'm looking forward to the rest of season. Hoping for episodes less dark than the Gorn stuff but not as silly as the musical episode. Some subtle humor and some classic, inspirational, good-guys-winning episodic Trek would be nice in these troubled times.
grumpy_otter
I liked the Gorn as an enemy, until this outing. They seemed cartoonish instead of scary as they have previously,
This episode felt like trying to do too many things at once and I wished they'd saved the "put the Gorn to sleep" solution for a later episode. I was really invested in saving Batel so got annoyed every time we were pulled away from that. I think that and rescuing the away team and colonists would have been plenty for this episode.
I feel overwhelmed with technobabble and usually I don't mind it but it felt like they were trying to do so many things that they HAD to solve everything with a babble solution. I like all the characters and so didn't mind any of those interactions, but the solutions to all the problems felt contrived. I'd give it 2/4 stars.
Joseph B
Like others here, I was a little peeved with the "Lets put the Gorn to sleep" plotline. It just veers too close to the BoBW. On the other hand, I guess if you feel the need to crib, at least you're cribbing form the best; and it does neatly button up the Gorn story so they can pass it along to TOS.
Other than that, I really enjoyed the entertainment value of the ep. It was at least a competent Part 2 resolution to the two year(!) old Cliffhanger. Really glad to have the show back!! 6.5/10.
Rahul
I think this is what sci-fi has become these days -- all-out highly arbitrary action adventure at a break-neck pace with some relationship moments thrown in. It's pretty superficial entertainment for the masses, not much thought-provoking or intelligence to be found. But it is decent to watch given that it is based on classic Star Trek.
My big issue is there's just so much implausible stuff that has to go perfectly right -- are we supposed to feel like Pike's crew are heros? I can understand 1 or 2 things really pushing it but here it's like 4 or 5 -- like turning the ship into a star? The transportation of all the colonists? Like ramming the Gorn ship and then just carrying on into the radiation zone etc. etc.
I did think it was interesting that the Gorn could be put to sleep (not unlike the Borg) and how their periods of attack coincide with stellar phenomena.
It's still disappointing that we get no further with the Gorn on their intelligence -- like the point I said in my comments about the first part of this episode: how was the demarcation line negotiated? That it was negotiated -- shouldn't there be a way of communication already established?
As for Pike in this episode, he was unimpressive as usual. Everybody else comes up with the ideas but he doesn't really bring anything to the table.
The cast is hit & miss -- too bad the Gorn didn't kill Ortegas. Her stupid lines are a hallmark of this series. And anybody could have flown that Gorn fighter. The Carol Kane character is almost as annoying, but I think everybody else is OK to good.
2.5 stars for Hegemony, Part II -- I think this is big sci-fi action adventure for today's masses that will tick most of the boxes. Occasionally classic Trek has shows like this but there are enough other ones with far more intelligence and less suspension of disbelief required. I still don't like what this series is doing with the Gorn and will reiterate that it should have just come up with another alien species to do what the Gorn are doing here.
Tim o
Falls flat like every other part 2 to open a season. Why do they keep doing this? The cliffhanger at the end of part one is the big payoff, watching part 2 feels like a chore. Episode 2 feels like the start of a new season.
Maq
When I start getting irritated because it seems quite silly I realises that it really is a good TOS remake, Plenty of their solutions an stories were extremly silly and stupid but you liked it becaus it mostly had some sort of twist.
This plot was as good as plenty of the TOS stories but technically / fx fantastic and the charaterisation good.
Still, compared with part 1 that was quite exciting part 2 was just a sort of emergecy wrap up. I am not to impressed.
BZ
I like how they didn't end up trying the solution that only had a 14% chance of working. I seem to remember an episode of Voyager where Janeway did just that and everyone survived.
Caloceptri
What a pleasure to read your reviews again, Jammer.
I’m not one to harp on continuity and canon (chaining scriptwriters to a strain of fanboy obsessiveness that exalts continuity as goodness, only to then have yhe same fanboys want to rip your neck off for being unoriginal for having to re-summon a plot or a concept that was introduced years past is a screenwriter’s own Kobayashi Maru), but when an episode is as glumly efficient - and nothing else - in its execution as is this one, continuity errors come to the fore by default.
When the name “Gorn” was mentioned at the end of “Arena,” Kirk (and more to the point, Spock, Scotty and Uhura) have a reaction that suggests complete unfamiliarity with the Gorn. In “Hegemony Part Ii,” we are again shown what the Gorn look like, so the “I put the Gorn to sleep” hibernation, executed without a droplet of imagination) just doesn’t work as a continuity hand-wave.
More to the point, though, there have been 21 episodes of Strange New Worlds now and 4 of them have been Gorn-centered. Why do this if not to offer an interesting take on the dusted-off Gorn that doesn’t play like multiple “Aliens” ticking time bombs? (the pilot seat… Ripley operating the big mechanical thingie, anyone? Batel….The bursting baby, La’An-the PTSD flashbacks; maybe the writers cribbed from an Alien and Aliens Cliffs Notes).
Arena (whatever you thought of the episode; Janmer’s. 1 1/2-star take makes complete sense to me), had a message at the end that hadn’t been beaten to death yet, given when the show aired in TOS’ run - maybe humans have more in common with other life forms, including those we find repulsive - than we think. Maybe we ARE in the wrong sometimes. There is no message in the SNW crop of Gorn episodes. No message; no attempt to portray the Gorn as something other than menacing space lizards with lousy dental work.
It’s awfully tough to not notice the glaring continuity errors when we’re given such a rote and regressive rerun. Hopefully in the 25 episodes that remain, the Gorn will not return.
Oh wait, silly me, the end of Wedding Bell Blues. Spoiler alert-sorry. “Sorry” indeed.
Nick
First off I'm glad I can comment here in the 'present day' after completing Enterprise 20 years later and finding this site. Jammer is a good read and the comments are often interesting.
In any event ... my collection of two-cents remarks and worth every penny:
'Arena' has gotten mixed reviews over the years; the rubber suit was silly but it WAS 1966 after all. I think it was a classic ... not only for the message-ending but the fact that Kirk had to go way back to basics ... remembering how gunpowder is made ... and that unlike Trek ever since TNG, the solution wasn't bombarding the planet with tachyon rays channeled through the deflector array on a subspace microfrequency powered by the warp coil plasma inductors ...
Bok R'Mor
It's good to be back enjoying a review and the attendant comments.
Nothing greatly surprising in this episode – which can be summarised as 'Pew pew; get away from her you BITCH; sleep' – with the usual ups (Anson Mount and most of the rest of the cast) and usual downs (plotholes, plot contrivances, playing fast and loose with its own internal continuity). But it's all for the spectacle. It isn't TOS, or TNG, or even DS9, VOY or ENT for that matter. We're never going to get a morality play or anything particularly challenging. It's a straightforward popcorn episode that doesn't pretend to be anything but a checklist of references to other episodes and franchises. That's the best we can hope for in 2025, sadly.
Second the point that it was a missed opportunity not to kill off Ortegas.
SlackerInc
I wrote a quick reaction to the episode a couple days ago but neglected to post it until now. I haven't read the comments or Jammer's review yet, but a cursory glance suggests I am lining up with others in my 2.5 stars take. Here's what I noted while watching:
That was...okay. 2.5 stars out of 4. I hope we are now done with all this pseudo-ALIENS Gorn nonsense.
If they can jam enemy comms to prevent them from coordinating, shouldn't this be SOP in a battle situation?
Why are we still getting two-dimensional maps of Gorn territory? 🤔
Is the actor playing Uhura wearing some kind of hairpiece? Her hair looks like a cap and the hairline looks awfully low on her forehead and unnatural to me.
"We'll just turn it off before we get blown up." Lol, that was some pretty good Pikery.
Nick
I like the two dimensional maps. They harken back to TOS. Remember the Romulan neutral zone map and Balance of Terror? Maybe not, I’m pretty old and I remember that kind of stuff.
Also, Ortegas is garnering major hate these days. I’m agnostic. I save my ugh-reflex for Carol Kane, who has never not been annoying.
Bok R'Mor
@SlackerInc:
'Is the actor playing Uhura wearing some kind of hairpiece? Her hair looks like a cap and the hairline looks awfully low on her forehead and unnatural to me.'
Apparently she's wearing a cap, yes. The actress' hair had (for obvious reasons) grown since the previous episode was filmed – you can see her new style in the next episode – so they tried (and failed) to recreate the very short hair she had. I agree it looks odd.
MidshipmanNorris
I came away from the ep feeling like it was a powerhouse of a Trek episode. I think 2.5 is selling it short. It doesn't have the bathic quippiness of previous seasons (or Picard or Discovery)'s writing. It's got a real sense of urgency to it, a real spark. The quippy humor is still there, but in measured amounts that don't tend to overstay their welcome. Pella is a bit much, though. I can barely understand what Carol Kane is saying (don't care for subtitles tbh).
Still, it's got Scotty, it's got Spock, Uhura, Chapel, Pike, they're doing space diplomacy things and there's a whole personal emotional angle going on through it that doesn't feel forced and man, I just really liked this episode. It feels like Star Trek is back, to me. I missed you, Star Trek!
Dave
And how do they get away from this huge fleet of gorn ships and stop a full scale invasion ??
Super easy , barely an inconvenience!
Kilby
Just a couple of quickies:
Pelia bursting into engineering, to Scotty: "the Gorn are here!" (or coming, close enough). And then he slams his techno-device on, shazam! Well played.
And, Pike, eyes first skyward, then down, at Batel's beside, starts to pray out loud. Subtle, nice touch.
Chris W
Feeling good we all mostly seem to be on the same page with regards to the mediocre quality in this episode.
I can't help but wonder how I would view this episode if I was exposed to this during the time when I was exposed to TNG. It's not like they didn't have episodes where technobabble came in to save the day at the last minute. This doesn't seem to be any different, but I still can't help but feel like the solution is too convenient, whereas the Best Of Both Worlds solution seems incredibly clever. (To be honest, though, I think it would've taken awhile for me to draw parallels between this and BoBW had it not been for Jammer's mention in his review.)
One thing I think SNW gets right is their ability to bounce ideas off of each other, even in the heat of the moment. It makes everyone seem incredibly engaged and a valuable contributor.
I'm feeling bad for Melissa Navia. It's not her fault her Ortega character is consistently reciting "I'm the pilot" lines. They've got my curiosity piqued with the injuries she's had to endure. Definitely wondering if they'll do anything with that.
theBgt
I am glad this show is back.
But...
I am frustrated this great crew/cast doesn't get the writing they deserve.
Way too many "miracles" had to happened to have a happy end.
Still it wasn't bad...l enjoyed it, but mostly for the crew not the story.
Trek fan
Two and a half stars — I totally agree with Jammer’s main points here.
@Jammer I’ll take a stab at articulating for you Star Trek’s problem with two-part cliffhangers: Part one always promises exciting new changes to the status quo; part two almost always delivers a formulaic letdown / reset button with no sense of actual stakes or character growth.
So we get forgettable 1990s two-parters (like TNG in old San Francisco, Voyager in Sarah Silverman’s earth, etc.) that deliver superficial diversions / change of scenery without ending with anything memorable or that builds to anything later.
In the exceptional two parters, that doesn’t happen because you get the sense that the characters (and/or our sense of them) have evolved or changed in some irreparable way. In other words, something big changes in the end. The Menagerie on TOS (which I saw before catching the original Cage pilot) gives us a deeper / more complex sense of Spock’s loyalty and personal sense of relationships, and it gives us a unique reverse-tragic mini for Captain Pike, from wheelchair to happily ever after. The Best of Both Worlds develops the Borg as adversaries and leaves Picard fundamentally changed / scarred in a way that feeds his character in later stories like First Contact. The two part premier of Voyager, which promised way more than the series ever delivered, gave us an exciting setup where all the key characters’ relationships were reshuffled by the end of part 2 and some interesting pieces / tensions were teed up for future development.
This part 2 of SNW was strictly by the numbers. It looked great but was the perfect episode to play in the background while catching up on Jammer discussion threads. Basically it’s a long, tedious slog of people babbling in future speak and pushing buttons until the Gorn went away. The most interesting sequences in the Gorn digestion pods felt directly lifted from 1986’s Aliens — both the production design and James Horner-esque score with menacing horn parts in a low register — without being nearlly as engaging.
Finally, I think the episode missed a big opportunity to become memorable by leaving Ortegas alive at the end — Jammer mentioned the utter pointlessness of her injury, which played no role in the plot. I would add that her survival of being impaled by a Gorn and then immediately piloting a ship was highly unbelievable. Frankly I wish they had let her die; she’s the least interesting character and this show could use a bit of Discovery’s willingness to move characters along.
Incidentally, I’d like to point out that people wouldn’t be complaining about “canons” if this series hadn’t set itself up as a prequel incorporating characters we’ve already seen for decades. I’m not interested in discussing “canon.” My problem is that the show’s entire setup paints it into a creative corner — essentially every episode has to choose between trying new stuff that doesn’t fit previously established character arcs that longtime fans see as coming in “the future” of the timeline, or else sticking so closely to the established universe that we watch with boredom because we know that certain characters (Spock, Kirk, Scotty, etc.) will never marry, die, or experience anything else unexpected. That sucks, frankly, and suggests a franchise that has run out of ideas.
At least Discovery had the clever idea of leaping forward to the 32nd century and providing a plausible explanation for why its creative departures had no effects on the Trek universe’s timeline. It didn’t do anything terribly interesting with that fresh start in its last two seasons, but I admired the effort to show us something new. Still not seeing anything very “strange or new” in SNW.
Bok R'Mor
@Trek fan
'Finally, I think the episode missed a big opportunity to become memorable by leaving Ortegas alive at the end — Jammer mentioned the utter pointlessness of her injury, which played no role in the plot. I would add that her survival of being impaled by a Gorn and then immediately piloting a ship was highly unbelievable. Frankly I wish they had let her die; she’s the least interesting character and this show could use a bit of Discovery’s willingness to move characters along.'
Agreed. It's curious that the writers and producers wouldn't even dare to kill Ortegas off, even though doing so would have actually given some consequence to the series for once. Instead it seems we'll have yet another predictable PTSD arc centred around one of the main characters. (Or, rather, how the writers and producers think PTSD works.)
Incidentally, her hand is magically fully restored in the next episode (unremarked upon) even though she's clearly missing fingers here. SNW doesn't even respect its own internal continuity from episode to episode (of course, we can come up with off-screen explanations of a prosthesis, but why should we?).
Also, the whole tell-don't-show mess of having a barely conscious Ortegas be the only one who can pilot the Gorn podracer. All she does is sit on it and grasp its handles and hey presto, let's fly. We're given no indication of any unique skills here, but Ortegas herself says 'It has to be me'. In NuTrek reckless self-assuredness is always an inalienable, incontrovertible human right. Even when you're half dead. If Ortegas had passed out while flying that podracer they would have all died in the service of her stubborn self-realisation.
Weiss
Wow MossBoss with Odyssey 5 reference. I watch that show again every 5 years for 25 yrs, last time with my wife. Need to watch with my kids (now i watch Shiloh and Bros with them a nice starter scifi space ship alien horror kids show... it feels like the patchwork fun that original TOS was with parents watching with kids)
Great show and last of a breed which didnt have memberberries and shows that force characters and plot to stupidity to force an undeserved over clever cliffhanger.
SlackerInc
@Bok R'Mor: Thanks for the info! Haven't seen the second episode yet.
"In NuTrek reckless self-assuredness is always an inalienable, incontrovertible human right. Even when you're half dead."
Hahaha, so true.
@Trek fan: "Frankly I wish they had let her die; she’s the least interesting character..."
Cosigned.
Nick
I was very indulgent with this episode, because it flowed well with well-acted moments throughout. What to say about the Gorn...no, they're not my Gorn, I gave up on that species with the Enterprise series portrayal. These Gorn are monster space-locusts, and I was fine with the solution to be a big bright light to lure the insects back home. This did not have to be complex, even though motivations and a Gorn society that made sense would have elevated the episode.
Points: a) what use would only several hundred colonists be for fuel, and fuel for what?!?; b) how do you have an intelligent, space faring race of these guys (all they do is compete to the death with each other)?; c) Ortegas should absolutely not have been able to pilot the Gorn ship, but I liked her irritation at being challenged over it.
The Gorn pilot open-mouthed shots made me think of the Spaceballs chestburster, or a dog trying to see if it's in trouble or not, so I was more laughing than trembling.
Three stars, liked it a lot, and was a great way to pull my fiance into Star Trek after years of resistance (forehead aliens kept her from trying out any episodes before).
Bok R'Mor
@Nick:
'Points: a) what use would only several hundred colonists be for fuel, and fuel for what?!?'
I took it to be a swipe from the Matrix. I doubt it was even intentional. NuTrek is an interminable parody-parade of references to famous franchises of the past 25 years, stewing in a sort of subconscious pop-cultural marinade the writers and producers probably aren't even aware they're copying half the time (to be fair to them).
Trek being broken down to slop by newer and more aggressive digestive juices, if you like.
Quincy
Not much to say about this. Jammer was more kind to it than I would've been.
Star Trek has never been all that great about depicting objects in space or the proper scale of such things. But either they're getting worse or I'm just getting more sensitive to it. It never used to bother me that much. Voyager's opening sequence where it's shadow is going across the ice ring that's so thick it might as well be a Dyson ring. Or Nebulas that are so dense you could hide your spaceship in it. That didn't matter much. But now that opening sequence where the camera pulls away from the star and two planets that are so close together they should be pulled apart as they plunge into the star. It just made me cringe so hard I pulled a muscle.
I really hope the Chapel x Spock relationship is over. It turns my stomach every time it's on screen. It's been putrid for awhile, but now it's unfathomably disgusting. They wanted to rehabilitate Nurse Chapel's character. Okay, fine. But there's no need to $#!% all over Spock's character and turn him into to some maudlin moron who wants to have a heart to heart, when 1) the ship is in mortal danger, 2) someone is dying on the operating table, and 3) there's an alien parasite gestating inside the patient that will kill everybody on the ship if it emerges. Not only that, but they failed to actually rehabilitate Chapel's character. They just turned her into the modern day feminazi who's a hot pocket thot rocket that "decenters men" while simultaneously letting the locker room plow her plantation.
Please, kill Ortega's annoying @$$ off. I haven't wanted a character gone so badly since Tasha Yar.
Janok
I thought it was a decent episode that hit all the main points. Had it been produced in the Berman era, I think it would be considered a middle of the pack season opener. When we compare this episode to TNG: “Descent Pt II” or VOY: “Unimatrix Zero Pt II” it’s similar in pacing for that time.
Contrary to some of the commenters here, I do like the Gorn reinterpretation in SNW. It’s not original, it feels very similar to xenomorphs from the Alien franchise, but the way they’re portrayed in SNW is much more alien and horrifying than the TOS version. I’m curious how their culture has evolved and become an interstellar power, how they communicate with the Federation / other neighbors and establish borders. Why weren’t they at the Khitomer conference in TUC and why haven’t they been seen since TOS? Does a Federation science ship inject a CME every year to keep them docile, and the one time they forgot is TOS: “Arena”?
Watching the SNW crew solve the problem is in the best traditions of Trek. Pike asks the bridge crew for options in a short but concise conversation. Not the DIS method of having an entire thesis spoken at lightspeed at the audience. This is a real problem-solving in a crunch vibe and I think it works.
I was disappointed in the prison busting scene. La’an and co. should not be in any condition to fight, especially Ortegas missing half her hand. And then we see a shot of tens of Gorn soldiers shooting at them form multiple directions in an exposed area with little cover, and none of them hit anything. Are the Gorn incapable of aiming? Also, both La’an and Ortegas are also able to figure out a completely alien language software and control system while half melted and in a time crunch (and in Ortegas case, being shot at, although their aim is so bad maybe this isn’t a factor). The Gorn fighters also magically cannot hit their own fighter piloted by a half dead pilot who just figured out 2 minutes ago how to fly it. It’s contrived and stretching credibility. Would it not be simpler for La’an and Co. to find a hatch leading to an escape pod or something, which they wait out the battle and get picked up later?
Emotional scenes with Spock, Chapel, Batel, and Pike are all well performed and believable. It reinforces my perception that the strength of this episode is character interactions and dialogue. I would prefer if nuTrek focused more on that and less on space shooty.
Looking forward to the rest of SNW S3 and what they have to offer.
Bok R'Mor
I can't help feeling that it doesn't bode well for SNW (and interest in Trek generally) that the first two episodes have been out nearly a week and there barely 40 comments here so far. Compare that with previous seasons of SNW, PIC and even DIS and there was far more buzz.
I don't know if it's because people have simply moved on, or whether it's because it was more difficult to actually watch the new season. Even though I subscribe to a streaming service that specifically advertised itself as 'the home of Trek' in my country (and which had a full-on nationwide bus shelter and train station marketing blitz for SNW last season), this season isn't being made available until 4 August here. I also subscribe to other streaming services which have NuTrek, but none are showing this season of SNW. It took me hours to find a solution from other sources. This isn't the way to sell people to your product.
Bok R'Mor
Relevant link: the outstanding Nitpicking Nerd on YouTube proves in less than a minute that the writers and producers either don't remember or don't care what happened in their own cliffhanger:
https://youtu.be/UXHNEb6eV4s?si=CZYnCUuM3Sx5ygbt
Ouch.
Nic
I've said it before, I'll say it again: the Gorn aren't interesting villains. I vaguely remember in "Arena" (as bad as that episode was) Kirk saying something like "he looks like a monster, but I know he is an intelligent starship captain like myself". Even that had more depth than the way the Gorn have been depicted in this series. I hope this is the last we see of them.
Although (unfavourable) comparisons to "BoBW" are apt (with the 'put them to sleep' solution), the cliffhanger resolution I was most reminded of while watching this one is "Unimatrix Zero", with the "tragic romance" angle and the insane plan that works only because the writers say it does. 2.5 stars it is.
Although very little here was remotely fresh (and Pelia has got to be one of the most annoying regular *female* characters the franchise has ever had), I found it interesting that they put a minor character like Batel in the "will she die?" situation. If it had been a regular character, we'd know they'd survive, which would undercut the suspense. The fact that Batel survives came as a bit of a surprise to me, though I can't say I cared much one way or the other.
Bryan
What is there to say about this fairly unremarkable and predictable resolution to the Gorn storyline?
Well, for one, it seems to wrap up the recurring Gorn plot thread, hopefully for good. That alone is a point in its favor. I appreciated the largely non-violent solution, though I found it disappointing that the Gorn were once again reduced to primal, instinct-driven creatures. Despite their technologically advanced civilization, they're portrayed here as essentially big, dumb bugs. The episode borrows heavily from Best of Both Worlds, but the same conceit — foiling an alien menace through exploitation of their base instincts — was far more satisfying and coherent with the Borg.
The only real surprise? That every single imperilled character made it out alive, even those who seemed narratively expendable. I fully expected one or two of them, like Batel or Ortegas, to be written out (especially with Scotty potentially joining the crew). The episode even dangled a possible successor in “Mitchels,” a conveniently skilled new pilot who emerged from nowhere. But alas, no redshirts were harmed. Maybe next time.
On the topic of Ortegas and Mitchels, there's an odd and recurring thematic beat in SNW: characters stubbornly pushing through injury or fatigue because they alone must carry the burden. It's framed as heroism, but it often comes across as arrogance. In a military or exploratory context where others are trained and available, refusing relief seems reckless, not noble.
It was interesting how La'an's trauma was both a distraction and a literal lifesaver. Her psychological scarring enabled her to partially resist the Gorn's induced sleep and eventually rescue the others. That said, her decision to abandon the still-imprisoned crew and colonists seemed deeply questionable. From a plot standpoint, I get it: you can't have a horde of extras cluttering the rest of the episode, but it undermines the supposed urgency of their imminent digestion and gruesome demise. Time was clearly of the essence, yet we're meant to accept her tactical retreat as necessary.
All in all, the episode feels like a checklist of modern Nu-Trek storytelling conventions: fast-paced, action-driven, emotionally earnest, but light on the things that used to define Star Trek, like philosophy, speculative science, and intellectual conflict. Continuity is treated casually at best. The soon-to-be infamous "He didn't say immediately" retcon is emblematic of the show's disregard even for internal consistency. You start to wonder if Paramount+ intends to do a full TOS reboot series in order to revision /all/ of TOS in the same Nu-Trek image and repair the discontinuities that way - by replacing the original story lines with something else. If so, I sincerely hope they reconsider!
Original Nick
I’m the Nick who thinks the Gorn update is unnecessary and ridiculous, and who hated the I-hope-he’s-not-Trelane.
Just clearing up.
Have a fine day!
Mephyve
Pike, Spock, Uhura Scottie all on the same ship. I'm willing to bet they'll come out ok
Mephyve
I win
davidw2
What's the point of this episode?
I think this is the fifth episode where the Gorn attack the crew for no reason. What's the moral?
What's the science fiction? What characters learn anything from the science fiction allegory?
Why do people just disobey Pike and have them just sit on his knees and not know what to do?
Bruno Jupiter
I enjoyed the episode. But I'm glad this Gorn arc is finally coming to an end. They're such one-dimensional cardboard villains that it's hard to believe they developed an entire warp-capable empire that spanned over a large portion of the Alpha Quadrant.
Heck, in that scene inside the Gorn ship, I was almost expecting Sigourney Weaver to burst out of one of those cocoons and start shooting.
Data's Lawyer
"The discovery that the Gorn's extended hibernation cycle can be triggered with an artificially created solar flare (between some binary stars where a portal exists back to the Gorn homeworld, which calls them all back home on instinct) feels like this episode paying homage to "The Best of Both Worlds, Part II" almost too literally. Really, we're solving the current scourge of the galaxy with the exact same hibernation solution?"
My thoughts exactly as I watched the episode. Come on, folks, come up with an original idea for once! Sheesh!
Anonymius
I've decided not to watch this episode (or any further episode of snw involving the gorn), on principle, because I don't like what the show has done with the Gorn, in a way that makes you think whether Kirk should have bashed the gorn captain's head in with a rock rather than make peace.
John B
Underwhelming episode. I have a headache from all my eye rolling during the episode. Seems this is common malady caused by viewing current Trek.
Gorn are stupid. Why are updates of old Trek species unwatchable?
And i needed subtitles every time Scotty and Pelia spoke.
Bob
@Chris W
"I can't help but wonder how I would view this episode if I was exposed to this during the time when I was exposed to TNG. It's not like they didn't have episodes where technobabble came in to save the day at the last minute. This doesn't seem to be any different, but I still can't help but feel like the solution is too convenient"
I think the difference is that a lot of the time Data and/or Geordie would go off and spend some time trying to figure out a solution, even if it made little sense to the viewer at the end. In this everybody just seems to be far too clever to be believable and just throws out ideas until they magically land on the solution.
The suspense is not in "will they figure out the solution?", it's purely "will they be able to pull it off?". We have a pretty good idea that the answer will be yes of course, even in TNG, but jumping straight to the second half seems less satisfying somehow, and is why these newer Star Trek episodes feel more like action films.
TNG (and TOS) followed a pretty standard structure a lot of the time - in the intro a problem is identified, it becomes more of an issue for the first 5 or 10 minutes, they spend 15 minutes trying to figure out a solution with the odd false start, 5 minutes implementing it and then 2 minutes showing the aftermath.
Natalya
I mean... they had to somehow connect this idiotic 2-parter into what would eventually become 'Arena'. Putting the 'gorn' under forced hybernation is a - effective - cop out. Still a cop out and a easy-way-out, but... at least it makes some kind of sense. I'm glad someone there realized that having the 'gorn' invade the Federation 10 years before Kirk's first contact with them, would be stupid.
Some pretty good 'escape from hatchery' scenes that may as well have been copied 1 for 1 from any Alien movie. Whatever. La'an is a unit as usual. +1 star there. 'gorn' are NOT Gorn. Hill I wil die on. Ortegas' PTSD from the lizard impaling her into the stomach is realistic (the fact that she SURVIVED that, not so much XD ).
Pike showing he can do more then be by-the-book drone, in actually going into enemy space after his people, and making a case in front of April. Good on him. Some suspenseful if contrived plot... fineee. Whatever. + another star, altogether.
I'm gona give this 2/4 stars. Barely. It is better then PT1. But that's a low bar.
Mr Picard
I just watched this after finishing a rewatch of DS9. Wow is it ever lacking in comparison despite millions more special effects.
God - who are these writers? Pike literally gets told off by his own ensign - saying she will stay put. Pike nods like a little schoolboy. I think in a cut scene Pike burns his man card as he makes soufflé. The he lets his dieing girlfriend console him and hold him like a baby because HE is the one traumatized.
Give me Sisko any day please.
Henson
The main problem with this episode is that there are too many plot threads. Every character gets a little something, and as a result there is no time to properly develop the main story, which already has a lot of moving parts. This issue with the Gorn should be a huge threat, but before you know it it's over. The result is that I'm watching the entire episode and feeling absolutely Nothing because nothing has any degree of substance behind it.
Rewriting it, this should be firmly focused on Pike. We don't need to spend time in sickbay, except for the Pike storyline worrying about his girlfriend (heck, we can devote time getting rid of the Gorn infection next episode!), and the Scotty material is entirely unnecessary. We don't even necessarily need to follow an escape from Gorn captivity; rather, the focus could be on Pike not knowing whether his captured officers are okay, dwelling on the unknown consequences of his command decisions.
Noni
My god, they reuse that shot of La'an's creepy brother even more frequently than Shippuden shows us Naruto sitting sadly on that damn swing.
Submit a comment