"Chapter 10: The Passenger"

The Mandalorian

Air date: 11/6/2020
Written by Jon Favreau
Directed by Peyton Reed

Review by Jamahl Epsicokhan

Djarin agrees to take on a frog-like passenger and her container of preserved unfertilized eggs in exchange for more intel on Mandalorians that allegedly live on her planet. The eggs are important to her — she needs to take them home to her husband to be fertilized — so when a hungry Baby Yoda starts eating them, of course we're hoping Mando stops him before things get too far out of hand.

I find it hilarious how the internet lost its collective mind over Baby Yoda eating Frog Lady's eggs. I read at least two think pieces on How Badly The Writers Miscalculated. Gimme a break. This was some mildly dark humor that grew from a place of simple logic. The Child is hungry. The eggs look like food. It's math. And yet, this is apparently the biggest controversy in the history of the show.

Shrug. "The Passenger" is another example of how this series uses simple stories (in this case, one that doesn't notably advance the series' plot) and executes them in great tactile detail, particularly with its physical settings and its set pieces. Take, for example, when Mando runs from the X-wing cops who want to run his plates. This leads to an extended, visually impressive aerial sequence through the mountains of an ice world that would stand up against any sequence in the Star Wars films. Ultimately, our crew ends up stranded in a crashed, broken-down Razor Crest in an ice cave.

This ice cave has a nest of alien spider eggs. Lots of them. When the Child tries to eat one — Don't do that!, we all yell at the TV screen — its massive mother and many, many, many siblings come scurrying out with a swarm attack, in an action-horror sequence that's impressive because it just keeps going and going and building and building as our heroes get ever more boxed-in. That they are saved with a last-second deus ex machina is okay, I guess, because they sure looked doomed up until then. There's not much to this episode, but it glides by effortlessly, boiling up the intensity just when it needs to.

Previous episode: Chapter 9: The Marshal
Next episode: Chapter 11: The Heiress

Like this site? Support it by buying Jammer a coffee.

◄ Season Index

15 comments on this post

🔗

Latex Zebra
Fri, Nov 20, 2020, 3:10am (UTC -5)

No need for ice spiders. Horrifying...

Fun episode though.

Paul M.
Fri, Nov 20, 2020, 4:18pm (UTC -5)

A very simple episode, probably the simplest and slightest to date, but that's okay. It does what it set out to do with great aplomb.

I commented on another review page on this site how The Mandalorian is very basic -- in a positive sense -- when it comes to its overall production design and story beats. Watching this episode, it also struck me how aptly this describes the show's more humorous side too! No convoluted setups that lead to "funny" payoffs, no intricate wordplay, just simple old-school comedic bits that nevertheless feel fresh and funny. That image of the Child staring into the "egg bowl"... priceless! This show is, simply put, supremely confident in its storytelling.

Dom
Fri, Nov 20, 2020, 5:23pm (UTC -5)

@Paul, that's a good way to put it. Mandalorian isn't really pushing the boundaries in storytelling or doing anything subversive, except perhaps in daring to be simple. Episode 2 of Season 1 was one of the best examples of lean, pared down storytelling I can think of on TV. And no matter what the show does, no matter how silly or sentimental, it's almost always confident. I get the sense that the creators are having fun playing in the Star Wars sandbox.

CaptainMercer
Sun, Nov 22, 2020, 10:26am (UTC -5)

One thing I thought about while watching this episode was our own history.. how the Native Americans have their entire culture based around the Buffalos.. everything that they eat, that they make, and even their ways revolve around those beasts. The same goes for the Tuskan raiders.. but their savagery (at least, as it appears) is due to the fact that that the Tuskans get no actual benefit from the Krayte dragon.. all they can do is hope to placate it. When Ben Kenobi used the call in episode 4 to scare them.. we now know why. I love how the Tuskans have become a fully realized culture (even riding single file)

Whereas discovery is using their huge budget to decorate the screen with effects, Favreau is using the money to create seemingly real cultures, and to create things that those cultures would actually USE. Plus, each episode maintains a good sense of humor.. the kind of humor Star Wars does best. things like the funny noises a creature makes

Yanks
Sun, Nov 22, 2020, 5:09pm (UTC -5)

One thing we learn in this episode is that Mando doesn't feed Baby Yoda enough.

This is the worst episode of 'The Mandalorian' yet IMO. Baby Yoda eats eggs, then Baby Yoda eats "alien", the bug spider thing, blah, blah.

Nothing gained here at all. All spectacle. ... just like the new Star Wars movies.

I hope this isn't a sign of things to come.

I have no desire to watch it again.

2 stars.

SlackerInc
Mon, Nov 23, 2020, 10:09am (UTC -5)

I was amused by how he kept eating the eggs, but also kind of horrified. I didn’t know there was a big controversy about this online, but that doesn’t seem too out of line to me. Actually, in a way I find it reassuring, tbh. While watching, I assumed everyone else would just shrug it off as a laugh and I found THAT idea disturbing.

Austin
Fri, Nov 27, 2020, 11:34am (UTC -5)

This was a nice horror episode of you hate spiders, my wife and daughter felt like things were crawling on them, so mission accomplished. Plot-wise though, it was the weakest episode of the series. No revelations, no plot advancement, no character growth, just spiders, eggs, and filler.

For anyone who legitimately had an issue with The Child’s egg eating, give me a break. You’re mad because a fictitious alien baby is eating the unfertilized eggs of yet another fictitious rando? If they’re upset or triggered by this kind of dark humor, stick with the other crap they offer on Disney+. Might I suggest Hannah Montana or Jessie?

If people are upset about this, imagine if they saw Futurama’s “The Problem With Popplers” in which humanity gets hooked on a tasty snack food, only to find out that it’s the young of an alien race, and even when they find out about it, they’re too delicious to stop eating. Here’s some dialogue:

Zapp: These would be great with guack-a-mole.
Lrrr: Stop eating our young! And it's pronounced guacamole!

This was way worse and aired 20 years ago, and was super funny. The only problem is that social media was way different back then, and now, anyone who can rub 2 brain cells together can write an angry tweet virtue signaling that eating a sentient being’s offspring is bad and we need to cancel this or cancel him or cancel her. Secondly, this baby may look like Yoda, but it isn’t Yoda. And for us to assume just because it looks like Yoda, it must be good, is equivalent to saying just because Senator Palpatine is humanoid like Obi-Wan they must both be good.

I’ll get off my soapbox for now.... 2/4 cool visuals. Also made me want an omelet.

Booming
Fri, Nov 27, 2020, 11:59am (UTC -5)

So far I only see people being angry about people being against baby yoda eating the eggs. Nobody at least on this board has written a single critical word about Baby Yoda constantly eating everything. Maybe take it down a notch. I'm so tired of people writing endless posts about the horrors of virtue signaling, cancel culture or whatever. If Jammer hadn't mentioned it then I would have probably never heard of it. Get a life, people. The Disney Cooperation isn't a suppressed minority.

Austin
Fri, Nov 27, 2020, 4:58pm (UTC -5)

@Booming My comments weren’t directed towards anyone on this board. I was merely expressing my frustration with how that’s even a thing, much less something that keeps popping up in my Google feed. I don’t want anyone to take what I said personally, and honestly I think nearly everyone on this site are very intelligent and understand dark humor.

Andy NoVA
Sun, Dec 6, 2020, 9:13pm (UTC -5)

Really suprised nobody's mentioned the simultaneous hat tips to Ridley Scott's alien eggs or the Lucas/Spielberg Indiana Jones like race through the (ice) cave with all those spiders in pursuit.

While I'm at it, the parent spider also evoked the creature that chases Chris Pine's James T. Kirk into an ice cave in the JJ Abrams Star Trek reboot.

Odes a plenty here.

Jason R.
Wed, Jan 6, 2021, 9:34am (UTC -5)

I agree with Jammer that this series is steadfast in its mission of solid storytelling using the Star Wars universe as its canvass. It isn't overly ambitious but manages to deliver on its premise episode after episode. This is true world building coupled with good stories well-executed. Good God I can't imagine what Kurtzman and crew would do with this. The fate of the galaxy would be at stake I am sure.

jillyenator
Tue, Aug 3, 2021, 4:55am (UTC -5)

Besides the obvious riff on aliens, we also get a bit of Harry Potter's Chamber of Secrets. Ick ick ick! In the best way.

I was suitably horrified that The Child kept slurping up the precious eggs, but also couldn't stop laughing over it. Each time he slurped one down I had to crack up.

In the next two eps the kid continues to eat things that either aren't his or that are...um...still moving. (Ghagh is best when served live.) Growing kid's gotta grow!

Quincy
Sat, Dec 18, 2021, 2:36am (UTC -5)

Ah, man. This episode was hilarious. It should've been entitled "Give It to the Child; He'll Eat Anything!" Baby Yoda was tearing those things up. That was his favorite snack. You can't eat just one. Lmao!

And then when he popped that face hugger in his mouth, I was like you bull$#'ing. Ain't no way on god's green earth or the ice planet for that matter. But once again slurp! I couldn't stop laughing.

And then the spiders came out. I'm like run. And they took their sweet time getting out of that pool. I'm like run! Then they're standing there looking while the situation's getting worse and worse. Run!

Aw, man, pure gold.

On another note, dude needs a new ship bad. There's no way that bucket of bolts is going to fly much longer.

Leif
Tue, Mar 21, 2023, 10:11pm (UTC -5)

Didn't thisepisode have NEW ORIGINAL life firms with those aliens which weren't just soldiers they looked like a cross between a Venus fly trap type flower and a spider no? And wasn't the passenger alien also original?

Rahul
Sun, Mar 26, 2023, 4:06pm (UTC -5)

While this one had the "usual" battle against an indigenous monster, there's a bit more depth for Mando's character here I feel. Probably a lot more good fortune here as well. The situation looked more hopeless than at any other time in the series. That his ship could take off from that ice planet with all its hull breaches etc. is pushing it.

But the good stuff is how I think Mando eventually appreciated the frog lady's situation and living up to the Mandalorian code just after he tells her the deal is off. Mando also has to supervise Baby Yoda more than ever with telling it not to eat the frog eggs. And then Baby Yoda goes and eats a spider larvae and then all hell breaks loose. Again, pretty impressive CGI with the attack of the ice spiders. This show takes a very simple plot and executes it like no other show I've seen -- that's really the "business model" here.

Mando's dialog picks up a bit here too -- has to lay out the situation of the damage, flying with just the cockpit pressurized, etc.. He actually had a lot to say here.

As for the New Republic -- they're trying to do a job but I think they are also fairly pragmatic. They know Mando's not the real problem and they have bigger fish to fry. That they help him with the ice spiders is the miracle needed.

2.5 stars for "Chapter 10: The Passenger" -- while there will seemingly always be an action/adventure component to the episode, the frog lady's story and its effect on Mando brought about a more "caring" side to Mando I think. So I think there was a bit better balance in this episode and I liked it a tad better than Chapter 9. But this one's also a bit more padding (albeit good padding) as, 2 episodes into S2, Mando still hasn't found another Mandalorian.

Jammer's Reviews

The Mandalorian