Comment Stream

Search and bookmark options Close
Search for:
Search by:

Total Found: 539 (Showing 1-25)

Next ►Page 1 of 22
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Tue, Jul 3, 2018, 2:46am (UTC -5)
Re: DS9 S6: Rocks and Shoals

Hello Everyone!

I think it comes down to this: If Sisko had found out about the plan through subterfuge, or found a map of the attack wrapped around a cigar (historical reference), he'd have had no problem with it. But he has some Honor left. And it just didn't feel Honorable, at that time, to massacre an enemy to save the skin of the Vorta who arranged it. Because the Vorta was despicable.

If they'd shown Sisko, and to a lesser extent O'Brien and the rest, just wanting to execute them without a second thought, they would be no better than the Jem'Hadar...

Enjoy the Day Everyone... RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Tue, Jul 3, 2018, 2:24am (UTC -5)
Re: DS9 S6: A Time to Stand

Hello Everyone!

Forgive me, I'm just running this through my head a bit...

The Dominion seems to want good Public Relations as "Benevolent Invaders". They keep Jake around to help with that PR, but seemingly only with the Bajorans, as his stories are somewhat one-sided and StarFleet media never sees them. But the Bajorans see him around and know he is okay, and that is important to them as he is the son of the Emissary. And they seem to need to keep the Bajorans happy, because the Wormhole Aliens seem to like Bajor for some reason, and whatever the Dominion thinks of the WA's, they know they could control the wormhole.

So... unhappy Bajorans could make for unhappy Wormhole Aliens, which could make accessing the supply lines problematic if the WA's are actually watching. They cannot be certain they aren't.
----------

Sir Bedevere: ...Exactly. So, logically...

Peasant #1: Jake must remain alive and unharmed to keep the Bajorans somewhat happy(ish) to hopefully keep the Wormhole Aliens happy or ambivalent (just in case they are watching) so that they might be able to use the wormhole if/when it becomes available.

Sir Bedevere: And therefore...

Peasant #2: If anything, the Dominion might want Jake there just to show how nice and merciful they can be to the son of the Emmisary. They wouldn't do anything to him until the day they might have to leave. Then he would be toast.

Sir Bedevere smiles and nods approvingly as they run off to try and weigh a Jem Hadar...
----------

As always, they were just strange thoughts running through my head recently, and no disrespect to anyone, real or imagined, is intended...

Regards... RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Tue, Jun 19, 2018, 4:49am (UTC -5)
Re: TNG S3: The Vengeance Factor

Hello Everyone!

I probably liked this one more than I should have. When I saw it originally, I'm fairly certain I was just starting to really like TNG again. I'd stopped watching it for a bit after season one (heresy I know), but had seen an earlier season three episode that brought me back. Perhaps this one touched me because of the Guest Star Joey Aresco, who played "Hutch" on "Baa Baa Black Sheep", the somewhat real/fictional depiction of the United States Marine 214th squadron during World War II (the show later renamed Black Sheep Squadron, because it sounded like a kids show... go figure the parents couldn't figure it out after the dogfights...).

But I digress.

It really sounded like something weird and boring Starfleet would actually do. We'd heard many times about one Starship or another heading out to do some diplomatic work, and usually only in the Captain's logs... (while heading to a conference about the problems on Melba 2, and if they should be called "Toast", we encountered an Anomaly...).

Here is an actual weird, boring problem the crew has to solve or make better. Yes, it was started with something being stolen, but in the entirety of the known Galaxy... it's actually somewhat mundane. It is something they do all the time, and it just got a little hotter than they were used to. A few baddies stealing something? Really? Mundane...

For years when watching TOS, I'd yearned to see some "normal" stories. Something on K-7, or something that was just on their normal patrol and involved the "regular", day to day operations. Everything always seemed to be ship or Galaxy shattering... if they didn't get it just right, all was lost. In my re-birth of watching TNG, this was mundane, and perfect. Perhaps that is why I liked it so much. If they didn't get the result they wanted, no-one would care! The folks can duke it out until their sun goes nova! And we'll say we tried and then head out to taste some new variations on toast...

As always, your mileage may vary... but Two Thumbs up for Me...

RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Tue, Jun 19, 2018, 2:53am (UTC -5)
Re: VOY S5: Latent Image

Hello Everyone!

Boy, after all of these years, I still ponder this one...

My random thoughts...

Doctor (his name, not The Doctor), is simply a fantastic program that has gone so far above and beyond its original programming it is essentially another person on the ship. But I say essentially. It is still a program. Just because it is aware that it can leave the holodeck (Moriarity as well), does not mean it is alive. It must have a soul, that inner spark that leaves upon death and heads out to a higher realm.

When his (I say that only because his image is male) programming came upon the improbable circumstance of both crew members having the unlikely perfect 50.0 percent chance of living, Doctor said he chose the one that he liked the best. But I think it was his programming saying this one is a bridge officer, and this one is not. And... done. Whether Doc knew it or not, that was his game-changer. He doesn't know all of the things that go on with the programming, just that he follows it. If there had been even the slightest indication (.001 or so, for arguments sake), he would have saved Jetal, if she was the .001+.

I love Doctor in Voyager, and in this episode. Always have and always will. But when it comes down to it, he is still a program, and can be edited, deleted or enhanced (as shown here). 7 talks about individuality, but at her base, she is still human, and has been brought back into the fold over time. She has computer parts in her, but the thinking is she is still human at her core. And still has her soul.

At the end of time, when there is no more power for Doctor, he will simply blink out of existence. No Valhalla, no Heaven... just nothingness and done.

End of program...

Regards... RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Sun, May 20, 2018, 3:23am (UTC -5)
Re: TNG S4: Devil's Due

Hello Chrome

So, out of many, many awful ST:TNG episodes, those particular broadcasters stood upon their bridge and declared "This... shall not... be BroadCast...!"... just because of someone in a devil suit (that wasn't even Ardra)? I'll bet they feel really silly now... (heh).

Wow, and I thought Michiana was a weird place to grow up in.

Regards... RT
Set Bookmark
Matsu
Mon, May 7, 2018, 12:17pm (UTC -5)
Re: Star Wars: The Last Jedi

Agreed with Dixie.
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Mon, Apr 16, 2018, 12:21am (UTC -5)
Re: TNG S1: Heart of Glory

Hello Everyone!

@Prince of Space

I loved your phaser comment. :)

I touched on this in some comment, somewhere, but it seems Starfleet just doesn't know how to use their phasers. They fire them precisely, as if they need to aim perfectly, like the Klingons must do with their single-shot weapon. A beam weapon needs to be used like a machine gun, sweeping back and forth over everything, or perhaps even set it to the wide setting we so rarely see. Then when the smoke cleared, they'd have two baddies down, and have to call for a damage control team. :)

Regards... RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Sun, Apr 15, 2018, 5:45am (UTC -5)
Re: Star Wars: A New Hope

Hello Everyone!

I sometimes feel badly for the people that didn't get to watch this as I did: 11 times in the theater and once at an outdoor. Yes, it was basic in hindsight, but darned if it didn't make my blood rush every time.

It didn't go straight to VHS (that'd be a few years away), and wasn't watched a few months later on a streaming service. After it was out of the cinema, that was it. It ran for a full year at one of the local movie houses, with notes in the paper on the movie page (24 weeks running!). And while we waited for the (hoped for) sequel, we talked about how big a baddie Darth Vader was, and read everything we could about it. I even read the novel...

Tee-shirts of Vader, wanting to be like Luke (except for the whining part early on, though that showed him to be human and not perfect), putting hair into strange buns like Leia for parties and whatnot, having that poster up in your room... it was just simply a phenomena. I don't believe I've ever seen anything like this before or since.

To be new to it, and just watch this one and then the next one immediately after... well... those folks will never know what it was like to wait a true three years for the next movie, and with no internet to release spoilers...

And as for some of the movie moments... as a dear friend of mine said at the time, those rebel pilots "Died Hard", as they screamed on the way down before piling it in. Movies before that seldom had any of the good guys dying very often, and if they did it was quite noble. Never before had I seen the likes of someone saying "Stay on target...", not listening to their wingman, and then exploding in a ball of flame while yelling in pain/surprise/anguish. Maybe that was part of the thrill... it showed some of the good guys meeting awful ends. Even though we didn't know them, it hurt. It made it a bit more real, and biting.

There are so many more things... and we had to stew about them for two to three years after our last viewing.

It was simply... an amazing time...

Regards... RT
Set Bookmark
Matsu
Tue, Apr 10, 2018, 1:08pm (UTC -5)
Re: VOY S6: Memorial

Horrible episode, from start to finish. To give this one star more than the previous Virtuoso episode, which was hilarious form start to finish, is a sign of an incredibly bad taste. Or no sense of humor whatsoever. But probably both.
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Sat, Apr 7, 2018, 3:54am (UTC -5)
Re: DS9 S5: Trials and Tribble-ations

@Jason R.

Yes, the Klingons might have recognized Worf as one of their own, but he was wearing a hat. Since they were so worried about fighting, they just didn't notice...

:D

Regards... RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Thu, Apr 5, 2018, 2:59am (UTC -5)
Re: DS9 S7: Afterimage

Hello Everyone!

Wow, what a great bunch of comments to go through. Thanks to everyone over the years for their insights... Now, to some thoughts, starting with the silly one:

Did the makeup change somewhat for this one? Perhaps I just don't remember seeing Garak wear a shirt like that, but he looked as if he had a form of shoulder pads on when we saw the top of his clavicle region. I just kept staring, thinking to myself "He has no neck". At the end, he looked more normal, perhaps because he had a regular shirt on, and I figure he just didn't have as much padding to imitate what would be under there. At the very least, it was distracting. And Worf, as he turned away to leave during his scene with Bashir, looked like his ridges went nearly straight up. I was reminded of some helmets in LOTRO. I always thought his forehead curved more gracefully.

Speaking of Garak. I suppose I'd thought he had come to terms with helping the Federation/Klingon alliance when he helped bring in the Romulans during "In the Pale Moonlight", and he'd also said something about wanting to be there as the first parts of Cardassia were liberated in "Tears of the Prophets". So I was surprised his underlying problem was his help was going to get Cardassians killed. He'd just been compartmentalizing it away, until it ate at him enough to burst through in a scene I watched at least twice. I thought it was quite compelling, and Very Garak.

I think I like Ezri just fine. As I've mentioned on other posts, I tend to take characters just as they are. She just... was. So I accepted her. After reading some of the comments above, I believe in hindsight Jadzia might have been relying more on the Dax symbiont in how she did things in the first season, perhaps as a result of her training. Then as time went on, melded Jadzia with the favorite parts of the previous hosts, until she played Tongo until all hours of the night, enjoyed both Ferengi and Klingons, and some days decided to just go out and have FUN (perhaps a bit more of Farrell in there as well), among other things I'm forgetting. Ezri on the other hand, had no training, so is seemingly relying on Ezri Tigan to make sense of things, and while that makes her a bit flighty, it also makes her more interesting to me. It would be worse if she was a somewhat more stoic version, acting like Jadzia in the first season.

I turned my thoughts of Sisko around from some of the other comments: Perhaps he doesn't want her there for selfish reasons, perhaps he thinks Jadzia's friends can help her with the transformation better than her old friends could on that other ship (@methane touched on this a bit above). Not only did he know two versions, but many of them helped her by hosting her previous memories in "Facets". Short of going back to Trill for a while, I think this group can help her along. In my mind anyway...

Lastly, Ezri should have told Garak to take some time to think about it, instead of telling him Sisko would be happy to hear he was back on the job. That wasn't a very counselor comment, and a poor writing choice.

Thanks and have a great day... RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Thu, Apr 5, 2018, 12:42am (UTC -5)
Re: VOY S2: Threshold

@mark

*One eyebrow raised...*

"Astonishing..."

Thanks for the information. Wow... Just... wow. :D

RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Thu, Apr 5, 2018, 12:33am (UTC -5)
Re: TOS S1: The Alternative Factor

Hello Everyone!

@Bill

I never knew those things about this episode and I always thought his beard looked funky. I suppose they thought he/they needed a beard, because where was he going to shave? :)

I wonder what they added into the episode? It always seemed a decent(ish) premise to me, but felt like it was half an episode stretched out. Perhaps it was...

Thanks for the insight... RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Wed, Apr 4, 2018, 8:01pm (UTC -5)
Re: VOY S5: Drone

Hello Everyone!

I just hit this one again on my re-watch, and was pleasantly surprised as, once again, I had forgotten much of it. My thoughts, in no particular order:

When One is getting his first injection of information, they keep the shot on his face, and it really struck me as his mouth dropped open slightly, and a look of awe crept in. I really liked how Boehmer acted here, and throughout.

As others mentioned, I also noticed when Doctor didn't say one bad thing about his emitter being in One (not even a slightly snarky comment), once One was up and about. It was as if he was just simply pleased to see this somewhat new lifeform, with a big smile when he scanned him. And I figured right then that One would be able to construct a new emitter eventually, some day down the road.

I never thought the Borg would really grow their own children (unless they had an idea about how to do something better), but my thought was if the Borg assimilated a unwilling participant who was with child, they'd keep the baby and grow him/her as Borg. Out of a population of millions or billions, there'd be quite a few babies around as well, and they'd just keep them too, so long as it was efficient to grow them. We already know they kept children, since Seven was young when assimilated.

We saw in the brig of the Enterprise that there was water for the sink in TNG episode "The Hunted". Perhaps they usually use a sonic shower, but do use some water sometimes and thus, a towel.

As much as I liked the episode, it sure seemed to be moving fast. I agree that parts of it could have been spread out over two or three.

I really liked Neelix interacting with One in the corridor. He just seemed like the perfect sentient to be helping him right there. Although I did feel that Neelix accepted him rather quickly, with no apparent trepidation (see previous comment).

When they were in engineering, and One came up with the algorithm, my first thought was Seven just realized she wasn't going to be the first stop for complicated problems any more. I don't know what her face was supposed to convey then, but I didn't read pride or satisfaction, more like "Oh crud, he's just out-done me".

We now know that no matter what they do to their weapons or shields they cannot be upgraded any higher than they are now, to be able to defeat a Borg ship. I'd think One's overclocking the systems would probably stick (heh, but you know... Voyager), but they would obviously need to upgrade their capabilities. In all fairness, they did show them attempting to do that a few episodes ago in "Retrospect", but this should show them they need to go much further than they have. In their current state, if One couldn't get weapons or shields any higher than that, no one can.

Lastly, One had multi-phasic shields up, or some such thing, after he destroyed the sphere, and the first thing Janeway says is "Get a lock on him!". Would they be able to?

I think that's about it. Thanks for your time and have a great day... RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Wed, Feb 21, 2018, 3:30am (UTC -5)
Re: Star Wars: Attack of the Clones

Hello Everyone!

Wow, what a great recent discussion!

My somewhat disjointed thoughts are that Jedi are trained to resist a Sith wherever they find them, no matter the cost. If it isn't a law, it's a rule the Jedi are taught from the beginning, since the Sith delve into things that are best left un-delved, and get power from areas that are better left untapped (dark side). And over the many years, they figure that is bad enough to override common sense and *light up* on the ruler of the entire known galaxy.

But when the Jedi power up before the bad guy does, they fall right into his trap. Heck, he's found a way to turn a stupid trade agreement dispute into full power for himself, and they don't think he is still working the long game? Even holding their saber *unlit* would be enough to convince that they were attempting to grab control of the government. Now, this was all manipulated of course, but they weren't bright enough to realize how they were being used?

What I don't quite get is why does Palpatine do all of this? He has a thirst for power, but once he gets it, what can he do with it? Conquer the outer rim planets? Okay, fine. But Star Wars never mentions an outside power or area to control. It seems the Republic had pretty much every planet within their sphere of influence already in the group. That's why they didn't really have an army, because there were no bad guys. He needed an army to back him up when he took control, and he got it (after inventing some bad guys). But what then? If he was looking for ultimate power, I think he'd already gotten that from the Dark Side, so now he just sits on the throne, with no one else to defeat? I'd think he'd get bored.

I'm reminded of that fantastic Robot Chicken skit where, in the middle of finding out the Death Star has been destroyed, someone calls him for a sandwich order. He'd hate running the galaxy, and the tedium that comes with it. While he probably *saw* a rebellion coming, he'd probably relish it because it would give him a reason to flex his muscles. And after it would be put down, once again, then what would he do? Now, if they'd even mentioned another portion of the galaxy that had different rulers (other than the Hutts *squish*), or even another galaxy to move into and put under his influence... maybe.

*I don't know... cole slaw... what is everyone else getting?... I'm not going to eat it anyway...*

And my ramblings are over... for now... :)

Regards... RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Wed, Feb 21, 2018, 12:46am (UTC -5)
Re: VOY S4: Demon

Hello Everyone!

Well, it wasn't quite as bad I remembered, but it still wasn't good. And Neelix ended up in Sickbay, on a spacious bio-bed. His book and blankie would have been just fine. I wonder where Tuvok threw his stuff?

I did like this exchange though:
CHAKOTAY: Looks like they went this way.
SEVEN: My tricorder isn't picking up any lifesigns. How did you reach that conclusion?
CHAKOTAY: Footprints. I guess you never assimilated any Indian scouts.

That did make me smile.

Enjoy the day Everyone... RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Thu, Feb 15, 2018, 2:24am (UTC -5)
Re: DS9 S1: Battle Lines

Hello Everyone!

@Drewmina

I noticed. But it isn't the only reason Tallman was (maybe) in the episode. She was Dr. Crusher's stunt double on TNG as well.

Oh, and I loved, loved Babylon 5.

Regards... RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Thu, Feb 15, 2018, 2:11am (UTC -5)
Re: DS9 S6: Who Mourns for Morn?

Hello Everyone!

@Matt

I always figured Quark kept playing with Dax, even it it often showed him losing, because he liked her, she probably brought a different perspective on how to play, and learning how to beat here could only make Quark better at defeating everyone else. I think the rest play because, to be the best, you have to try to beat the best.

Just a thought... RT
Set Bookmark
Matsu
Sun, Feb 4, 2018, 11:46am (UTC -5)
Re: VOY S5: Someone to Watch Over Me

Startrekwatcher: "Overall a pretty average affair?" LOL. Someone here is a pretty average person without any sense of humour whatsoever.. ;-)
Set Bookmark
Vernon watts
Wed, Jan 31, 2018, 6:52pm (UTC -5)
Re: VOY S2: Tuvix

I personally thought the episode to be powerfull but found Janeways actions at the end to be genocidal and not simply murder as Tuvix was an utterly unique life form. Also some people question why the Doc refused to kill him after initially looking for the cure, up until Tuvix expressed his wish to live it was asumed he wanted to be sepparated so the cure was sought. All in all a very thought provoking episode with a very nasty ending.
Set Bookmark
Erin Roberts
Tue, Jan 23, 2018, 1:20pm (UTC -5)
Re: DSC S1: Vaulting Ambition

I for one was hoping that Lorca was a time traveler from future section 31 or something like there is no way events could line up so perfectly unless you already knew where everyone was going to be at any given time. Also I guess we are supposed to believe it was BS but I feel like Lorca genuinely cared about winning the Klingon war based on Isaacs's performance.
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Tue, Jan 16, 2018, 12:26am (UTC -5)
Re: DS9 S6: Valiant

Hello Everyone!

Let's see, where to begin? Ah, with the last message of the Dominion vessel: Attacked by Federation warship... *boom*. And 8 months strained credulity for me. Perhaps if they were hiding in an asteroid field or something. I realize there are less ships behind the lines in open space, but Nog/Jake crossed the line into Dominion territory in no time. I'd think the Valiant would've been spotted before this, perhaps by the Dominion raiding party that was going to attack the Starbase (which, thinking again, must have been pretty close to the border). Oh, and if some of the Dominion ships survived their attack on the station, wouldn't they have gone looking for their other ship, or find what destroyed it? (Hopefully they scuttled the runabout, it hadn't blown up yet, had it?)

Didn't they say in an earlier episode that two officers are required for any mission? Especially one to see the Nagus...

Heh, Watters gets a battlefield promotion, and then it's battlefield promotions for Everyone!

I really thought Nog was going to say something about their chain of command and where he should actually fit into it, until he was told he was going to be a Lt. Commander and Chief Engineer. Then his eyes lit up, he sucked in a little air, and said thank you sir, I'll be in engineering if you need me. Then at the end, he realizes he'd over-stepped himself, and by not being a voice of reason, aided in the destruction of the ship. Oh, and weren't his pips for Lt. Jg (one full and one dark) instead of Lt. Commander (two full and one dark)?

I really think Nog was sucked in by his need to be accepted, as if he wanted to prove himself, and when he was given a promotion and a great deal of responsibility, he attempted to be the best at it he could be. And that clouded his judgement. I am wondering why he wasn't in engineering during the attack though. LaForge or Torres would be down in the guts when the action was thick and heavy, not doing things from the bridge.

There was such a long pause when the Captain went down... like nobody knew what to do. The Commander should have been up immediately, but instead sat there with a big arrow pointing towards her head and a balloon reading "Not Ready". I'd actually thought Nog would wait a moment to see if they'd get over their shock, then take command and tell them to get the heck out of there. Instead they wasted precious seconds getting pummeled from the rear as they sailed along...

Lastly, I think, I'd recently seen a show where someone who was abducted and held for 18 months defended their abductor, because of something psychological.
Somehow, that struck me as I watched Dorian defend Watters. He wouldn't let them go home (or even talk about it), but had kept them safe and made them feel like a valuable part of the team, etc. Perhaps at this point, there is no way she can find any real faults in him, because of the mental conditioning...

Any accurate or inaccurate thoughts in the above post are purely coincidental and may be explained away by random chance... :)

RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Sat, Jan 13, 2018, 1:17am (UTC -5)
Re: VOY S4: The Omega Directive

Hello Everyone!

Heh, I also somewhat agree with all of the positive and negative responses to this episode. :)

I won't re-hash what has already been hashed above, so I'll bring up a tidbit that struck me rather early in the episode. Torres said something about them being 60,000 light-years from home. Again with the 60k. I mentioned in an earlier review that they should be closer than that. They'd probably traveled a couple thousand themselves (70k light-years distant taking 70 years or so), in a couple of years, and they also found a few shortcuts along the way. And don't forget Kes flung them 10k. I'm thinking 55k max, and maybe closer to 50k. And since the last episode where they mentioned 60k (I don't recall which one, but I believe it was this season), they've gone nowhere. Now, if she'd over-exaggerated by saying a million, billion light years, that'd be fine. But 60k makes me think they've only gone backwards, then forward 10k from Kes, and that's it.

Your mileage may vary... :) RT
Set Bookmark
RandomThoughts
Thu, Jan 11, 2018, 1:06am (UTC -5)
Re: DS9 S6: The Reckoning

Hello Everyone!

Two thoughts...

1) I'd actually hoped for more of a fight. They just... stand there and put power against power. I was thinking more throwing around, doing some damage to the station and themselves. Sort of like Gandalf and Saruman, when they fought in Lord of the Rings.

2) I'd have found it more enjoyable if the Wraith was the only one in the stone, and a Prophet showed up on the station just as the tablet was broken. Why encase them both for 30,000 (linear) years?

Maybe three thoughts...

3) I was surprised the Wraith seemed to be losing so quickly, as the two forces would seem to be on-par with each other. Perhaps Kira wasn't holding back, and being a true believer, just let the power flow, while Jake was screaming NO! on the inside, and mildly fighting the Wraith. I can see that tilting an even scale...

Enjoy the Day Everyone... RT
Set Bookmark
stackcats
Tue, Jan 9, 2018, 5:21am (UTC -5)
Re: DSC S1: Despite Yourself

Soooo.... the Spore Drive is the Holly Hop Drive?
Next ►Page 1 of 22
▲Top of Page | Menu | Copyright © 1994-2018 Jamahl Epsicokhan. All rights reserved. Unauthorized duplication or distribution of any content is prohibited. This site is an independent publication and is not affiliated with or authorized by any entity or company referenced herein. See site policies.