Comment Stream
Search and bookmark options
Total Found: 341 (Showing 1-25)
Next ►Page 1 of 14
Re: TNG S7: The Pegasus
Yeah, I like this episode. Not a 4 * but a decent 3.
I'm also on the Federation having no cloaking devices as dumb. So the Federation win their war with the Romulan's and then they organise a peace treaty which basically says "Yeah you can have technology that means you can sneak everywhere and we wont."
It's nonsense. I appreciate the Federation wouldn't use it as standard, but it would be on all their ships.
Yeah, I like this episode. Not a 4 * but a decent 3.
I'm also on the Federation having no cloaking devices as dumb. So the Federation win their war with the Romulan's and then they organise a peace treaty which basically says "Yeah you can have technology that means you can sneak everywhere and we wont."
It's nonsense. I appreciate the Federation wouldn't use it as standard, but it would be on all their ships.
Re: DSC S2: General Discussion
Looking forward to it.
Season one was not without it's flaws but pretty much every 1st season on Trek was weak when you look back.
If people are going to turn their back on it then that is up to them. They'll be the ones complaining about it in February without having watched an episode.
Looking forward to it.
Season one was not without it's flaws but pretty much every 1st season on Trek was weak when you look back.
If people are going to turn their back on it then that is up to them. They'll be the ones complaining about it in February without having watched an episode.
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story
Oh.... And why was there even a train on that planet. The Star Wars Universe is full of space ships that could have got the Coaxium or whatever it was there in no time.
But lets stick in on a train on a mountain because it will look cool.
All I kept thinking is "Why is that even there?"
Oh.... And why was there even a train on that planet. The Star Wars Universe is full of space ships that could have got the Coaxium or whatever it was there in no time.
But lets stick in on a train on a mountain because it will look cool.
All I kept thinking is "Why is that even there?"
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story
My verdict on Solo.
Pretty much forgettable. Ok. It wasn't a disaster but I really didn't care. There is no jeopardy in a story like this. You can instantly guess who the bad guys might be and who is likely to die.
Got really bored towards the end and started to nod off.
None of the humour made me laugh. The Last Jedi was actually funnier. None of the action sequences blew me away either. Oooh.. another big monster chase.
I maintain this film didn't need to be made. The fact that it bombed has now likely robbed us of some potentially decent side stories. Like Rogue One was.
Slow clap Disney. Slow clap.
My verdict on Solo.
Pretty much forgettable. Ok. It wasn't a disaster but I really didn't care. There is no jeopardy in a story like this. You can instantly guess who the bad guys might be and who is likely to die.
Got really bored towards the end and started to nod off.
None of the humour made me laugh. The Last Jedi was actually funnier. None of the action sequences blew me away either. Oooh.. another big monster chase.
I maintain this film didn't need to be made. The fact that it bombed has now likely robbed us of some potentially decent side stories. Like Rogue One was.
Slow clap Disney. Slow clap.
Re: DS9 S2: Paradise
Elliot... So good to see you on here again.
I for one cannot wait to see you vent your spleen against Star Trek Discovery.
Elliot... So good to see you on here again.
I for one cannot wait to see you vent your spleen against Star Trek Discovery.
Re: DS9 S2: Crossover
Just read the script to this.
This was supposed to have Worf in it.
http://www.st-minutiae.com/resources/scripts/443.txt
Just read the script to this.
This was supposed to have Worf in it.
http://www.st-minutiae.com/resources/scripts/443.txt
Re: Star Wars: The Last Jedi
Really pleased that someone else has taken positives from scenes that people were negative about.
This film is not without it's flaws... I'm sticking with a 3/4 now but I have seen it twice and enjoyed it both times. I look forward to watching it again.
Really pleased that someone else has taken positives from scenes that people were negative about.
This film is not without it's flaws... I'm sticking with a 3/4 now but I have seen it twice and enjoyed it both times. I look forward to watching it again.
Re: DS9 S1: Emissary
I know it's TV nonsense but it kind of bugs me that after this episode that the Enterprise doesn't go off for a jolly through the worm hole.
The flagship of the Federation. It's mission to boldly go etc... But doesn't boldly go to a new quadrant.
I know it's TV nonsense but it kind of bugs me that after this episode that the Enterprise doesn't go off for a jolly through the worm hole.
The flagship of the Federation. It's mission to boldly go etc... But doesn't boldly go to a new quadrant.
Re: DSC S1: Will You Take My Hand?
Most people expected this series to be horrific and bomb hard I think a lot of people have been proved wrong.
It's not perfect and certainly shows a slightly disjointed first season. A clunky finale but not the absolute shit show half the commentators on here are saying. IMO anyway.
Very confident that season 2 will be better with steadier hands running the ship and that they'll be focused on taking it in Trekkier directions.
Just give us more Tilly... She is amazing.
Most people expected this series to be horrific and bomb hard I think a lot of people have been proved wrong.
It's not perfect and certainly shows a slightly disjointed first season. A clunky finale but not the absolute shit show half the commentators on here are saying. IMO anyway.
Very confident that season 2 will be better with steadier hands running the ship and that they'll be focused on taking it in Trekkier directions.
Just give us more Tilly... She is amazing.
Re: DSC S1: The War Without, The War Within
Possibly my favourite episode so far.
Sad to see this coming to an end next week. Hope I (I wont say we because from the comments here everyone seems to dislike it) don't have to wait an age for season 2.
Can't wait to see where they go with all this.
Part of me is hoping for an epic reset just because of the implosion it will cause!
Possibly my favourite episode so far.
Sad to see this coming to an end next week. Hope I (I wont say we because from the comments here everyone seems to dislike it) don't have to wait an age for season 2.
Can't wait to see where they go with all this.
Part of me is hoping for an epic reset just because of the implosion it will cause!
Re: ENT S4: In a Mirror, Darkly, Part I
@Chrome - One other thing that bothered me was the cheap cash-in on "First Contact". The clip even used the exact same music and stock footage of James Cromwell meeting the Vulcans without actually hiring the actor back.
Him and the other actors all agreed on a minimal appearance fee for reusing the footage. Imagine hiring them back, rebuilding the set (they were lucky enough to be able to get the bottom of the Vulcan ship from someone) would have taken a decent slice of the budget from quite an FX heavy couple of episodes.
@Chrome - One other thing that bothered me was the cheap cash-in on "First Contact". The clip even used the exact same music and stock footage of James Cromwell meeting the Vulcans without actually hiring the actor back.
Him and the other actors all agreed on a minimal appearance fee for reusing the footage. Imagine hiring them back, rebuilding the set (they were lucky enough to be able to get the bottom of the Vulcan ship from someone) would have taken a decent slice of the budget from quite an FX heavy couple of episodes.
Re: DSC S1: Vaulting Ambition
Do I like the more grown up, gory Star Trek - Yes.
Do I like the serialised nature - Yes.
Do I like the fact that "fan theories" turn out to be correct, more or less - Yes.
Do I like Star Trek Discovery - Yes... Yes I do.
Not much more to add. My wife and I look forward to watching this on Monday nights... Are sad there are only a few episodes left... Are extremely sad we'll have to wait ages for season 2!
Do I like the more grown up, gory Star Trek - Yes.
Do I like the serialised nature - Yes.
Do I like the fact that "fan theories" turn out to be correct, more or less - Yes.
Do I like Star Trek Discovery - Yes... Yes I do.
Not much more to add. My wife and I look forward to watching this on Monday nights... Are sad there are only a few episodes left... Are extremely sad we'll have to wait ages for season 2!
Re: DSC S1: The Wolf Inside
Continues to be entertaining and engaging.
I sometimes feel that people forget that TV can be about switching off and going with the flow rather than switching on an analyzing the **** out of every minute detail...
Continues to be entertaining and engaging.
I sometimes feel that people forget that TV can be about switching off and going with the flow rather than switching on an analyzing the **** out of every minute detail...
Re: ORV S1: About a Girl
Best episode yet and certainly the most Trek like.
I like the humour... I'm a big kid. Dick jokes make me laugh.
Best episode yet and certainly the most Trek like.
I like the humour... I'm a big kid. Dick jokes make me laugh.
Re: ORV S1: Command Performance
Second episode watched and big improvement on the first.
I love the modern day references "I'm not going to be your Obi-Wan" and the hash cake cracked me up. I like that this is a crew of "Us" onboard a star ship.
Thought the Zoo thing was very cool as well, not heavy handed but cool.
Rescuing the kid was a nice touch as freeing the whole Zoo would have been a bit lame.
Whilst there is no escaping the fact that this is a Trek pastiche it is also it's own thing. Light hearted with some Sci-Fi thrown in.
Looking forward to what comes next. I think this will be fun.
Second episode watched and big improvement on the first.
I love the modern day references "I'm not going to be your Obi-Wan" and the hash cake cracked me up. I like that this is a crew of "Us" onboard a star ship.
Thought the Zoo thing was very cool as well, not heavy handed but cool.
Rescuing the kid was a nice touch as freeing the whole Zoo would have been a bit lame.
Whilst there is no escaping the fact that this is a Trek pastiche it is also it's own thing. Light hearted with some Sci-Fi thrown in.
Looking forward to what comes next. I think this will be fun.
Re: ORV S1: Old Wounds
OK... So UK viewer finally watched the first episode on catch up.
I like the overall vibe but agree, this wasn't a great first episode. Made me smile a lot but not the comedy I was expecting and the Sci-Fi wasn't amazing.
Onboard for more though (just finished the second episode) and I have hopes that this will be an entertaining show. If not amazing.
OK... So UK viewer finally watched the first episode on catch up.
I like the overall vibe but agree, this wasn't a great first episode. Made me smile a lot but not the comedy I was expecting and the Sci-Fi wasn't amazing.
Onboard for more though (just finished the second episode) and I have hopes that this will be an entertaining show. If not amazing.
Re: DSC S1: Into the Forest I Go
Not sure if this has been said but I think Ash's flashbacks are to his conversion from Klingon to Human and not of actual torture...
Or not.
Not sure if this has been said but I think Ash's flashbacks are to his conversion from Klingon to Human and not of actual torture...
Or not.
Re: DSC S1: Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum
Decent episode, not one of Discovery's best but it was worth it for Saru legging it across the cliff top.
I hope they clear up the is Tyler a spy or isn't he.
One minute he says something that makes you think "If he's a spy he has sure done his home work." Then he proper telegraphs things and makes you yell "You're a spy..." We've not seen Voq for ages either.
I will be annoyed if he is.
Cornwell isn't dead. Think that is pretty obvious.
Much as I am enjoying this show (certainly a lot more than a lot of people on here) I do agree with the common held though... Why make it a prequel? A few tweaks to the foe and this could have been set after Voyager... Maybe something is going to happen in the second half of the season that hammers home why they wanted another prequel. At the moment it doesn't make sense.
Decent episode, not one of Discovery's best but it was worth it for Saru legging it across the cliff top.
I hope they clear up the is Tyler a spy or isn't he.
One minute he says something that makes you think "If he's a spy he has sure done his home work." Then he proper telegraphs things and makes you yell "You're a spy..." We've not seen Voq for ages either.
I will be annoyed if he is.
Cornwell isn't dead. Think that is pretty obvious.
Much as I am enjoying this show (certainly a lot more than a lot of people on here) I do agree with the common held though... Why make it a prequel? A few tweaks to the foe and this could have been set after Voyager... Maybe something is going to happen in the second half of the season that hammers home why they wanted another prequel. At the moment it doesn't make sense.
Re: Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home
It's amazing the bad science people will let go when it suits them.
Time warps round the sun. Recharging Dilithium Crystal's in the 20th century despite the fact it's, supposedly, impossible in the future.
I love this movie but when I see people ripping into Discovery for bad science it does annoy. It's Sci Fi FFS!
It's amazing the bad science people will let go when it suits them.
Time warps round the sun. Recharging Dilithium Crystal's in the 20th century despite the fact it's, supposedly, impossible in the future.
I love this movie but when I see people ripping into Discovery for bad science it does annoy. It's Sci Fi FFS!
Re: DSC S1: Choose Your Pain
@Chrome - Damn you and you're Vulcanesque critique of my humour. ;o)
But yeah, she can paint the hull like the start of Red Dwarf.
@Chrome - Damn you and you're Vulcanesque critique of my humour. ;o)
But yeah, she can paint the hull like the start of Red Dwarf.
Re: DSC S1: Choose Your Pain
Sylvia Tilly you are fined one credit for the violation of the Verbal Morality Statute!
Sylvia Tilly you are fined one credit for the violation of the Verbal Morality Statute!
Re: DSC S1: Choose Your Pain
Maybe I'm just overly optimistic because I like the show but I do feel this is going somewhere.
There are certain things I am hoping.
Lorca's capture was a planned. Otherwise yes it was dumb. The whole eye thingy was telegraphed and that is because I think the thing he used on his eyes was actually to assist him when they tortured him.
Not sure the exact reason for letting him be captured but maybe find out what the Klingons know or feed false information.
That new crewmember... Klingon spy calling it now.
Mirror Stametts - Mirror Universe. Heard rumors that Lorca is a mirror Lorca.. .Don't see it myself but spore travel opening up the Mirror Universe makes sense in the scheme of things.
As for other stuff.
The Swearing - Yeah, needless but hardly he end of the world. My wife thought it was hilarious. First F Bomb on Star Trek.
Gay Couple - Oh no! Two men in love. Thought it was great.
Overall, still enjoying this and, as Jammer said in his review of the last 8 odd episodes of DS9... You have to review each as a separate part of a bigger untold story.
If at the end of the series it is a mess and characters have been inconsistent and huge plot holes are still there then fine.
I think a lot of this is the smoke and mirrors of serialised TV.
Maybe I'm just overly optimistic because I like the show but I do feel this is going somewhere.
There are certain things I am hoping.
Lorca's capture was a planned. Otherwise yes it was dumb. The whole eye thingy was telegraphed and that is because I think the thing he used on his eyes was actually to assist him when they tortured him.
Not sure the exact reason for letting him be captured but maybe find out what the Klingons know or feed false information.
That new crewmember... Klingon spy calling it now.
Mirror Stametts - Mirror Universe. Heard rumors that Lorca is a mirror Lorca.. .Don't see it myself but spore travel opening up the Mirror Universe makes sense in the scheme of things.
As for other stuff.
The Swearing - Yeah, needless but hardly he end of the world. My wife thought it was hilarious. First F Bomb on Star Trek.
Gay Couple - Oh no! Two men in love. Thought it was great.
Overall, still enjoying this and, as Jammer said in his review of the last 8 odd episodes of DS9... You have to review each as a separate part of a bigger untold story.
If at the end of the series it is a mess and characters have been inconsistent and huge plot holes are still there then fine.
I think a lot of this is the smoke and mirrors of serialised TV.
Next ►Page 1 of 14