Comment Stream
Search and bookmark options
Total Found: 1 (Showing 1-1)
Page 1 of 1
Re: ENT S1: Dear Doctor
Considering the 11 years worth of negative comments on I think Star Trek ought to come out and apologize for the episode at this point. But since they have yet to do so i'll add my comment to the number of reasons they should...
As was previously stated Doctor Phlox should loose his license to practice medicine. The reason we have a moral code is so that we can make the best decision possible when the choice is not so obvious. The moral code of medicine is to save lives not involve yourself in the politics of whose lives they are.
The human moral code has been carved in stone at this point, literally! It dictates that even in extreme circumstances even the most morally corrupt individuals, Hitler, Caligula, Nero, whoever (provided they are not posing a imminent threat of death or harm to others: we wouldn't ask a policeman or solider to stop shooting at someone who is still shooting back) but, once they are out of the fight if injured, even if they were the enemy a moment ago, it is the moral responsibility to provide aid in anyway capable.
There is simply nothing that can be said to redeem this episode. Archer failed as a captain and Phlox failed as a doctor!
Considering the 11 years worth of negative comments on I think Star Trek ought to come out and apologize for the episode at this point. But since they have yet to do so i'll add my comment to the number of reasons they should...
As was previously stated Doctor Phlox should loose his license to practice medicine. The reason we have a moral code is so that we can make the best decision possible when the choice is not so obvious. The moral code of medicine is to save lives not involve yourself in the politics of whose lives they are.
The human moral code has been carved in stone at this point, literally! It dictates that even in extreme circumstances even the most morally corrupt individuals, Hitler, Caligula, Nero, whoever (provided they are not posing a imminent threat of death or harm to others: we wouldn't ask a policeman or solider to stop shooting at someone who is still shooting back) but, once they are out of the fight if injured, even if they were the enemy a moment ago, it is the moral responsibility to provide aid in anyway capable.
There is simply nothing that can be said to redeem this episode. Archer failed as a captain and Phlox failed as a doctor!
Page 1 of 1