Air date: 2/10/2006
Written by Anne Cofell Saunders
Directed by Reynaldo Villalobos
Review by Jamahl Epsicokhan
"Sacrifice" reminds me of "Bastille Day" in that it's a competently executed routine plot with moments that transcend the overall structure. The problem is just that: It feels like a competently executed routine plot with just a few moments that transcend the whole. It doesn't feel like it's actually happening (which is one of BSG's usual strengths). It exists more often within standard, uninventive storytelling conventions.
At this point in my movie- and TV-viewing life, I'm almost willing to say that any pitch that can be summarized as "hostage situation" should be thrown out by whomever is potentially producing it. At its core, that's what "Sacrifice" is — a "hostage situation." On the Cloud Nine, terrorists take over the bar — which happens to be conveniently occupied by several key Galactica characters — and make their demands. The question is how to deal with the terrorists and how to save the hostages. Describing it like that is probably enough to make your eyes glaze over.
Fortunately, there's a little more to it than that, and it's worth noting that BSG's writers have employed their routine plot in a way that makes sense and relates to key issues on the show. The terrorists are demanding that Admiral Adama turn over Sharon Valerii to them for execution because they think she's a Cylon agent that's working for the Cylons and not the Colonial Fleet. Hell, they may even turn out to be right. You never know with the Cylons, not even with Sharon, who has saved the Galactica on more than one occasion.
The terrorists are led by Sesha Abinell (Dana Delaney), who, we learn in the opening minutes, lost her husband in a recent Cylon attack. She's fed up with the Colonial Fleet's apparent lack of assessing and dealing with threats, and says that if the military is not willing to take action against Valerii, then she and other civilians must take matters into their own hands.
Sesha is a domestic terrorist, plain and simple; she's willing to kill, or even be killed, so long as her cause is advanced. Like any ready-to-be-martyred terrorist, to her the movement is larger than her own life or anyone else's. She's using violence to advance a cause she believes will make things better for the homeland, as opposed to a terrorists who want to simply destroy his enemies. The arrogance of domestic terrorism is, of course, that a few people decide to do what they think is right for all of us, meanwhile using innocent bystanders as currency.
The selfish human complication here is that Sesha has lost someone close to her. But as Adama rightly points out, everyone in the Fleet has lost someone — if not everyone — close to them. What makes Sesha more entitled to carry out terrorist threats and take hostages? The answer, obviously, is nothing. I'm trying to do character analysis here, but there's really not much to say about the personality type that believes they're entitled to demands simply because they've made them.
The reason you can't negotiate with terrorists is very simply, as Tigh puts it, because you'd "open the floodgates." You'd be under siege every week. The story question here is how the people in charge of working the threat behave when the threat becomes personal (a plot thread which propelled an entire season, or perhaps three, of 24). On board the Cloud Nine are Lee, Dualla, Billy, and Ellen Tigh. This makes it a very personal situation for Adama, Roslin, and Tigh as they make decisions on how to handle the crisis from the Galactica. Much of the episode is about stalling for time, as such hostage scenarios ago.
Interesting is how much of a hard line Roslin takes. She seems even less willing to cave — even for the sake of stalling — than does Adama. True, Billy is not her blood the way Lee's is Adama's, but as Roslin correctly points out, Billy is as close a thing to family as she has left in this world. The terrorists know who the hostages are and use that knowledge. Meanwhile, Adama contacts Kara, who just happens to be taking vacation time also on Cloud Nine, so she can infiltrate the bar for recon purposes.
On board the Cloud Nine are the usual standoffs, shootings, etc. One thing that definitely got my attention, however, was the story's massive momentum shift when Kara ends up in the bar and gets forced into a shootout with the terrorists. In the confusion, she accidentally shoots Lee in the chest ("It was friendly fire," she later tells Adama, in tears). Every once in a while something happens in a routine plot that makes you sit up and become reinvested in the story, and this is one of those moments.
Such moments are the exception to the rule, however. "Sacrifice" is more often reluctant to deviate from formula. Possibly the most true-to-BSG moments are the ones that focus on character rather than plot, like the opening sequence where Billy proposes marriage to Dualla, who, in a scene of agonizing discomfort, turns him down. Naturally, it follows that Dee and Lee — who have been the corners in the Dee-Billy-Lee triangle for several episodes now — will shortly thereafter unexpectedly run into Billy at the bar on the Cloud Nine just before the terrorists take it over. Billy's words to Dualla here are even more agonizing, because they are in response to a perceived betrayal, and have the ring of truth. I'd imagine I'd be pretty pissed too, if I were in his position.
The other unexpected moment is when Billy is shot and killed in the episode's climactic struggle for control of the bar, when the marines storm in and the machine guns come out. Billy has been on this series since the beginning, and killing him here is what earns the story its title, since most of the characters in the episode don't have to make any real sacrifices. If this episode truly had the convictions of its title, Adama would have to let Lee bleed to death rather than negotiate with the terrorists, but obviously we are boxed in here by the fact that we can't go killing off our lead characters (just the supporting ones).
What does not play as a surprise is Adama's attempted shell game, where he pretends he's going to hand Sharon over to Sesha and instead gives her the corpse of the Sharon killed in "Resistance." This will instantly be obvious to any audience member (who has been paying attention) from the moment Adama announces his terms and hangs up the phone. My thinking is that it should've been obvious to Sesha as well, since the other Sharon's death is a matter of public record.
The episode's best payoff is the heartbreaking scene where Roslin visits Billy's body in the morgue. Roslin, who maintained a tough, rightful hard line about not caving in to terrorists during the crisis, is seen at the end as an individual who has truly paid the price of those convictions. It's a credit to Mary McDonnell's performance that all sides of Roslin's persona exist believably, seamlessly, and in no way in contradiction with each other. They are a part of a realized whole.
I'm not entirely sure what to make of the scene where Dualla visits Lee in sickbay. Clearly, this is a woman who has reached a conclusion about who she's really in love with. Maybe that's an easier conclusion to reach when the other guy is lying on a slab in a freezer. Yes, relationships can be messy and sometimes you crash through one with no idea where it's going or why, but this to me feels a little nebulous, like the writers just sort of concocted the Dualla/Lee thing — even though, yes, there were hints of it as far back as "Resistance."
I guess that's as a good note as any to end on regarding "Sacrifice." This is an okay show with some nice moments, but it's not a deep or complex one, and it doesn't feel ironclad in its romantic motivation. And I guess every once in a while a supporting character has to die to remind you that maybe no one is safe.
Previous episode: Scar
Next episode: The Captain's Hand
Like this site? Support it by buying Jammer a coffee.
24 comments on this post
Tue, Dec 23, 2008, 4:05am (UTC -5)
I am currently in the process of watching the show for the first time and by this episode, BSG seem to be more depressing than anything I've seen on TV before, including X-Files and the first three seasons of 24. It seems the writers are getting out of their way to systematically break the characters (seriously, who isn't a manic-depressive or drug addict yet?) and to delay or skip expected payoff scenes. It's become more of a cathartic experience than entertainment.
In this particular case, I was looking forward to a Starbuck/Apollo scene where they bring up the friendly fire incident, but I guess the Dualla/Apollo pairing (which severely lacks chemistry between the actors in my opinion) was more important. Secondly, sticking Starbuck into the background is a silly plot device and a rather cheap and ancient way of exposition that has been used by BSG several times already.
And then there is the death of Billy, which I felt was gimmicky at best and just a way to create a Dualla/Apollo/Starbuck love triangle taken straight out of Beverly Hills 90210. Besides, I think the Dualla character comes off like a hooker in this one. Does she even mourn for Billy?
The one thing that really works here is the aforementioned friendly fire accident. Now here's something that is a natural risk in such a line of work (I suppose) and doesn't happen to often on screen. I certainly didn't expect it. But overall this was a weak episode and not the kind of "dark entertainment" I am looking for - it's just to obviously messing with the audience.
Overall, I think you nailed it once again. While I concurred with most of your old Trek reviews, your take on BSG seems to be even closer to my own.
With best wishes from Germany,
Fri, Nov 6, 2009, 11:48pm (UTC -5)
Tue, Feb 2, 2010, 10:21am (UTC -5)
Tue, Mar 23, 2010, 10:52pm (UTC -5)
And I reckon they're right on sharon too. She's playing them. The fleet's being played. I think there's possibly two factions within the cylons and Sharon/Six are in the less evil of the two, but this faction (or the cylons as a whole if there aren't two factions) is clearly using pregnant sharon to infiltrate the fleet. To what ultimate end I'm not sure, but some combination of leading them to earth in order to utterly destroy humanity or creating a hybrid-human race that will maybe lead to peace between the races/factions seems likely. Either way, Sharon's interests are very unlikely to match the fleet's interests and she SHOULD be killed as a security threat which is exactly what the terrorists are demanding.
This is what sets this episode apart from run of the mill terrorist/hostage scenarios. The bad guys are right. I think :).
Thu, May 12, 2011, 10:44am (UTC -5)
Sun, Jun 5, 2011, 11:20am (UTC -5)
I've not watched any episodes after this, but it seems to me they killed off Billy just so Apollo could schtupp Dualla without Billy being in the way. It was pointless, arbitrary, and just wrong. Much like Ianto's death in Torchwood.
I'm hoping there's more to it than just that. maybe future episodes will reveal something to come out of this. I hope so.
Sun, Jun 5, 2011, 12:22pm (UTC -5)
Billy also was supposed to accompany Roslin when she fled Galactica in "Resistance." But Campbell was not available for the arc, so they wrote that exchange between Roslin and Billy where he says that he can't go with her because that would be crossing a line. Sometimes on TV the realities of the business influence what gets written.
Mon, Jun 13, 2011, 10:23pm (UTC -5)
And how could anyone still think Sharon is 'playing' them? If it wasn't for her they would ALL BE DEAD by now. They owe her their lives, several times over. It's revolting enough that they still keep her in a cell. I've said it before, but I'll say it again: the only two characters I'm rooting for are Helo and Sharon.
Fri, Nov 18, 2011, 4:33pm (UTC -5)
Not happy about Billy being killed off. I understand about the show production and all, but they could have replaced him with a lookalike. He was one of the few sweet and innocent, truly likable characters on there.
Not happy about Starbuck further imploding. She's a shadow of her former self.
I am inclined to agree with you concerning Boomer's treatment, but, then, why was her riposte to Adam's question--albeit hypothetical--about whether she would give up cylon agents in the Fleet negative?
I wouldn't trust her either if I was in their shoes. I'd perhaps not sheckle and manacle her the way they're doing, but I'd not give her free reign of Galactica either.
Thu, Apr 26, 2012, 3:42am (UTC -5)
Sun, Jan 27, 2013, 8:38am (UTC -5)
Fri, May 31, 2013, 6:34pm (UTC -5)
Farewell, Billy! We hardly knew ye. Oh well... At least you got to have lots of sex, like all the other characters on the show. Oh wait- darn!
Maybe Billy will show up later as a Cylon. Then he will get to have lots of sex, as that seems to be what Cylons do best. Maybe their whole "plan" is simply to create a new supply of porn for all their buddies stuck on the Cylon homeworld, who are slightly bored with only 12 models to choose from :)
Thu, Aug 29, 2013, 9:18pm (UTC -5)
Sat, Dec 28, 2013, 12:48am (UTC -5)
Sun, Jan 12, 2014, 8:57pm (UTC -5)
Hey, but on the plus side, there's no flash-forward in this one.
Mon, Jul 21, 2014, 9:51am (UTC -5)
This principle - I guess every once in a while a supporting character has to die to remind you that maybe no one is safe. - is true (and enlarged to massive scale in Game of Thrones.
Thu, Mar 12, 2015, 1:41am (UTC -5)
Starbuck still rubs me the wrong way!
Sat, Jul 25, 2015, 3:20pm (UTC -5)
Thu, Jun 22, 2017, 12:24pm (UTC -5)
Thu, Aug 31, 2017, 2:40am (UTC -5)
Billy is so sadly pathetic. It's like this relationship is all in his head and he's just wandering around clueless. I dont think Dualla deceived him. It is more that she simply does not reciprocate those feelings for Billy, so Billy feels betrayed. But I dont know that it is. She never lied to him. It seems like she was just seeing him on and off and he turned it into something more serious without her being in it with him. As I said, It seems more like a one sided thing where he imagines the relationship to be something it actually isnt.
Anyway, to then have him later take a bullet for her was the final straw in terms of pathetic. Why would he do such a stupid thing? Do people really think DYING for someone else, especially someone who doesnt give a shit about you, is romantic? Or kind of endearing? This was almost clichee. The writers are better than that. And then she gets over him in like 2 seconds. Poor Billy. He just might be the one of the most tragic characters on the show.
Mon, Feb 22, 2021, 12:54pm (UTC -5)
Sat, Dec 10, 2022, 3:53am (UTC -5)
Wed, Feb 15, 2023, 7:55pm (UTC -5)
I like Billy as a character and it sucks that he dies. Got to be a bit soap-opera-ish with the love triangle of Lee / Dualla / Billy. The Lee / Dualla romance comes and goes. Not a fan of keeping track of all the potential relationships (throw Kara in there with Lee).
But in terms of mechanics of the hostage situation, negotiations, this was well done. The leadership have personal stakes.
More interesting is Adama questioning Sharon on if he's being played and being told he's being played by Tigh and the terrorist lady. Sharon won't tell him who the other Cylons are, but she has caused the death of many Cylons by helping Galactica...
2.5 stars for "Sacrifice" -- disappointed when it became clear the episode was another terrorist / hostage show, but some of the twists & turns raised the stakes. Another episode with civilian issues bubbling to the surface. One can't help feeling bad for Billy who got rejected by Dualla, then has to help the man Dualla's on a date with, and then tries to play hero and gets killed. Talk about a bad day.
Tue, Mar 7, 2023, 10:08am (UTC -5)
Btw Jammer wrote "The arrogance of domestic terrorism is, of course, that a few people decide to do what they think is right for all of us, meanwhile using innocent bystanders as currency."
Exchange "terrorism" for "government" and the sentence still rings true. Strange times.
Submit a comment
◄ Season Index