Jammer's Review

Star Trek: The Next Generation

"Half a Life"


Air date: 5/6/1991
Teleplay by Peter Allan Fields
Story by Ted Roberts and Peter Allan Fields
Directed by Les Landau

Review by Jamahl Epsicokhan

What is it about the Trois that, given the starring spotlight, ultimately make me want to crawl under my kitchen table and hide? Whether it's "The Child" or "Manhunt" or "Menage a Troi" or "The Loss" — they just never seem to work. Bad stories? Bad characterization? My own anti-Troi bias that I don't want to admit? Maybe a little of all of it? I'm not sure, but good intentions misfire here.

In "Half a Life," we have Lwaxana Troi aboard the ship (rarely a good sign, although this episode ultimately tries to utilize her better than most) at the same time as Timicin (David Ogden Stiers), a scientist about to test an experimental procedure on a dying star that will hopefully allow his people to save their own dying sun. Lwaxana and Timicin meet and fall instantly in love, pursuant to every unrealistic timeline in every love story in every TV show and movie. This November-November romance isn't bad, but not compelling either. But then the other shoe drops: Timicin, in accordance with his people's longstanding culture, is scheduled to kill himself on his 60th birthday, mere days away.

To me, the episode was basically unsalvageable once Lwaxana came to her daughter wailing ("wailing" isn't a word I have reason to use very often) over the fact that Timicin must die "JUST BECAUSE HE'S SIXTY!" There's drama, and then there's melodrama. And then there's nails on a chalkboard. Lwaxana Troi wailing is maybe two steps beyond the chalkboard. I'm being mean, but when you have a story based on arbitrary alien customs, performances matter.

What can I say? Lwaxana is right. (Her message is fine, even if I still want to shoot the messenger.) Far be it for me to judge a fictional belief, but Timicin's society's custom is hopelessly silly, and based on all kinds of nonsensical logic and assumptions about the dignity of death in the face of aging, and avoiding getting so old you're soiling yourself, or whatever. The allegorical point here, somewhat rendered useless by stretching the story past the absurd point, seems to hint at our own society's general disregard for the elderly. But just as "The Loss" was an ineffective allegory for disability, "Half a Life" is a failed allegory for getting old. Do we blame the Trois? Well, maybe I shouldn't be that unfair.

Previous episode: The Drumhead
Next episode: The Host

Season Index

34 comments on this review

Jake - Fri, Mar 21, 2008 - 11:00am (USA Central)
I actually enjoyed "Half a Life." That episode(and "Dark Page") kept Lwaxana from becoming as bad as Neelix or Jar Jar. It showed her to be, shall we say, a more human person as she found happiness with a kind man who actually returned her affections, only to be held back by his own society's obligations(we can call those obligations 'silly,' but, hey, there are some here on Earth that I find silly, too).
"Qpid" was another fun episode. Granted, there was no suspense, per se(like Q would allow Picard & co. to die in a fantasy he created), but it was witty, and how could you NOT love Worf's classic "I am not a merry man."
I actually cherred when Satie broke down at the end of "The Drumhead." I thought it worked because Picard referenced her father, so the fact that it was a personal nerve that set her off made sense to me.
Eduardo - Sun, Mar 23, 2008 - 3:09pm (USA Central)
I never really understood the overwhelming hatred towards Lwaxana.

I never had a problem with either the character, or Majel Barrett's interpretation of the character. Once you accept what she represents, I think she can be pleasant to a certain degree. And when she's not, it always pays off to notice the crew's annoyed reaction to her.

She was never my favorite, but I've seen worse characters on Voyager.

Half a Life was actually one of my favorite episodes that season. It dealt with the issue through Timicin's internal conflict as well as Lwaxana's own guilt and struggle. Despite the cornball romance being grown within 2 minutes, I actually enjoyed the chemistry between both actors.

As for Wesley, he was never the strongest character, but his best moments were the ones Wil Wheaton played against Patrick. Picard was as close to a father figure as anyone could get.

Final Mission was also a favorite of mine, which would eventually get a stunning direct sequel through The First Duty. I look forward to that particular review.

On the other hand, I would have been harsher on both The Loss and Suddenly Human.

As a whole, I actually enjoyed this season a lot more than the third. It felt a bit more consistent and entertaining.
Markus - Sat, Oct 17, 2009 - 8:50am (USA Central)
In "Half a Life" I couldn't stop laughing, when directly in the beginning Deanna says to the log "my mother is on board" and then picard looks carefully around before leaving the turbolift. great!
Tim - Thu, May 24, 2012 - 3:15pm (USA Central)
The weeping scene was somewhat over the top! This episode left me feeling a little glum after. Normally the message at the end is quite uplifting and I expected them to make inroads into changing the custom, but no, it just showed that resistance is futile, and one must surrender to such customs. Qpid was much more uplifting!
Jess - Sat, Mar 2, 2013 - 1:45am (USA Central)
And no one is mentioning the novelty of having Winchester from M*A*S*H* playing a Star Trek alien?
Grumpy - Sat, Mar 2, 2013 - 5:13pm (USA Central)
Maybe after 7 years of watching the original Father Mulcahy on DS9, a one-off guest shot isn't as exciting.

(And the original Hot Lips in "Where No Man..." and the original Painless as the Klingon Ambassador, etc.)
mike - Wed, Mar 6, 2013 - 12:15am (USA Central)
Jammer, you must be very young, otherwise you would recognized that is episode had a poignancy that middle agers understand--dignity in old age. Timicin and Luxwanna weren't in love. They just saw in each other a chance to not be lonely. When you're young you can have friends aplenty. But in later years they drift away until finally you are as Timicin glumly observed "the recipients of young people's patience"

The story wasn't terribly exciting but give it some credit for showing us Luxwanna can rise above being just comic relief. As soon as she's told Timicin must commit ritual suicide, she sobers up and behaves like anyone else who might be appauled by the idea of euthanasia. And that's the issue here. Star Trek is always tackling one social issue or another and this week it's euthanasia.

Whereas Luxwanna is usually self absorbed and silly in every episode that features her character, this time we find she can logically debate a serious issue. "ah, celebration of life," she mocks as she hears Timicin explain his society's ritual suicide. "What you really mean is you got rid of the problem by getting rid of the people". And you can't laugh it off because she's absolutely right.

Of course her over extended talking while weeping is a bit over the top but by the end the hour the gaudy wardrobe and shrill vocals are gone. She actually calls Picard properly by his rank in the last scene.

I'm glad the story ended realistically with Luxwanna gracefully accepting Timicin's decision to adhere to his culture's demands. Too many times we've seen our gallant Starfleet crew miraculously convert planetary cultures and leave orbit.

Hat's off as well to David Ogden Stiers who played an alien with a very human dilemma. The fact that he didn't have awesome powers or could walk through walls kept his character easy to attach to the euthanasia issue.
T'Paul - Mon, Jun 10, 2013 - 9:35am (USA Central)
I tend to agree with the pro-Lwaxana camp here... it was a good performance in character with her previous development.

And this episode was far more coherent and dare I say it meaningful than other episodes in this season such as Night Terrors and and Identity Crisis that are throw away one off techno-babble mysteries.

In fact the poor rating of this episode surprises me as a whole given how Jammer generally defends character-based stories and to me tends to suggest a bit of an anti-Lwaxana bias.

I also thought the "alien of the week" was excellently played, and even if the message was somewhat laboured, it wasn't a bad discussion to have
Dom - Thu, Jun 13, 2013 - 10:07pm (USA Central)
I don't think this episode was about disability. Rather, I thought it was about intergenerational conflict. When people live longer, is it fair to society that they also consume resources and the young don't have as many opportunities. We're facing this problem right now. Yes, enforced suicide is a silly solution, but guess what - it's not far off from what might happen. What if government cuts medical care for the elderly? What if we stop research into anti-aging technology precisely so we don't run into these sorts of problems? This is the type of episode that for me at least still makes TNG relevant today.
mephyve - Sat, Jun 22, 2013 - 7:02pm (USA Central)
Half a life was just plain stupid. Euthenasia would have made it more palatable. Accepted suicide? Cmon. Even a show like Dinosaurs was smart enough to come to a logical and objective conclusion on this subject. As much as I would have loved to see Earl hurl his mother in law off a mountain and into the tar pit, Robbie actually made sense out of the situation.
Half a Life's stupid premise doomed it ftom the get go.
William B - Mon, Jul 8, 2013 - 4:20pm (USA Central)
While I like the movie, my "M*A*S*H" is the TV show and so I do love having David Ogden Stiers in the episode more than the other examples listed by Grumpy (well, I mean, I love Rene Auberjonois as Odo more than Stiers as Timincin obviously, but I don't really associate Auberjonois that much with M*A*S*H; he had a bigger role in "McCabe & Mrs. Miller" anyway in the Altman canon).

I agree that the Lwaxana scene in the transporter room was pretty unbearably acted, though many of the sentiments worked for me. I do think this and "Haven" are the two main candidates for best Lwaxana episode of the series, which, granted, is not saying much. And unlike Jammer, I think that the romance actually is believable for more reasons than the ones given. Lwaxana is on vacation and is especially flirtatious and lonely; she is always as forward as she is here, but it's almost never that other people reciprocate. And Timicin is going to die in a week -- so there isn't exactly the time for dawdling. It's possible that they exchange "ILY's" too quickly, but I think that's again somewhat forced by the situation -- everything is more intense when there is no time for indecision.

The premise borrows from "Logan's Run," but is less absurd than that (pushing from 30 to 60, naturally). The killing of the elderly once they cease to be vital is also an element in "Brave New World." I suppose I don't really think that the allegory in this episode is so ludicrous, though I can't say why I find it easier to accept (as premise) than many here do. What Timicin speaks of is something I understand, looking at my own family history: their society is dedicated to "protecting" everyone from dealing with what it means to become old -- very old. The last years of a person's life are difficult and frightening. Lwaxana, more so than any of the main cast (though this story *could* be told with Picard), is approaching a period in her life, akin to the one Quaice mentioned in "Remember Me," in which (at least she fears) she's going to continue losing people she cares about and it is unlikely that her life will get better. Her quality of life will be lowered and she will become a burden to others rather than a the strong independent woman she prides herself on being.

In much of Western society these days, the elderly are not really sufficiently cared for. Timicin's description of death watch facilities where people simply waited to die is not far off from what some nursing homes are. Ideally, people would be cared for in the last years of their lives rather than (ultimately) abandoned to a system which cannot sufficiently provide for them, but for the most part we don't live in that ideal world, though I do think it seems plausible that the Federation does. "Die at sixty, regardless of one's situation" is a reducto ad absurdum, but the episode is certainly not arguing in favour of it, or even (imo) presenting it as a reasonable hypothesis. I think what it's more doing is showing why Timicin would prefre to die rather than live out his last years in a way that terrifies him; and Lwaxana does not have the right or jurisdiction to tell him not to. The forced-death is also an allegory for forced retirement (note how his work stops being taken seriously), as well as a general impression from the young that the elderly are not worthwhile contributors to society. Timicin dies, ultimately, because he doesn't have the courage to fight a world that tells him he's useless, and it's a tragedy that I find rather touching. He gives up, and take that as representing whatever reality of aging in our world you like -- no longer fighting for his usefulness, accepting forced retirement, moving to a nursing home and waiting to die. Lwaxana has compassion for him, though she is the model of what to do instead -- to carry on despite the sadness and fears that she have; and of course Deanna is a positive contrast to Timicin's daughter, who I think does care for him but is unable to conceive of what he's going through.

I think Timcin is well-performed, though it might just be that I like the actor. Majel Barret Roddenberry, sadly, is not up to the task that the episode requires of her, and so I like Lwaxana's role in the episode much better in the abstract than in reality. While I don't really mind the "resolution" part of the episode's premise, exaggerated though it is, the standard-issue "alien warships to start incident!" part of the story was unnecessary and silly. The episode has significant flaws but I still have some fondness for it: 2.5 stars, I'd say.
Corey - Wed, Jul 10, 2013 - 1:51pm (USA Central)

William, you usually write pretty good reviews, but I think your comment that the warships come to the Enterprise was silly or unnecessary wasn't on target - if the Enterprise doesn't return Timicin, they are abetting breaking an obviously important law to the people of that planet.

Think of it another way - American parents think dearly of their children - what if the Mexican government was sending its agents to kidnap our children? The parents would contact their congressman, and it would not surprise me to see American Navy ships in Mexican ports, to basically say quit this practice or else. This is a similar situation.

Also note that Timicin is well known - if he gets away with it (not doing the suicide ritual), it could send ripples through society - the planetary government realizes this quite well, and thus sends their warships.
William B - Wed, Jul 10, 2013 - 3:38pm (USA Central)
@Corey: what I meant was that I thought it was unnecessary within the episode to cause dramatic tension (and a pretty familiar device for this show, see e.g. "Suddenly Human"), not so much that it's unbelievable or out of character for Timicin's people to send warships. So they are different arguments. And while I agree that it's plausible that Timicin's people would send warships, I don't think that it's so certain that the episode would be unbelievable without that element (I don't see myself sitting through the second half of the episode thinking, "why aren't they sending warships?" if that hadn't happened). I think the threat of major diplomatic tensions is sufficient, especially since Timicin is already going to suffer exile for his decision.
Corey - Wed, Jul 10, 2013 - 5:41pm (USA Central)
@William - I see where you are coming from. Except, actually, I think it was actually necessary for the story. Lwaxxanna, had nearly convinced Timicin to stay alive, when the news about the warships approaching the Enterprise arrived. In the story, that was the turning point, Timicin would not choose his life if meant risking the lives of the Enterprise or his fellow citizens on the warships, he would do what was right in the eyes of his people, and that was that.

Without the warships, Timicin would choose life, which apparently was not the ending the writer wanted. That would be happy ending for Lwaxxanna, but not more dramatically powerful. So thus, they WERE necessary, contrary to your argument.
William B - Wed, Jul 10, 2013 - 9:29pm (USA Central)
@Corey: I know what you mean, but I took the true turning point -- and indeed the bigger emotional whallop -- as being Timicin's conversation with his daughter. When Picard asks Timicin at the episode's end if he's going back to relieve diplomatic tensions between their peoples, Timicin says, "it's not just that."
Coffeeaddict - Mon, Aug 19, 2013 - 8:06pm (USA Central)
This is one of those episodes that always tended to annoy and anger me. Not merely because of the characters, but the whole mess of a story. Is it trying to make an argument/cause debate about the actual issue of euthanasia, or about the dangers of euthanasia being taken too far? It doesn't do the former, and the latter just seems unnecessary, beating us over the head with the point that this action taken against Temicin was wrong when no one in their right mind was thinking this was a good idea.

Look at the arguments made by the culture for doing this. They claim to want to spare individuals the indignity of becoming sick, but they don't wait for anyone to actually become sick or even begin to diminish. They want to spare children the burden of caring for their parents when that's not anywhere close to being an issue for anyone yet. What happens if someone becomes ill or infirm at 55? Do they have to wait until 60? Is an exception for early death made for them? Do they up an start making everyone die at 55 because of one sick person? But most damning of all, they show that they don't give a damn what the 60 year old's own wishes are, as shown when they force Temicin to die despite his wish not to. And at the end of the story absolutely NO progress is made towards their culture examining what they're doing, or the reasons for it, or Timicins brief resistance having any effect. Indeed the only positive I took away at the end was that hopefully their foolish actions will doom their whole planet, ending the practice once and for all.
Daniel Davis - Wed, Aug 28, 2013 - 12:04pm (USA Central)
CoffeeAddict, I completely agree with you.

It would be awesome to see someone write a novel or future Star Trek series episode where a mention is made of how the-now dead, lifeless world doomed itself due to the people's utter stupidity.
K'Elvis - Thu, Nov 7, 2013 - 8:52am (USA Central)
Only someone very young would think that you can't have dignity or enjoy life when you reach the "ancient" age of 60. Only someone very young would think that people can't find love at 60 or older. That perspective is that of a child, who thinks being old must be a terrible thing. But when people to get older, they find it not such a bad thing at all.

The problem with this episode is that it is muddy with its ideas. If you try to cover all aspects of an issue, you make a muddy mess of it. This episode started well as an exploration of ageism. His culture demands that people die at 60, but he doesn't want to die, and decides not to die. So far we're fine. He could have left his planet.

Instead, they trash the anti-ageism message, and we get "accept the demands of your culture, even if it means your death." If you want to explore two different ideas, then write two different episodes. He wants to live, and wants to be with Lwxana, but has a sudden about-face and goes happily to his death. He exchanges what he wants to avoid exile, the scorn of his family and of his culture. Someone might well accept death to avoid exile and scorn, but they aren't very likely to be happy about it.
Moonie - Sat, Nov 23, 2013 - 7:44am (USA Central)
I'm really surprised by the low rating you gave this episode. And four stars for the Barclay Technobabble dumbness?? Sometimes I think it must be a generational thing.

Anyway, it was so nice to see Lwaxanna as a real person versus just a caricature of a middle-aged woman. (As a soon-to-be middle-aged woman myself, I was often wildly angered by her portrayal, and the fact that even though she's around the same age as our dear Captain,he recoils in horror at her advances....pretty misogynistic if you ask me.)

I really wish this episode would have ended differently but I know Timicin would crack when his daughter showed up to direct him back on the right path. Oh, children and their self-righteousness.

It's episodes like that that really make me wonder about the whole "non-interference" rule. "It's their culture! (tradition, religion)" is, in my opinion, a pretty weak reason to accept barbarism. In such a case the prime directive basically is the equivalent of civilised nations turning a blind eye to stonings and honor killings because "it's their culture".

I don't agree with this at all. I guess I can't join Starfleet after all.
William B - Sat, Nov 23, 2013 - 8:08am (USA Central)
@Moonie, I agree with most of what you say here (though I love the Barclay ep in question), and I like this episode more than most. But I disagree a bit about Picard. His "recoiling in horror" is...actually how he deals with almost all interpersonal issues where someone gets close. He pretty much recoiled in horror from Wesley the first few times he saw him in season one, for example. He reacts pretty similarly to young women approaching him on Risa in "Captain's Holiday," and only grows to like Vash as a result of their adventure together. And I think "Manhunt" screwed this up by having Deanna tell Picard helpfully that he's not allowed to turn her down because it might hurt her feelings, so that his only options are to enter into a relationship he doesn't really want with the mother of one of his crewmembers, or to hide. Or, of course, to ignore Deanna (best option) and just be honest with Lwaxana. Personally I think "Manhunt," with the "middle-aged women just so crazy yo, nothing you can do!" attitude, is a huge problem pretty much throughout.

That scene with Timicin and his daughter (and indeed the whole episode) reminds me of the 1950's movie "All that Heaven Allows," where middle-aged Jane Wyman has an affair with a much younger man and her children keep pressuring her to give it up because It's Right. SPOILERS she eventually relents, and then of course her children go on and go back to ignoring her and then get her a television set for company. I'm not wild about aspects of the execution of this episode but I think emotionally and thematically it's fine.
SkepticalMI - Sat, Apr 12, 2014 - 4:50pm (USA Central)
This is probably the best Lwaxana episode, not that that's saying much. I think I like the idea of her more than the actual presence of her. Some of the stupid Lwaxana tricks (such as nearly launching a photon torpedo) are just silly, but seeing some of the reactions to her works well. It just doesn't help when the plots surrounding her shows are awful (see Menage a Troi as an example). So it was nice to see a good plot for once. And it was nice to see Lwaxana forced out of her annoying mother character and into something more sobering.

I won't get too much into the death/respect of elders aspect, because I felt there was another theme there too that nobody else commented on. And that is the theme of love vs one's tradition and culture. Timicin did find himself falling in love with Lwaxana, and was then forced to choose between that love and everything that he was. Lwaxana was, essentially, asking him to sacrifice his entire way of life just to be with her, while Timicin was demanding that she put aside all of her morals and beliefs and accept his fate. And, to the story's credit, Timicin simply could not abandon his life for his new love (just as Worf couldn't in Emissary). Relationships ain't easy, and it's not clear how much of yourself you can bury for your partner. Yes, this is a more fantastic version of this theme than, say, one person wanting kids and the other doesn't, but it still demonstrates it all the same. And because of the fantastical nature of the rift between Troi and Timicin, the helplessness and anger Lwaxana feels hits home just a little bit more.
Kieran - Thu, Apr 24, 2014 - 9:28am (USA Central)
I must admit when Troi's voiceover said "My mother is on board", I was tempted to hit the off switch immediately, but I'm glad I stuck this one out. It raised some interesting questions about ageing and care for the elderly and I liked the sombre way the actor who played Timicin played it. Lwaxana was annoying as ever but at least she was annoying in a good episode for once.
Marcwolf - Sun, May 4, 2014 - 10:31pm (USA Central)
One of the main things I enjoy about Star Trek is the chance to explore other idea's and viewpoints.
This is a very good episode because it covers just that.
It's not a pleasant prospect (myself in my 50's) to have to die at 60. But if the choice is reducing resources to the more productive members of society then maybe that is an option.
Sadly Star Trek can only give so much of a societies background in one hour so we might never know of all of the reasons for Timicin needing to die.
Andy's Friend - Mon, May 5, 2014 - 7:56pm (USA Central)
@Marcwolf: Thanks for your comment, coming as you say from someone in his 50s.

I find this is one of the most underrated episodes of TNG. It touches on several hugely important issues in our world, as our societies grow ever more international.

We’ve had aspects of it for ages, like the centuries-old question: if a Catholic/Jew/Moslem/Orthodox/Protestant/[your faith here] marries someone from another faith, how shall they raise their children? And so on and so forth.

Of course, this kind of cultural interchange was very limited until the 20th century. But these past decades we’ve seen more and more of it, especially ― I’m making an educated guess now ― in Europe, where we have much clearer cultural identities and defining lines than in the Americas, and where very recent and very massive immigration from other cultures, and the very process of forging a European Union, is forcing us to reevaluate not only our administrative, but also our normative systems. The difference between say, Greeks and Swedes is greater than say, between Alaskans and Texans. And certain cultural problems that arise when boy meets girl and falls in love are indeed beginning to be felt.

So in my book, this is Star Trek at its near-best.

Furthermore, the actual example in this episode is of course hugely relevant. You say you’re in your 50s. Well, I’m around 40 myself. I’m pretty sure that if I were say, 55, and a law was passed that would kill me off at 60, I wouldn’t be too happy about it. But if I had grown up all my life knowing that law existed, I would make the most of the twenty or so years I had left. Actually, I’m sure that I would have lived life more intensely than I actually have. In my line of business (I’m a historian), you can keep going as long as you have a lucid mind; but if I knew that there was a (literal) deadline, I would be more in a hurry to finish the projects I have, and move on, and live life ― instead of reading and writing comments here! It’s an interesting thought.

You are also right about that very fundamental phrase of yours, “One of the main things I enjoy about Star Trek is the chance to explore other ideas and viewpoints.” This episode, along with ENTs “Progenitor”, is the one that does it best in all Trek, in my opinion. It is incredibly arrogant to judge supposedly alien cultures in space by our moral standards. These two episodes thankfully let the alien culture win, as it should, in a way unlike say, VOYs “Distant Origin”

But as I said, this episode not only works well in a literal reading, but also as a metaphor. Sadly, it has none of the great lines of say, “The Measure of a Man” or “Q Who?”, nor does it benefit from outstanding performances by say, Patrick Stewart or Brent Spiner.

“Half a Life” is a relatively quiet, slow-paced episode. But its subject matter ― both the specific in the episode, and the abstract metaphor ― is too important to be anything less than three stars. I think it works well on so many levels, and touches such important questions, that I wouldn’t hesitate to give it 3.5 stars.
Andy's Friend - Mon, May 5, 2014 - 8:19pm (USA Central)
^^^^ That's ENTs "Cogenitor", of course, and not progenitor. It's geting late; perhaps I should go to sleep! ;)
Robert - Tue, May 6, 2014 - 9:17am (USA Central)
I've always liked this episode. I like Lwaxana when shes not being totally ridiculous and here is my favorite episode with her. I also particularly like her in the episode where she's stuck in the turbolift with Odo and the one where she marries him (although not the A plot of that episode).
Nonya - Thu, Dec 4, 2014 - 3:03pm (USA Central)
I agree with Robert. I like this side of Lwaxana, when she is going out of her way to be kind to others. She really is a sensitive person, when she tones it down a notch. The episodes where she doesn't tone it down are usually awful, but her being there doesn't guarantee the episode sucks.

As for the anti-aging debate, I don't mind its existence. Sure, it was handled clumsily, but arguing about this idea makes sense for the show. I hated the ending, however. Kirk never would have let them kill Timicin. Some days you just need a Kirk to come in and bellow his clumsy self-righteous banter until the opposition gives in. :)
Adam - Sun, Dec 21, 2014 - 12:52am (USA Central)
"Soylent Green is people!"

Am I seriously the only one who was reminded of that movie by the premise of this episode?
Shannon - Sat, Jan 17, 2015 - 11:37pm (USA Central)
Jammer, I tend to agree with 95% of your reviews, but this is clearly an example of your anti-Trois bais affecting your rating. This is easily a 3-star episode, perhaps even 3.5 stars. Trek is at its best when it gets you to reflect on the human condition through its sci-fi platform. Yes, Luwaxana's wailing was a bit over the top, but this was a very effective use of her character. As the baby boomers age its going to put an enormous strain on our resources, and the topic of euthanasia, albeit an ugly one, will be lingering out there. Obamacare is probably one day going to head down the slippery slope of "rationed care", arguing that once you've outlived your usefulness, society shouldn't have to spend billions on the final years of life. This episode quite cleverly brings this topic out in the open and asks the question "is it better to end your life with dignity prior to be bed-ridden and soiling yourself"? I found it quite memorable and thought-provoking.
CPUFP - Sun, Jan 25, 2015 - 6:30pm (USA Central)
One thing about this episode made me wonder: If the Betazoids communicate telepathically with one another, why did they even develop verbal communication during their evolution as a species?
William B - Mon, Jan 26, 2015 - 5:57am (USA Central)
@CPUFP: A few possibilities that come to mind:

1) they developed telepathically after developing verbal communication, and it's semi-vestigial;
2) it's still useful to have verbal communication for recorded messages, long-distance communication, etc.;
3) telepathy doesn't work in all cases, even among Betazoids, and the exceptions are rare enough that they don't come up. It may be that even the average full-Betazoids are not at Lwaxana levels, and so verbal communication is useful as a result.
Robert - Mon, Jan 26, 2015 - 9:40am (USA Central)
Fanwank time.

There are 3 types of possible "telepathic powers".

1) Active Send - This would be when you can push your thoughts into the head of another person.

2) Active Connect - This would be when you can connect two minds together, similar to the Vulcan mind meld or Borg links.

3) Passive Receive - You always hear everything that is going on in a radius that your powers are capable of. You'd have to learn to tune into a specific voice and/or block them all out to not go insane. This was discussed in the "Tinman" episode and in Kes/Tuvok's lessons.

We pretty much know Betazoids have #3. Tam had issues tuning out the voices. Troi is sometimes overwhelmed by a powerful nearby emotional presence. So if someone is giving a speech they can "tune in" to the right voice (ie they guy on the podium). But assume for a minute that they DON'T have #1 also, you'd kind of need a voice box to say "Hey, Deanna" if you were behind her and wanted to start a conversation. Otherwise she'd be ignoring the background "static".

There is SOME evidence to support the other 2 kinds (primarily that Deanna talks to Riker telepathically). One would assume that since he cannot "receive" at all, that she must be able to "send" to him. And one primitive, pre-tech Betazoids can send and receive they honestly don't need to develop complex vocal cords at all.

Sure, once they develop the telephone they might be sad that they don't have vocal cords.... but presumably they'd just develop texting instead. Of course if Riker/Deanna talk via a link (as in #2), then they could still reasonably need vocal cords to indicate who you should "tune into". Although perhaps they don't need them to be so complex and would have just developed grunting.
CPUFP - Sat, Jan 31, 2015 - 6:12am (USA Central)
William B and Robert:
Thank you for your thoughts.

I think that maybe they just started developing these powers long after they already had created a spoken language. Since the powers don't seem to be distributed equally among the Betazoids (ranging from empathy to full telepathy including all three types Robert mentioned), it would make sense that they shouldn't rely exclusively on this form of communication.
CPUFP - Sat, Jan 31, 2015 - 7:11am (USA Central)
This episode also had me thinking about the Lwaxana character.

I usually find her quite entertaining. This is mainly due to the way Majel Barrett plays her, which makes even sub-standard plots like "Manhunt" or "Ménage à Troi" enjoyable. Barrett should really have been given a bigger role!

But in the first half of this episode, I was extremely annoyed by her. Flirting aggressively with a distinguished representative of a planet whose population usually avoids contact to other peoples? Disrupting a meeting for a picnic on the engineering console? I thought that Betazed's society was so hopelessly caught up in its aristocratic decadence that with the right pedigree, even a complete moron who is devoid of any diplomatic skill can become ambassador to the UFP.

During the second half though, I thought about the issue some more and got a different picture of Lwaxana. It's obvious that telepathic/empathic powers are an advantage in all professions where you have to negotiate, since you can sense what the other party is feeling and thinking, regardless of what they are saying explicitly. This was explored with Devinoni Ral in "The Price".

It's also logical that in a society where such powers are the norm, negotiations would be very different, since the other party can sense the same things about you. There would be two options to deal with this:
a) You leave diplomatic double-talk and ambiguity aside, put your cards on the table and openly confront the conflicts at hand.
b) You intentionally twist your own thoughts in order to make them harder to read for the other party. If you're only dealing with an empath and not a telepath, you could use techniques like thinking of pleasant experiences or you could use mood-altering drugs so that they could not sense your true feelings.

Lwaxana apparently relies on option a). In all her dealings, be it professionally or privately, she's usually completely open about her intentions and bluntly states her opinion about anything (much to the chagrin of her daughter). But this does not mean that she is oblivious to the effect of her actions on others. Actually, I think that she often used this behavior intentionally on non-telepathic/empathic persons in order to throw them off guard, since they are not used to such behavior, especially from a high-ranking diplomat. I think that she often does this to "test" the other person, in that she puts them in a somewhat extreme social situation and watches how they react. As a full telepath, she can also read the other person's cognitive response to her actions and see how it corresponds to their explicit response in actions and words.

We also know that her apparently un-diplomatic behavior is not a sign of stupidity, since Lwaxana can be pretty manipulative if it serves her interests, like she did with the Ferengi in "Ménage à Troi" or when she invited Picard for dinner in "Manhunt".

So in the end, this episode made me appreciate Lwaxana's character much more, since what on the surface seems like the actions of an oblivious buffoon is actually a pretty smart method for quickly getting a profile of people's thoughts and behavior - something which should definetely come in handy when working as an ambassador.

Submit a comment

Above, type the last name of the captain on Star Trek: TNG
Notify me about new comments on this page
Hide my e-mail on my post

Season Index

Copyright © 1994-2015, Jamahl Epsicokhan. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction or distribution of any review or article on this site is prohibited. Star Trek (in all its myriad forms), Battlestar Galactica, and Gene Roddenberry's Andromeda are trademarks of CBS Studios Inc., NBC Universal, and Tribune Entertainment, respectively. This site is in no way affiliated with or authorized by any of those companies. | Copyright & Disclaimer